When Lincoln died, Reconstruction passed into the hands of a very different man. Andrew Johnson of Tennessee had been a tailor who taught himself to read with help from his wife and rose through Democratic politics as a champion of poor white farmers. He was the only senator from a seceding state who stayed loyal to the Union, which is why Lincoln chose him as running mate in 1864. Johnson despised the planter aristocracy, but he also held firm views of white supremacy and a strict belief in states' rights. Those convictions shaped the eight months between his inauguration in April 1865 and the meeting of Congress in December, a period called Presidential Reconstruction.
Johnson's plan
On 29 May 1865 Johnson offered amnesty and the return of property, except slaves, to most former Confederates who swore an oath of loyalty. Certain groups were excluded, including high Confederate officials and anyone owning taxable property worth more than $20,000, who had to apply to the president personally for a pardon. Johnson then granted pardons by the thousands, often to the very planters he claimed to scorn. He appointed provisional governors and asked the Southern states only to abolish slavery, repudiate their Confederate war debts and declare secession void. He required nothing about Black voting, which he insisted was a matter for each state.
The land is taken back
Johnson also ordered abandoned and confiscated land returned to pardoned owners. In October 1865 the head of the Freedmen's Bureau, General Oliver Otis Howard, went to Edisto Island in South Carolina to tell freed families that the land they had settled under Sherman's order would go back to its former owners. The islanders wrote a petition protesting that they were being asked to work for the very men who had held them in bondage. Most of the land was returned anyway. For many freed people this was the moment when the promise of independence first slipped away.
The Black Codes
Under Johnson's terms, Southern voters elected legislatures dominated by former Confederates. In late 1865 these bodies, starting with Mississippi and South Carolina, passed laws known as Black Codes. The codes recognized some rights, such as marriage and the ability to own property and to sue in court. But their main purpose was to force freed people back into plantation labor. Mississippi required Black workers to hold written evidence of employment for the coming year. Vagrancy laws let authorities arrest Black people without work and hire them out to anyone who paid their fines. Apprenticeship laws allowed courts to bind Black children to employers, often their former owners, sometimes over the parents' objections. South Carolina demanded special licenses for Black people who wanted any work other than farming or domestic service.
Southern voters also sent former Confederate leaders to Washington. Georgia chose Alexander Stephens, the Confederacy's vice president, for the Senate. To many Northerners it looked as if the South had lost the war but was winning the peace. Republicans who had expected gratitude and repentance saw defiance instead, and many who had once trusted Johnson began to doubt him.
The case for Johnson, and against
Johnson's defenders argued that the Constitution left voting rules to the states, that the Southern states had never legally left the Union and so deserved prompt return, and that harsh terms would breed lasting bitterness. Quick reunion, they said, was the surest way to heal the nation. Critics answered that leniency simply handed power back to the planters, who used it to rebuild slavery in all but name. They pointed to the codes, to violence against freed people, and to the return of Confederate leaders as proof that the South was not ready to accept the results of the war.
Violence strengthened the critics' case. In May 1866 white mobs, many of them police, attacked Black residents in Memphis, killing dozens and burning homes, churches and schools. In July a white mob that included police attacked a mostly Black gathering at a convention in New Orleans, killing dozens more. The Memphis and New Orleans riots of 1866 convinced many Northern voters that Johnson's approach had failed.
Worked example: one man under a Black Code
Consider an imagined freedman in Mississippi early in 1866. He has left the plantation where he was enslaved, hoping to find better pay in a nearby town. In January he has not yet signed a contract for the year. Under the vagrancy law, a local officer can arrest him as a vagrant. A court fines him. He cannot pay, so the court hires him out to whoever will cover the fine, and the highest bidder may well be his former owner.
Trace what has happened. No law says he is enslaved. He has the right to marry and to own property. Yet a chain of rules about contracts, vagrancy and fines has carried him back to the same fields under the same master, now with the backing of the state. The example shows why Republicans in Congress decided that abolishing slavery was not enough. Freedom needed a definition, and someone would have to enforce it.
