Skip to main content

Can it ever be right to believe something before the evidence is in? In 1877 the English mathematician W. K. Clifford said no, and he said it memorably. In "The Ethics of Belief" he told of a shipowner who sent an old emigrant ship to sea after talking himself out of his doubts about its soundness. The ship sank with everyone aboard. Clifford concluded: "It is wrong always, everywhere, and for any one, to believe anything upon insufficient evidence."

Genuine options

William James answered in an 1896 lecture, "The Will to Believe." He did not defend believing whatever you like. He tried to mark out a narrow class of cases where Clifford's rule fails. Call a decision between two hypotheses an option. Options can be living or dead, forced or avoidable, and momentous or trivial. A live option is one where both choices seem genuinely possible to you. A forced option is one where there is no third way; not choosing is itself a choice. A momentous option is unique, high in stakes, and hard to reverse. A genuine option, in James's sense, is one that is live, forced and momentous.

James then argued that when a genuine option cannot be settled on intellectual grounds, our passional nature may, and must, decide it. "Passional nature" meant our hopes, fears, loyalties and will. Refusing to decide is no escape, since in a forced option it amounts to deciding against. Clifford's rule, James said, reflects one passion among others: a horror of being duped. James preferred to risk error for the chance of truth.

Faith that helps create the fact

James's strongest examples came from human relations. Will someone like me? If I wait for proof before acting friendly, I may never get it, because my coldness helps produce the dislike I feared. James wrote that in such cases "faith in a fact can help create the fact." A team, a business or a democracy works only if many people trust that others will do their part. A mountaineer facing a leap across a chasm, he wrote elsewhere, may succeed only if confidence steadies the leg.

Critics accept these cases but doubt they reach as far as James wanted, especially to religion. Belief that creates its own fact is special; God's existence, if real, does not depend on our trust. James later suggested that a better title would have been "The Right to Believe".

By their fruits

James's Gifford Lectures in Edinburgh, published as The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902), carried the pragmatic method into religion. He collected first-person reports of conversion, mystical states and saintly lives, treating them as data. Against those who dismissed religion as nothing but the product of a disordered body or brain, he argued that origins do not settle value. Religious experience, he said, should be judged "by their fruits," not by their roots: by what it does in people's lives. Many saints, he noted, showed remarkable courage, charity and calm; some religion also produced fanaticism and cruelty, which the same test condemns.

A certain blindness

In "On a Certain Blindness in Human Beings" (1899), James described a journey through the mountains of North Carolina. He passed clearings where settlers had cut down the forest, left stumps standing and planted corn between them. To him the scene looked like pure ugliness. Then a mountaineer explained that the clearings meant a family's labor, safety and hope. James realized he had been blind to the inner significance that other people's lives hold for them. The essay ends with a plea for tolerance: we should be slow to judge, and should respect the ways others find meaning, as long as they do not harm others.

This links to James's pluralism, the view that reality is not one seamless whole but many partly connected things and perspectives. In A Pluralistic Universe (1909) he argued against philosophers who saw the world as a single block in which every detail is fixed by the whole. A plural world leaves room for real novelty, real choice and real risk.

Worked example: joining the founding board

A volunteer is asked to join the founding board of a new community health clinic in a neighborhood without one. Funding is uncertain. If enough capable people commit, the clinic will probably open; if not, it will fail. Our volunteer cannot know in advance which will happen.

Apply James's test. The option is live: both joining and declining seem reasonable. It is forced: declining is a choice that weakens the project. It is momentous: the chance may not come again, and lives may depend on it. Evidence alone cannot settle whether the clinic will succeed, partly because the outcome depends on whether people like her believe in it. James would say she may let hope and commitment decide.

Clifford's warning still applies to the parts evidence can settle. The board should not believe the building is safe or the budget sound without checking, as the shipowner did. James's "certain blindness" adds another duty: board members from outside the neighborhood should ask residents what a clinic would mean to them, rather than assuming they already know.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did James say Clifford's rule reflects?
2. What makes an option genuine in James's sense?
3. When may our passional nature decide, according to James?
4. Which example fits James's claim that faith in a fact can help create the fact?
5. How did James say religious experience should be judged in Varieties?
6. What did James realize on his journey in North Carolina?
7. What is James's pluralism?
8. Which title did James later suggest would have been better?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia