Skip to main content

The 3 June Plan settled that Punjab and Bengal would be divided. It did not say where. That task went to a London lawyer working against a deadline he had not chosen, with maps and figures he had to take on trust.

The Radcliffe commissions

Cyril Radcliffe was a distinguished barrister. He had never been to India before, and that was the point: no side could say he was biased. He arrived on 8 July 1947 with about five weeks to work. There were two boundary commissions, one for Punjab and one for Bengal. Radcliffe chaired both, and each had four judges, two nominated by the Congress and two by the Muslim League. As expected, the judges split along party lines, so in practice Radcliffe decided.

His instructions were short. The commissions were told to demarcate the boundary by ascertaining the contiguous majority areas of Muslims and non-Muslims, while also taking account of "other factors". Those other factors were never defined. Lawyers for each side filled the gap with arguments about canals, railways, property, sacred sites and the economic unity of districts.

Punjab

Lahore, the provincial capital, had a Muslim majority but much of its property belonged to Hindus and Sikhs. It went to Pakistan. Amritsar, holy city of the Sikhs, went to India. Between them, villages a few kilometers apart were sorted by the census figures of their tehsil, a subdivision of a district.

The Sikhs were the hardest hit. They formed a majority in no district, so the principle of contiguous majorities gave them nothing of their own. Rich canal colonies farmed by Sikhs, and many Sikh shrines, went to Pakistan. Sikh leaders had pleaded that property, history and sacred sites should count as other factors, with little effect. Some of them prepared for war.

The Gurdaspur question

Gurdaspur district had a narrow Muslim majority. Radcliffe gave three of its four tehsils to India. The Gurdaspur award is controversial because it gave India a land route to Kashmir, the princely state whose future was still open. Pakistani writers have long argued that Mountbatten pressed Radcliffe to make the change. Radcliffe said he followed canal headworks and rail links. The evidence is suggestive but not conclusive, and historians remain divided.

Bengal

In Bengal, Calcutta, with its port and industry, went to India; the League had hoped for it. A last-minute proposal by Suhrawardy and the Congress leader Sarat Chandra Bose for a united, independent Bengal had failed in May. Radcliffe made trades on the edges. The Chittagong Hill Tracts, overwhelmingly non-Muslim, went to East Pakistan because they lay behind the port of Chittagong. Murshidabad, with a Muslim majority, went to India to protect the river serving Calcutta. Khulna, with a narrow Hindu majority, went to Pakistan.

The new line also left behind a strange legacy around Cooch Behar, a princely state that joined India: scores of tiny pockets of one country surrounded by the other, some even with pockets inside them. People living in these enclaves often lacked schools, police and papers for decades. India and Bangladesh finally resolved the enclaves by a land swap in 2015, and their residents chose their citizenship.

Publication

The awards were ready by 12 to 13 August. Mountbatten held them back. The boundary awards were published on 17 August 1947, two days after independence. Mountbatten argued that early release would have ruined the celebrations and left Britain responsible for the violence that followed. The result was that on independence day millions of people in border districts did not know which country they were in. In some towns crowds raised one flag and had to lower it days later. Radcliffe left India almost at once and is reported to have destroyed his papers.

Worked example: one district, three answers

Consider Gurdaspur through the instructions Radcliffe was given. On the principle of contiguous majorities, the district as a whole leaned Muslim, which points to Pakistan. But the district was not the only possible unit. Looked at tehsil by tehsil, the eastern tehsil of Pathankot had a non-Muslim majority, and the others had Muslim majorities so narrow that small shifts in the boundary of the unit could change the answer. Then add other factors: the headworks controlling the canals of the region, the railway to Pathankot, and the needs of Amritsar district next door.

Each choice of unit and factor produces a defensible line, and each line has winners and losers counted in hundreds of thousands. Applying the ideas of this level, notice that a rule that sounds neutral, majority areas, depends entirely on the unit chosen and on how much weight goes to the undefined extras. Boundary drawing is never just arithmetic, and the people on the ground are rarely asked. In Gurdaspur the line that resulted shaped not only a district but the war over Kashmir that began two months later.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was unusual about Cyril Radcliffe's background?
2. How were the two boundary commissions made up?
3. What principle were the boundary commissions told to apply?
4. When were the boundary awards made public?
5. Why is the Gurdaspur award controversial?
6. Which overwhelmingly non-Muslim area went to East Pakistan?
7. Why were the Sikhs especially hurt by the Punjab line?
8. How were the enclaves on the India and Bangladesh border finally resolved?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia