Skip to main content

Jean Baudrillard's Simulacra and Simulation (1981) opens with an epigraph credited to the Book of Ecclesiastes, declaring in effect that the copy is true and that truth hides the fact that there is none. No such verse exists. Baudrillard wrote it himself. A book about copies without originals begins with a citation without a source.

Copies without originals

Baudrillard (1929 to 2007) was a French sociologist who became one of the most quoted theorists of media and consumer culture. His central term was the simulacrum. A simulacrum, in Baudrillard's sense, is a copy that no longer has an original. To explain, he retold a short fable by Borges about an empire whose mapmakers drew a map so detailed that it matched the territory point for point; later generations let it rot, and its tatters lay across the desert. Baudrillard reversed the fable. Today, he said, the map comes first and produces the territory, and it is reality whose scraps lie scattered across the map.

Four phases of the image

He described a history of images in four stages. First, the image reflects a basic reality, like a faithful portrait. Second, it masks and distorts reality, like propaganda. Third, it masks the absence of a reality, pretending there is something behind it when there is not. In the final phase, Baudrillard said, the image bears no relation to any reality at all; it is its own pure simulacrum.

Hyperreality

Hyperreality is a condition in which simulations come to seem more real than the reality they once copied. Baudrillard's favorite example was Disneyland. It presents itself as a fantasy world, and its visitors know it is fake. That very knowledge, he argued, reassures them that everything outside the gates is real. Baudrillard claimed Disneyland exists to make the rest of America seem real, when the suburbs, freeways and television around it are also built from images and models.

The Gulf War

Baudrillard's most notorious provocation came in 1991. In newspaper essays later collected as a book, he declared that the Gulf War did not take place. He did not deny that bombs fell. His claim was that the war reached Western publics as a televised spectacle of briefings, maps and footage from guided missiles, a one-sided operation staged for screens rather than a contest that viewers could grasp. Baudrillard argued that the 1991 Gulf War reached Western viewers mainly as a televised simulation. The British philosopher Christopher Norris replied in 1992 that this was a betrayal of the tens of thousands who died. If simulation swallows everything, how can anyone say that a government lied?

Jameson: the economics of style

The American critic Fredric Jameson approached the same phenomena from the left. In a 1984 essay, expanded into a 1991 book, Jameson interpreted postmodernism as the cultural logic of late, multinational capitalism. Postmodern style, in his view, was not a free choice of taste but what culture looks like when markets reach into every corner of life, including art, the unconscious and nature.

He listed its features: a new flatness or depthlessness, a weakening of historical sense, and a love of pastiche. Jameson described pastiche as blank parody: the imitation of past styles without satire or a norm to measure them against. Parody mocks a style from a standpoint. Pastiche wears old styles like costumes, because no standpoint remains. His most famous example was the Bonaventure Hotel in Los Angeles, finished in 1976, whose mirrored towers and confusing lobbies left visitors unable to find their bearings. For Jameson this disorientation mirrored our inability to map the global economy we live inside.

Notice the difference in tone. Baudrillard often sounded fascinated by simulation. Jameson described postmodern culture in order to criticize it, and he hoped that understanding it might help people regain a sense of history and of collective action.

Prophet or provocateur?

Admirers say Baudrillard anticipated reality television, curated online selves, deepfakes and politics staged for screens. Critics answer that his provocations outran his evidence and undercut the distinction between truth and propaganda that any critic of media needs. Both judgments can be true at once. A diagnosis can be vivid and exaggerated, and still help us see.

Worked example: a museum made for photos

In 2016 a pop-up called the Museum of Ice Cream opened in New York. It had no collection. Its rooms were pastel sets built to be photographed, including a pool filled with plastic sprinkles. Tickets sold out quickly, and the images spread across social media.

Read with Baudrillard, the museum is close to the final phase of the image. It copies no original; the scene exists for the pictures, and the visit seems fully real only once it has been posted. Read with Jameson, it is pastiche: a nostalgic childhood style borrowed without irony and sold as an experience, a product of an economy that now markets moments rather than objects. A fair reader adds one more thing. The visitors who laughed in the sprinkle pool had a real afternoon with real friends. The theory sharpens our sight, but it should not persuade us that nothing happened.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What is a simulacrum, in Baudrillard's sense?
2. What happens to the image in the final phase Baudrillard described?
3. What is hyperreality?
4. What did Baudrillard claim Disneyland exists to do?
5. What did Baudrillard argue about the 1991 Gulf War?
6. How did Fredric Jameson interpret postmodernism?
7. How did Jameson describe pastiche?
8. Which building did Jameson use as his most famous example of postmodern space?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia