Skip to main content

At midnight on 14 to 15 August 1947 British rule in South Asia ended and two new states took its place. India kept most of the territory. Pakistan came in two wings, one in the west around the Indus and one in the east in Bengal, roughly 1,600 kilometers apart with India between them. The two great provinces of Punjab and Bengal were cut in half. To see how this happened, start with the places that were divided and the state that ruled them.

Mixed lands

Punjab, the land of five rivers, was the breadbasket of the north and the army's main recruiting ground. In both Punjab and Bengal, Muslims made up a slight majority of the population: in Punjab about 53 percent at the 1941 census, with Hindus near 30 percent and Sikhs near 15 percent. The Sikhs, a faith founded by Guru Nanak around 1500, were concentrated in central Punjab, and their sacred places were scattered across the province. Nankana Sahib, the birthplace of Guru Nanak, lay in the west and ended up in Pakistan, while the Golden Temple at Amritsar ended up in India.

Bengal, in the east, was Bengali speaking and densely settled. Its Muslims were concentrated in the eastern districts, many of them peasants farming land held by Hindu landlords, while Hindus dominated the professions and the great city of Calcutta. Religion and class overlapped, so quarrels over rent and debt could easily be cast as quarrels between communities.

Daily life in both provinces mixed sharing and separation. People of different faiths traded, served in the same regiments and visited the same Sufi shrines. They also kept rules about food, marriage and touch that marked boundaries. Historians warn against two opposite myths: that communities lived in unbroken harmony, and that they had always hated each other. Neither explains 1947.

Counting and classifying

The British Raj governed through information. A census of all India was attempted in 1871 to 1872 and repeated every ten years from 1881. It recorded each person's religion and caste. The anthropologist Bernard Cohn argued that the colonial census helped turn blurred, local identities into fixed, countable communities. Once each group had a number, leaders could claim to speak for it. Critics of this argument reply that the British did not invent religion or caste: people already knew who they were, and Indian reformers and politicians used the categories eagerly for their own ends.

Separate electorates

When Britain began to admit Indians into elected councils, Muslim leaders worried that a Hindu majority would outvote them everywhere. In October 1906 a delegation of Muslim notables met the Viceroy, Lord Minto, at Simla and asked for separate representation. Two months later the All-India Muslim League was founded at Dhaka, then spelled Dacca. The Indian Councils Act of 1909, known as the Morley to Minto reforms, granted the request. Under separate electorates, Muslims voted for Muslim candidates in seats reserved for them.

Defenders saw this as fair protection for a minority. The Indian National Congress, founded in 1885 and the main nationalist party, objected that it built division into politics: a candidate who needed only the votes of one community had little reason to appeal to anyone else. Yet in the Lucknow Pact of 1916 the two parties joined forces, and Congress accepted separate electorates in return for joint demands on Britain. A young lawyer who belonged to both parties, Muhammad Ali Jinnah, helped broker the deal and was praised as an ambassador of Hindu and Muslim unity.

Unity reached its height in the Khilafat movement of 1919 to 1924, when Gandhi joined Congress to a Muslim campaign whose aim was to defend the Ottoman sultan as caliph, the symbolic head of Sunni Islam. The alliance collapsed when Turkey itself abolished the caliphate in 1924, and the decade that followed saw a wave of riots.

Divide and rule?

Many nationalists argued that Britain deliberately set Hindus and Muslims against each other. The strongest exhibit was the 1905 partition of Bengal by Lord Curzon, which created a Muslim majority province in the east. Bengali protest was so fierce that Curzon's partition of Bengal was reversed in 1911. Other historians answer that British policy was often muddled rather than calculating, and that Indians made their own choices. Both sides agree that colonial institutions shaped the arena in which those choices were made.

Worked example: Bengal's first partition

In 1905 Bengal had about 78 million people, and officials said it was simply too large to govern from Calcutta. Curzon split off a new province of Eastern Bengal and Assam with its capital at Dhaka. Private notes show they also hoped to weaken the Bengali Hindu leaders of nationalism. The result was the swadeshi movement: boycotts of British cloth, bonfires of imported goods, and songs by Rabindranath Tagore, one of which later became the national anthem of Bangladesh. Some Muslim leaders in the east, however, welcomed a province where they would have more weight and jobs.

The same line thus meant convenience to the government, an attack on the nation to Hindu nationalists, and an opportunity to many eastern Muslims. When the partition was undone in 1911 and the capital moved to Delhi, those Muslims felt betrayed. Applying the ideas of this level, notice how a boundary drawn for one purpose was read through the lens of community, and how quickly a number on a census map became a grievance. Forty years later the same districts would be divided again, this time permanently.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was the religious balance in Punjab at the 1941 census?
2. Where was the All-India Muslim League founded in 1906?
3. Under the 1909 reforms, what did separate electorates mean?
4. What did Congress accept in the Lucknow Pact of 1916?
5. What did Bernard Cohn argue about the colonial census?
6. What was the aim of the Khilafat movement of 1919 to 1924?
7. What happened to Curzon's partition of Bengal of 1905?
8. Which Sikh holy place ended up in Pakistan?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia