Skip to main content

The Romans called the Carthaginians Poeni, their version of the Greek word for Phoenicians, and from Poeni comes the word Punic. The three Punic Wars, fought between 264 and 146 BCE, are usually told as a Roman story of setbacks overcome. Seen from Carthage, they look like something else: a struggle by a merchant republic to keep its place in a world that a military state was remaking.

The first war: a contest at sea

The first war began in 264 BCE over Messana in Sicily and turned into a twenty-three-year struggle for the island. Carthage entered as the stronger naval power. Rome, with almost no navy, built fleets from scratch. The deciding blow came in 241 BCE, when a Roman fleet defeated the Carthaginians at the Aegates Islands off western Sicily. Hamilcar Barca, a Carthaginian commander who had never been beaten on land in Sicily, was told to make peace. Carthage agreed to leave the island and pay a large indemnity.

The Truceless War

Defeat brought a crisis at home. Mercenaries returning from Sicily rebelled when Carthage could not pay their wages in full, and they were joined by Libyan subjects who had been taxed hard to fund the war. The rising lasted from 241 to 237 BCE and was fought with such cruelty on both sides that Polybius called it the "truceless war." Hamilcar finally crushed the rebels.

While Carthage was still recovering, Rome took Sardinia and demanded more money under threat of a new war. Polybius, a historian who generally admired Rome, judged this seizure of Sardinia to be unjust, and he saw the bitterness it caused as one root of the next war.

The Barcid family in Spain

Hamilcar looked for new strength overseas. In 237 BCE he crossed to Spain, where Carthage already had old allies, and over the following years he and his family conquered much of the south and east, drawing on Spanish silver mines and Iberian soldiers. The Barcid family founded the city known today as Cartagena: Hamilcar's son-in-law Hasdrubal laid it out on the coast and gave it the same name as the mother city, Qart-hadasht. Hannibal took command in Spain in 221 BCE and two years later attacked Saguntum, a town that Rome counted as a friend. Rome declared war.

Hannibal's war from the home front

From Carthage, Hannibal's war looked different. The government in Africa had to defend Spain, Sardinia and Sicily as well as supply an army in Italy, and it sent most of its reinforcements to Spain, where the silver mines were. Hannibal's best hope of fresh troops was his brother. In 207 BCE Hasdrubal Barca led an army over the Alps to join Hannibal but was defeated and killed at the Metaurus River.

Hannibal was recalled to defend Africa and defeated in 202 BCE. The peace of 201 BCE was severe. Carthage had to pay ten thousand talents over fifty years, hand over its war elephants and cut its fleet to ten warships. Worst of all, Carthage could not make war without Rome's permission, even in Africa.

The last war

Carthage recovered its prosperity remarkably quickly and, according to Livy, even offered to pay off the indemnity early. Rome refused. Meanwhile Masinissa, the Numidian king and Rome's ally, seized Carthaginian land again and again, and Roman envoys sent to settle the disputes mostly found in his favor. The elderly senator Cato, struck by Carthage's wealth, is said by Plutarch to have ended his speeches on any subject by declaring that Carthage should be destroyed.

In 150 BCE Carthage finally fought back against Masinissa without asking Rome, breaking the treaty. Rome declared war. Carthage surrendered hostages and handed over vast stores of weapons and armor. Then the consuls announced the final demand: the Carthaginians must abandon their city and resettle inland, away from the sea. For a trading people it meant the end of everything. They refused and held out for three years. In 146 BCE Scipio Aemilianus broke in, the city was destroyed and the survivors, about fifty thousand according to ancient sources, were sold into slavery.

A popular story adds that the Romans sowed the ground with salt. No ancient source mentions salting Carthage's fields; the story is a modern invention, not found in any writer before recent centuries.

Worked example: Hannibal as suffete

Hannibal's career did not end in 202 BCE. In 196 BCE he was elected suffete and turned his energy on Carthage's own government. Members of the Hundred and Four then held office for life, and Livy says they had become arrogant and feared. Hannibal took a law to the popular assembly so that judges were chosen each year and could not serve two terms in a row. He then examined the public finances, found that officials had been embezzling revenue and showed that the indemnity to Rome could be paid without new taxes if the theft stopped.

The reforms won him the support of ordinary citizens and the hatred of the powerful. Accused by enemies of plotting with the Seleucid king Antiochus III, he fled east in 195 BCE. He spent his last years as an adviser to kings and took poison around 183 BCE rather than be handed to Rome. The episode shows that Carthage was a political community with real reformers and real conflicts of interest, not just a war machine.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where does the word Punic come from?
2. Which battle in 241 BCE ended the First Punic War?
3. What started the Truceless War of 241 to 237 BCE?
4. How did Polybius judge Rome's seizure of Sardinia?
5. Which city did the Barcid family found in Spain?
6. What happened to Hasdrubal Barca at the Metaurus River in 207 BCE?
7. Under the peace of 201 BCE, what could Carthage not do without Rome's permission?
8. What did Rome demand of the Carthaginians in 149 BCE that they refused?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia