Skip to main content

In the summer of 1877, with the country four years into a severe depression, the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad announced a ten percent wage cut. Workers at Martinsburg, West Virginia, stopped the trains, beginning the Great Railroad Strike of 1877, which spread within days to Baltimore, Pittsburgh, Chicago and St. Louis. Crowds burned rail yards in Pittsburgh. President Rutherford Hayes sent federal troops, and by the time the strike collapsed about a hundred people had died. It was the first nationwide strike in American history, and it announced that industrial conflict would be one of the defining features of the age.

Why workers organized

Industrial workers faced long hours, frequent injuries and no unemployment insurance, pensions or compensation for accidents. Wages could be cut at will, and depressions in the 1870s and 1890s threw hundreds of thousands out of work. Many workers also feared a loss of independence. A skilled craftsman who once set his own pace now worked under a foreman in a factory, and many Americans worried that permanent wage labor was incompatible with the republican ideal of free and equal citizens. Child labor was common too: the 1900 census counted about 1.75 million children aged ten to fifteen at work, many of them in mills, mines and street trades.

The Knights of Labor

The first great national labor organization was the Noble and Holy Order of the Knights of Labor, founded in 1869. Under Terence Powderly it grew quickly in the 1880s. The Knights welcomed skilled and unskilled workers, women and Black workers into one organization, and they aimed at more than wages: their goal was a cooperative commonwealth in which workers would own businesses together. Yet their idea of solidarity had limits. They barred bankers, lawyers and liquor dealers, and they supported the exclusion of Chinese immigrants. In 1885 a successful strike against railroads controlled by the financier Jay Gould drew new members in a rush, and the Knights reached about 700,000 by 1886.

Haymarket and its aftermath

On 1 May 1886 hundreds of thousands of workers across the country struck or marched for an eight-hour day. In Chicago, police killed workers at the McCormick reaper plant two days later, and anarchists called a protest meeting at Haymarket Square for 4 May. As police moved to break up the dwindling crowd, someone threw a bomb. Police fired, and officers and civilians died in the chaos. Eight anarchists were convicted although no evidence tied them to the bomb, and four were hanged. In 1893 Illinois governor John Peter Altgeld pardoned the three still in prison, condemning the trial as unfair, and was denounced for it. Haymarket unleashed a wave of fear about radicals and immigrants, and the Knights, though not involved, declined rapidly.

A different model survived. Samuel Gompers led the American Federation of Labor, founded in 1886, which organized skilled workers by craft and focused on wages, hours and conditions rather than remaking society. Critics called this narrow, since it left out most unskilled, women and immigrant workers. Gompers replied that it worked, and the AFL outlasted every rival of the era.

Homestead and Pullman

Two great defeats in the 1890s showed how much power stood against labor. At Carnegie's Homestead steelworks in 1892, manager Henry Clay Frick locked out the union. On 6 July about three hundred Pinkerton guards arrived by barge and were driven back by armed workers in a battle that killed both strikers and guards. The governor sent the state militia, the plant reopened with replacement workers, and the union was broken. Skilled steelworkers would not win union recognition again for more than forty years.

In 1894 George Pullman, who made railroad sleeping cars, cut wages by about a quarter in his company town near Chicago without lowering the rents he charged his workers. The new American Railway Union, led by Eugene V. Debs, refused to handle trains carrying Pullman cars, and rail traffic stopped across much of the country. The federal government obtained a court injunction against the strike, and President Cleveland sent troops to Chicago over the governor's protest. Debs went to jail for contempt, and in 1895 the Supreme Court upheld the injunction. Debs read socialist writings in his cell and emerged as the country's best known socialist.

Worked example: seeing Homestead from three sides

Picture three accounts of 6 July 1892. A striker sees men defending homes they had bought near the mill and jobs they had helped make productive, against a private army hired to replace them. Frick sees property owners exercising the right to run their own plant and to hire whom they choose, facing a mob that fired on lawful guards. A state official sees a breakdown of public order that only the government can end. Each view rests on a principle Americans valued: the dignity of labor, the rights of property and the duty of the state to keep the peace. In practice the state sided with property, and the question of whether workers had a right to organize was left for a later generation to settle.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where did the Great Railroad Strike of 1877 begin?
2. Which statement about membership in the Knights of Labor is accurate?
3. What was the larger goal of the Knights of Labor?
4. What happened to the eight anarchists convicted after Haymarket?
5. What did Illinois governor Altgeld do in 1893?
6. How did the American Federation of Labor organize workers?
7. Who arrived by barge at Homestead on 6 July 1892?
8. How did the federal government respond to the Pullman boycott in 1894?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia