Skip to main content

When an assassin killed President McKinley in September 1901, the presidency passed to Theodore Roosevelt, who at 42 remains the youngest person to hold the office. Roosevelt believed that the federal government had to become stronger than any private interest, not to destroy big business but to make it answer to the public. Over the next two decades, under Roosevelt, William Howard Taft and Woodrow Wilson, the federal government took on powers it had never held before.

Roosevelt's Square Deal

Roosevelt promised a "square deal" for capital and labor alike. In 1902, anthracite coal miners in Pennsylvania struck for higher pay and shorter hours, and as winter approached the nation faced a fuel shortage. Roosevelt brought owners and union leaders to the White House and pushed them to accept arbitration, hinting he might have the army run the mines. The commission awarded the miners a ten percent raise and a shorter day, though not union recognition. It marked a break with earlier presidents, who had sent troops to break strikes rather than broker a settlement.

Roosevelt distinguished between good trusts, which served the public, and bad ones, which abused their power, and he pursued the second kind in court. He also strengthened regulation. The Hepburn Act of 1906 gave the Interstate Commerce Commission power to set maximum railroad rates. The same year Congress passed laws on meat inspection and on pure food and drugs. Roosevelt rallied support for each measure from what he called the bully pulpit, the presidency's power to persuade the public directly.

His deepest passion was conservation. With his chief forester, Gifford Pinchot, Roosevelt set aside vast national forests, managed for long-term use rather than quick sale. Under the Antiquities Act of 1906 he could protect sites by proclamation, and he named Devils Tower in Wyoming the first national monument. By the time he left office, Roosevelt had placed roughly 230 million acres of public land under some form of federal protection. Conservationists like Pinchot, who wanted resources used wisely, clashed with preservationists like John Muir, who wanted wild places left untouched.

Taft and the Republican split

Taft, Roosevelt's chosen successor, was a cautious lawyer who actually brought more antitrust suits in four years than Roosevelt had in nearly eight. But he angered progressives by signing a tariff they thought too high, and he fired Pinchot in 1910 after Pinchot publicly attacked Taft's interior secretary over the handling of public lands. Roosevelt returned from an African safari, grew estranged from his old friend, and challenged him for the 1912 nomination. When party leaders gave it to Taft, Roosevelt's followers formed the Progressive Party, nicknamed the Bull Moose Party after Roosevelt said he felt as strong as one.

Wilson's New Freedom

Wilson, a former Princeton president and governor of New Jersey, won in 1912 promising a New Freedom that would restore competition. Once in office, he presided over a burst of lawmaking. The Sixteenth Amendment, ratified in 1913, allowed a federal income tax, and the Underwood Tariff of that year used one to replace revenue lost by lowering tariffs. The Seventeenth Amendment, also of 1913, required the direct election of senators, who had been chosen by state legislatures. The Federal Reserve Act of 1913 created a system of twelve regional reserve banks under a central board, meant to provide a more flexible currency and to prevent the bank panics that had struck in 1893 and 1907.

In 1914 Congress created the Federal Trade Commission to police unfair business practices and passed the Clayton Act, which Gompers hailed as labor's Magna Carta because it said labor was not a commodity. Courts later read its protections for unions narrowly. As the election of 1916 approached, Wilson moved toward Roosevelt's ideas, backing farm credit, a child labor law and the Adamson Act, which gave railroad workers an eight-hour day. The Supreme Court struck down the child labor law in 1918.

Worked example: four choices in 1912

The election of 1912 offered voters an unusually clear menu. Roosevelt's New Nationalism accepted big corporations as a fact of modern life and called for a powerful federal government to regulate them, along with social insurance, a minimum wage for women and the recall of some judicial decisions. Wilson, advised by Brandeis, argued that bigness itself was the danger and that government should break up monopolies and restore a market of small competitors. Taft defended the Constitution and the courts against what he saw as dangerous experiments. Eugene Debs, running for the Socialist Party, called for public ownership of major industries.

The results show how much the country had shifted. Wilson won with about 42 percent of the popular vote, Roosevelt took about 27 percent, the incumbent Taft about 23 percent and Debs about 6 percent, the best showing the Socialists ever achieved. Roughly three quarters of voters chose a candidate who called himself a reformer or something further left. The debate between regulating big organizations and breaking them up was not settled in 1912, and it returns whenever a new industry grows large enough to worry the public.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did Roosevelt handle the anthracite coal strike of 1902?
2. What power did the Hepburn Act of 1906 give the Interstate Commerce Commission?
3. Which site did Roosevelt name the first national monument?
4. Why did Taft fire Gifford Pinchot in 1910?
5. Where did the Bull Moose Party get its nickname?
6. What did the Sixteenth Amendment of 1913 allow?
7. What did the Federal Reserve Act of 1913 create?
8. What did the Adamson Act of 1916 give railroad workers?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia