Skip to main content

Much of the race debate asks what race is from the outside, as a scientist or a census taker might. Two thinkers changed the angle. Frantz Fanon asked what race is like from the inside, as it is lived. Charles Mills asked what race has done to political philosophy itself.

Fanon and the look

Fanon was a psychiatrist from Martinique who studied in France. In Black Skin, White Masks (1952) he described walking in a French city when a white child pointed at him, called out a racial label and told his mother he was afraid. In that moment, Fanon writes, his ordinary sense of his own body, moving easily through the world, broke apart. He found himself fixed by the gaze of others, made into an object loaded with stories about cannibals, savagery and sexual danger that he had never chosen. Fanon described himself as overdetermined, defined in advance by others' images before he could act or speak. The chapter describing this is often called "The Fact of Blackness," but a newer translation renders the chapter title as "The Lived Experience of the Black Man," closer to the French and to Fanon's aim of describing experience.

Making inferiority skin-deep

Fanon used the word epidermalization for the way social and economic domination comes to be felt as a fact about the skin. By epidermalization Fanon meant inferiority becoming felt as a fact of one's own skin, so that colonized people may come to see themselves through the colonizer's eyes. He also challenged allies. Jean-Paul Sartre had praised the Black poetry movement known as negritude as a stage in a larger historical process that would end in a raceless future. Fanon felt that Sartre's praise robbed Black people of their own experience by treating it as a step toward something else. Fanon objected that Sartre treated negritude as a mere passing stage in history. Later philosophers, such as George Yancy, have extended Fanon's method by describing ordinary scenes, like a white woman tightening her grip on her purse when a Black man enters an elevator, and asking what such gestures assume.

Fanon's book is not only a record of injury. It ends with a short prayer in which he asks his own body to make him, always, someone who questions. The closing note is a refusal to let either the racist's image or a defensive counter-image have the last word, and a claim to the freedom to keep asking.

The Racial Contract

Charles Mills, a philosopher raised in Jamaica, turned to the great texts of modern political thought. Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau and Kant described a social contract among free and equal persons. In The Racial Contract (1997), Mills argued that the real contract was a domination contract: a set of formal and informal agreements that counted white people as full persons and treated others as less, justifying conquest, slavery and segregation. White supremacy, he argued, was itself a political system, though textbooks rarely named it as one.

Mills added a claim about knowledge. Mills's "epistemology of ignorance" is a structured pattern of not knowing that protects the beneficiaries of racial injustice. People can fail, systematically and comfortably, to see how the world they benefit from was made.

Critics and later turns

Critics say the contract metaphor suggests a conscious conspiracy that never happened, and that it lumps together very different people as "signatories." Liberal philosophers answer that the ideals of equal rights in Locke and Kant were exactly what abolitionists and civil rights leaders appealed to, so the fault lay in failing to apply the theory, not in the theory. Mills partly agreed. In later work Mills defended a "Black radical liberalism" that keeps liberal ideals of rights and equality while correcting their racial blind spots. The debate over Kant is similar. Pauline Kleingeld has argued that Kant revised his racial views in the 1790s, when he condemned colonial conquest, while others doubt the change went deep.

Worked example: Locke and America

John Locke's Second Treatise of Government (1689) says people gain property in land by mixing their labor with it, and that unimproved land is waste. "Thus in the beginning all the world was America," he wrote, picturing America as a commons waiting for cultivation. Read with Mills, the passage takes on new meaning. Native peoples hunted, fished, burned and farmed the land, yet Locke's framework allowed English settlers to treat it as empty and to claim it by fencing and plowing. Locke also held shares in the Royal African Company, which traded in enslaved people, and he served as secretary to the proprietors of the Carolina colony, whose Fundamental Constitutions of 1669 gave every freeman "absolute power and authority over his negro slaves." A defender of Locke can reply that his principles of consent and natural rights condemn slavery, and that later abolitionists used them that way. Mills's challenge is to ask why a philosopher so clear about freedom found so many ways to make exceptions.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Fanon mean in calling himself overdetermined?
2. How does a newer translation render Fanon's famous chapter title?
3. What did Fanon mean by epidermalization?
4. What did Fanon object to in Sartre's praise of negritude?
5. What did Mills argue the real social contract was?
6. What is Mills's epistemology of ignorance?
7. What did Mills defend in later work?
8. What has Pauline Kleingeld argued about Kant?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia