Skip to main content

In the late 1970s the Council of Universities of Quebec commissioned a report from a French philosopher on the state of knowledge in the most developed societies. Jean-François Lyotard, who taught at the University of Paris VIII, delivered a short book in 1979 called The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge. It became one of the most cited philosophy books of its era.

Stories that justify

Lyotard began with a simple question: why should anyone accept a form of knowledge, fund it or teach it? Every kind of knowledge needs legitimation. Traditional societies, he said, legitimated knowledge through narratives, stories handed down that authorized themselves simply by being told. Modern science looked down on such stories as myth. Yet when science had to explain why it deserved support, it also turned to stories of its own.

Lyotard called the overarching stories that justify knowledge and politics metanarratives, or grand narratives. He identified two. The first is a story of emancipation, in which knowledge frees humanity; the second is a speculative story, in which all knowledge unites into one system. The emancipation story descends from the French Revolution: educate the people and they will govern themselves. The speculative story descends from German idealism, from Hegel and the University of Berlin founded under Wilhelm von Humboldt in 1810, where each science was to find its place in a single growing whole of knowledge.

Disbelief

Lyotard's best known sentence, paraphrased, defines the postmodern as disbelief toward such stories. For Lyotard, the postmodern condition is a growing distrust of metanarratives. They have not been refuted in a single argument. They have simply lost their grip. Lyotard pointed to history: Auschwitz, he wrote, mocked the Hegelian faith that the real is rational, and the Soviet camps mocked the promise that a scientific socialism would free the workers.

Language games

To describe what remained, Lyotard borrowed Wittgenstein's notion of language games. Making a scientific statement, giving an order, telling a joke, making a promise and asking a question are different games, each with its own rules for good moves. Society, on this view, is a crisscrossing web of many games played at once. Lyotard held that no single master language game could judge all the others. Science can tell us what is the case, but it cannot, by its own rules, tell us what is just.

Performativity

Without grand stories, what justifies research and teaching? Lyotard saw an answer already taking over, and he described it as a warning. Performativity is the rule that knowledge is justified by its efficiency, the best ratio of inputs to outputs. The question shifts from "Is it true?" to "What use is it?" and then to "Can it be sold?" Knowledge becomes a commodity produced to be exchanged. Writing as computers spread, Lyotard predicted that whatever could not be translated into data would be neglected, and that those who paid for research would decide what counted as knowledge.

Small stories and dissent

Lyotard did not welcome this. Against performativity he set two hopes. One was the little narrative, the local story of a community or a practice that makes no claim to speak for history as a whole. The other was paralogy, the search for new moves and instabilities that break an established consensus. Science, he argued, advances less by agreement than by dissent, by the move that nobody expected. For this reason he distrusted ideals of universal consensus, including the one defended by the German philosopher Jürgen Habermas, which he feared would smother difference.

In a later book, The Differend (1983), Lyotard sharpened the ethical point. A differend is a conflict that cannot be fairly settled because the parties lack a shared rule of judgment. A victim whose harm cannot be proved under a tribunal's rules of evidence suffers a second wrong: the injury becomes unspeakable in the only language available. Here the connection to human dignity is direct. Some injustices stay invisible because the forum has no words for them.

Criticism

The obvious objection is that "the end of grand narratives" sounds like a grand narrative about history. Lyotard's defenders reply that he described a mood rather than a law of history. A second objection cuts deeper. Universal human rights look like a grand narrative of emancipation. If we lose faith in all such stories, do we lose the strongest language the powerless have? Lyotard never abandoned justice, but critics doubted that little narratives could protect people against powerful states.

Worked example: saving a philosophy department

A university facing cuts proposes closing its philosophy department. Its defenders reach for justifications. One sounds like the emancipation story: philosophy forms free citizens who can think for themselves. Another sounds speculative: without philosophy the university is no longer a whole, only a collection of trades. The administration answers with a spreadsheet of graduate salaries and cost per student. That is performativity, exactly as Lyotard predicted.

His other ideas suggest a different defense. A department might justify itself by paralogy, by producing the dissent that keeps other fields honest. And some of what it offers may face a differend: its value cannot be stated in the spreadsheet's terms at all. The case does not prove the department should survive. It shows how the rules of the debate decide in advance what will count as a reason.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who commissioned Lyotard's report The Postmodern Condition?
2. What did Lyotard call the overarching stories that justify knowledge and politics?
3. Which two grand narratives did Lyotard identify?
4. How did Lyotard define the postmodern condition?
5. What did Lyotard hold about language games?
6. What is performativity, in Lyotard's sense?
7. What is paralogy?
8. What is a differend?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia