Skip to main content

In the early 1870s a handful of young men in Cambridge, Massachusetts, began meeting in one another's studies to argue about philosophy. They called their group, half as a joke, the Metaphysical Club. It left no minutes and lasted only a few years. Yet a way of thinking took shape in those rooms that became the best known philosophy ever to come out of the United States: pragmatism, the view that the meaning and worth of an idea lie in the practical difference it makes.

Who was in the room

The two members who mattered most for philosophy were Charles Sanders Peirce, a brilliant and difficult scientist who worked for the United States Coast Survey, and his friend William James, then a young instructor in physiology at Harvard. Alongside them sat the lawyer Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., later a justice of the United States Supreme Court, and Chauncey Wright, a gifted critic of grand philosophical systems who earned his living computing tables for a nautical almanac.

Another member, the lawyer Nicholas St. John Green, kept urging the others to take seriously a definition from the Scottish psychologist Alexander Bain. Bain had described belief as that upon which a person is prepared to act. Peirce later recalled that pragmatism followed almost directly from this idea. If a belief is a readiness to act, then two beliefs that would lead to exactly the same actions in every possible situation are not really two beliefs at all.

After the war

Why did this outlook appear then and there? The historian Louis Menand, in a prize-winning book on the club published in 2001, pointed to the Civil War. Holmes had been shot three times as a Union officer. Menand argued that the war convinced many of this generation that certainty was dangerous: people sure they had absolute truth on their side had been willing to kill for it. A philosophy that treated ideas as tools to be tested, revised and shared looked like a safeguard against that kind of fanaticism.

The thesis is debated. Peirce and James were driven at least as much by science, especially Darwin. The Origin of Species (1859) suggested that even living forms were not fixed but had changed through chance and selection, and the pragmatists asked whether ideas, too, might be better understood as things that grow, compete and adapt, rather than as copies of eternal truths. Either way, pragmatism began as an attempt to think honestly in a world without guaranteed foundations.

The law as experience

Holmes carried the club's attitude into law. His book The Common Law (1881) opens with a famous line: "The life of the law has not been logic: it has been experience." He meant that legal rules are not deduced from first principles like theorems in geometry. They grow out of the needs, beliefs and even prejudices of each period, and judges adjust them, often without admitting it.

In a later lecture, "The Path of the Law" (1897), Holmes went further. If you want to know what the law is, he said, look at it the way a "bad man" would, someone who cares only about what will actually happen to him. From that angle, the law is a set of predictions about what courts will in fact do. This was pragmatism applied: the meaning of a legal rule is found in its consequences.

A name goes public

For a quarter century the word stayed mostly private. Then in 1898 William James gave a lecture at the University of California in Berkeley called "Philosophical Conceptions and Practical Results." There James publicly introduced the word pragmatism and credited the principle to Peirce. The name came from the Greek pragma, meaning an act or deed, the same root that gives us practice and practical.

Within a decade pragmatism was the most talked about philosophy in the English-speaking world.

Worked example: two neighbors and a fence

Two neighbors are arguing over whether the fence between their gardens is "really" on the boundary. One cites an old deed and says the line was meant to follow a stream that has since moved. The other cites a survey from twenty years ago.

A member of the Metaphysical Club would ask a simple question: what practical difference turns on the answer? Perhaps it matters for who must repair the fence, who may plant beside it, or what a buyer will be told. Once those questions are named, the dispute becomes something that can be settled by a court, a new survey or a written agreement. The neighbors' general argument about which piece of paper reveals the true line may never be settled. The practical questions can be.

Holmes would add that, if they went to court, the meaning of their rights would be whatever the judge would in fact decide, which depends on precedent, evidence and the judge's sense of fairness. Bain's definition fits too. Each neighbor's belief about the boundary shows itself in what they are ready to do: build, sue, or let the matter drop. Pragmatism does not say the boundary question is meaningless. It says a question becomes clear when we trace what would follow from each answer.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the Metaphysical Club's members later call the view that an idea's meaning and worth lie in its practical difference?
2. Which member of the Metaphysical Club later became a justice of the US Supreme Court?
3. How did Alexander Bain define belief, in the idea Green urged on the club?
4. According to Holmes in The Common Law, what has the life of the law been?
5. What did Holmes say the law is, seen from the viewpoint of the bad man?
6. What did James do in his 1898 Berkeley lecture?
7. What did The Origin of Species suggest that interested the pragmatists?
8. On the pragmatist approach, how does a question become clear?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia