Skip to main content

Loyalists and critics

The fall of the Ming forced a generation of scholars to ask why their world had collapsed. Many refused to serve the Qing and spent their lives writing instead. Huang Zongxi, in a book finished in 1663 and usually called Waiting for the Dawn, argued that rulers existed for the people, not the people for rulers, and that much of the misery of the past came from emperors treating the realm as their private property. He also proposed that schools should be places where officials and scholars openly debated government policy, a check on the throne. Gu Yanwu, another loyalist, traveled widely and urged scholars to study practical matters such as geography, waterworks and taxes rather than abstract speculation. These books circulated quietly for two centuries and were rediscovered with excitement by reformers in the 1890s.

Evidential learning

In the eighteenth century the most admired scholars practiced what they called evidential learning. They compared ancient texts, studied the sounds and meanings of old words, checked inscriptions on bronzes and stones, and tried to recover what the classics had really said before centuries of commentary.

The movement's most famous result came from Yan Ruoju (1636 to 1704). Through decades of comparison he showed that twenty-five chapters of the Book of Documents were later forgeries, though they had been studied for over a thousand years as words of the sage kings.

The philosopher Dai Zhen (1724 to 1777) carried the critical spirit into ethics. He attacked the way officials and elders invoked an abstract "principle" to override ordinary human feelings and needs, arguing that people could be crushed in the name of principle as surely as by harsh laws.

Novels and tales

Qing fiction produced works still read everywhere in China. Pu Songling (1640 to 1715), who failed the provincial examinations again and again, spent decades collecting and writing nearly five hundred short pieces published after his death as Strange Tales from a Chinese Studio. They are stories of ghosts, fox spirits and the uncanny, often with a sharp edge of satire against corrupt officials and the examination system.

The greatest Qing novel is The Story of the Stone, also known as Dream of the Red Chamber. Its author, Cao Xueqin, grew up in a family that had been close to the Kangxi emperor and grew rich in imperial service, then lost everything when its property was confiscated in 1728. The novel follows a great household's slow decline through the eyes of a sensitive young heir and the brilliant young women around him. Cao circulated it in manuscript, unfinished, with comments by family members. Only in 1791 was it first printed in 120 chapters, with an ending of uncertain authorship supplied by its editors. Whether the last forty chapters follow Cao's plan remains one of the great questions of Chinese literature.

Painting and theater

Painting split in two directions. Orthodox masters at court and among the elite followed earlier models closely. Others, often loyal to the memory of the Ming, painted in strange and personal styles. The most striking was Bada Shanren, a descendant of the Ming imperial family who became a monk and painted birds and fish with glaring, sideways eyes. At court, the Jesuit Giuseppe Castiglione blended European perspective and shading with Chinese brushwork in portraits and horse paintings for three emperors.

Theater thrived in cities, temple fairs and the homes of the rich. In 1790 troupes from Anhui came to Beijing for Qianlong's eightieth birthday, and their style, later combined with tunes from Hubei, grew into what the world now calls Peking opera.

Women writers

The eighteenth century saw more published women writers than any earlier age in China. Many wrote poetry, compiled anthologies of women's verse and corresponded across provinces. The poet and critic Yuan Mei (1716 to 1798) took women as poetry students and published their work, which scandalized some contemporaries and delighted others.

Worked example: how do you prove a forgery?

Yan Ruoju's case against the Old Text chapters shows how evidence can overturn tradition. He used three kinds of argument. First, citations. Early writers who quoted the Book of Documents did not quote the disputed chapters, or quoted versions of passages that differed from them, which suggests those chapters did not exist in that form when the early writers read the work. Second, history of the text. Records said the original old-script chapters had been lost long before the version that later circulated, so the surviving version had a suspicious origin. Third, internal clues. Some passages borrowed lines from later works or used ideas and phrases out of place for their supposed age, much as a letter "from" a medieval king that used modern slang would give itself away.

No single point settled the matter. Together, piled up over 128 sections, they made the case overwhelming. Some scholars resisted, because the forged chapters contained cherished passages on the mind and the Way. That reaction is worth noticing. Evidence can be strong and still meet resistance when it threatens beliefs people care about, and part of a careful thinker's training is learning to weigh the evidence apart from the comfort of the conclusion.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Huang Zongxi propose that schools should be?
2. What did Yan Ruoju show about the Book of Documents?
3. What did Dai Zhen argue about appeals to principle?
4. What are Pu Songling's Strange Tales mostly about?
5. How was Dream of the Red Chamber first printed in 1791?
6. Who was the painter Bada Shanren?
7. What happened in 1790 that helped give rise to Peking opera?
8. What did Yuan Mei do that scandalized some of his contemporaries?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia