Skip to main content

In the spring of 1996 the journal Social Text published an article by the New York University physicist Alan Sokal titled "Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity." Weeks later Sokal revealed in another magazine that the article was a parody, stuffed with nonsense about physics dressed in fashionable theory. Sokal's hoax was meant to show that a cultural studies journal would publish nonsense that flattered its politics. The journal did not use outside peer review at the time, which its defenders stressed. The episode still became a symbol of everything critics disliked about postmodern theory.

Sokal and Bricmont

In 1997 Sokal and the Belgian physicist Jean Bricmont published a book, issued in English the next year as Fashionable Nonsense, that collected passages in which French theorists such as Jacques Lacan, Julia Kristeva and Baudrillard used terms from mathematics and physics loosely or wrongly. Sokal and Bricmont argued that several famous theorists misused scientific concepts to lend their writing authority. They were careful to say this did not refute every idea those authors had. Defenders replied that metaphor is not a crime, and that Foucault and Derrida were barely touched by the charge.

Habermas: an unfinished project

A more searching criticism came from the German philosopher Jürgen Habermas. In September 1980, accepting the Adorno Prize in Frankfurt, he gave a lecture titled "Modernity: An Unfinished Project." Habermas argued that modernity is an unfinished project to be completed, not abandoned. The Enlightenment's failures, he said, came from reason applied too narrowly, as a tool for control and profit, not from reason itself. He provocatively grouped the French critics with conservatives, since they gave up the hope of reforming society by reasoned argument.

In The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity (1985) he examined Nietzsche, Heidegger, Derrida and Foucault in turn. His central charge was logical. Habermas charged that total critics of reason fall into a performative contradiction, using reason's tools to argue that reason cannot be trusted. A performative contradiction occurs when the act of making a claim conflicts with its content, as when someone says aloud, "I am not speaking." A book that argues carefully that argument is only power in disguise asks its readers to accept what it says on the strength of argument.

Description without standards

The American philosopher Nancy Fraser, broadly sympathetic to Foucault, put a related objection in a 1981 essay. Fraser argued that Foucault could describe domination brilliantly but could not say why it is wrong. His histories are full of moral energy. Yet if every norm is just another product of power, the reader is left asking why resistance is better than submission. Answering requires some standard, such as freedom, dignity or the avoidance of suffering, that the theory seemed to rule out.

Relativism and post-truth

The broadest criticism is that these ideas lead to relativism, the view that no belief is truer than any other. Most of the thinkers met here denied being relativists, and the claim that all truth is relative undermines itself, since it presents itself as true. But ideas travel. In 2004 the French sociologist of science Bruno Latour, whose own work had shown how laboratories build facts, published an essay of second thoughts. Latour worried that critique's tools for exposing how facts are built had been taken up by those manufacturing doubt about climate science.

The way out is a distinction. That facts are made through human practices, instruments, measurements and arguments, is true of every scientific fact. That facts are therefore arbitrary does not follow. A bridge is built too, and that is why it holds.

What remains

Several lasting gains survive the criticism: attention to whose voices a debate leaves out, histories of the categories we sort people by, suspicion of official stories, and the habit of reading closely. A balanced verdict keeps the suspicion of claimed certainties while defending the standards of evidence that make criticism possible. Human rights need both halves. Suspicion exposes the stories the powerful tell to excuse cruelty. Standards let us name cruelty as wrong for everyone, everywhere.

Worked example: "just a narrative"

A government spokesman is shown satellite images of a burned village. He shrugs: everyone has a narrative, and this is merely theirs. Each figure gives the journalist a tool. Habermas would point out that the spokesman is himself making a truth claim, that his side's story is the better one, and should be asked for evidence like anyone else. Foucault's genealogical suspicion applies to official narratives at least as much as to anyone's; who benefits from the claim that no account can be trusted? Latour would note that the images are constructed, by satellites, analysts and cross-checking, and that their construction is what makes them strong. Rorty would urge telling the villagers' story so that distant readers recognize them as people like themselves.

The lesson is that these tools cut both ways. Used carefully, they help the weak question the powerful. Used carelessly, they hand the powerful a way to dismiss the weak. Knowing the difference is the point of studying them.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was Sokal's hoax meant to show?
2. What did Sokal and Bricmont argue in Fashionable Nonsense?
3. What did Habermas argue in his 1980 Adorno Prize lecture?
4. What did Habermas charge total critics of reason with?
5. What did Nancy Fraser argue about Foucault?
6. Why does the claim that all truth is relative undermine itself?
7. What did Latour worry about in his 2004 essay?
8. What does a balanced verdict on postmodern thought keep, according to the level?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia