The first war settled less than either side hoped. British merchants found that China's market grew more slowly than expected, the opium trade remained illegal, and the walled city of Canton stayed closed to foreigners. Many British officials concluded that only an envoy resident in Beijing, dealing directly with the court, would make the treaties stick. The Qing hoped instead to keep the foreigners at the coast. Meanwhile the court was fighting for survival against the Taiping, a vast rebellion in central China, which made it weaker but no more willing to give ground.
The Arrow incident
In October 1856 Chinese officers boarded the Arrow, a Chinese-owned lorcha, a small ship with a European hull and Chinese sails, anchored at Canton. They arrested twelve of its Chinese crew on suspicion of piracy. The ship had been registered in Hong Kong and flew the British flag. The British consul, Harry Parkes, demanded the crew's release and an apology for what he called an insult to the flag. The governor-general, Ye Mingchen, returned the men but refused to apologize. In fact the Arrow's Hong Kong registration had lapsed some days earlier, and whether the flag was flying at all was disputed. The governor of Hong Kong, Sir John Bowring, backed Parkes, and British warships shelled Canton.
In London many thought the case flimsy. Richard Cobden moved a motion condemning the action, and Palmerston, now prime minister, lost the Commons vote in March 1857, then won an election. He had campaigned on national honor and returned with a larger majority. Popular feeling had swung behind the war.
Britain and France together
France joined for its own reasons. The execution of the French missionary Auguste Chapdelaine in Guangxi in 1856 gave Napoleon III a cause. The British envoy, the Earl of Elgin, set out in 1857 with troops, but many of his troops were diverted to India to fight the great rebellion that had broken out there, which delayed the campaign for months. At the end of 1857 an Anglo-French force took Canton. Ye Mingchen was captured and sent to Calcutta, where he died in 1859.
In 1858 the allies sailed north, took the Dagu forts guarding the river to Tianjin and forced new treaties. The Treaties of Tianjin, signed with Britain, France, the United States and Russia, opened about ten more ports, including river ports on the Yangzi, allowed foreigners to travel in the interior with passports and protected Christian missionaries. The British treaty even banned the character yi, often translated "barbarian", from official documents about the British. The term the court resisted most was the right of foreign envoys to live in Beijing, which struck at the heart of the old order. Later that year, in tariff talks at Shanghai, opium was legalized as an import paying a fixed duty. The Qing, desperate for revenue, accepted.
1860: the march on Beijing
When the British and French envoys returned in 1859 to exchange ratified treaties, the Qing asked them to land at Beitang, farther up the coast, and travel overland. They insisted on forcing the river past Dagu, where newly strengthened forts sank or disabled several British gunboats. The allies returned in 1860 with about 17,000 troops, took the forts and advanced on Beijing. During negotiations in September, Qing forces seized Harry Parkes and a party of British and French officers and civilians who had come under a flag of truce. About twenty of them died from mistreatment in captivity. The Xianfeng emperor fled to his summer retreat at Chengde.
In October, French and then British troops looted the Yuanmingyuan, the vast imperial garden palace northwest of Beijing, often called the Old Summer Palace. Then Elgin ordered its burning to punish the emperor for how the prisoners had been treated. Hundreds of halls and pavilions burned over two days. In 1861 the exiled French writer Victor Hugo condemned the sack as the work of "two bandits", one who looted and one who burned. The emperor's brother, Prince Gong, signed the Convention of Peking, which opened Tianjin, raised the indemnities, allowed Chinese laborers to emigrate on foreign ships and ceded the tip of the Kowloon peninsula to Britain.
Russia's gain
The biggest winner was a power that fired hardly a shot. Russia's envoy offered to mediate, then pressed his advantage. Under treaties of 1858 and 1860, Russia gained the land north of the Amur and east of the Ussuri, a territory larger than France, and founded the port of Vladivostok on the Pacific coast in 1860.
Worked example: who broke faith in 1859?
The repulse at Dagu in June 1859 is a good test of even-handed judgment. The British case: the treaty of 1858 promised envoys in Beijing, the Qing were stalling, and the river was the obvious route. The Qing case: the treaty did not say which route envoys must take, the court offered another landing and an escort, and a foreign fleet forcing a fortified river near the capital looked like an invasion. Each side could read the other's conduct as bad faith. A careful historian asks what each side knew, what it could reasonably expect and what alternatives were open. Here the British chose force when a slower route was offered, and the Qing chose to fight when they could have let the ships pass. Neither choice was inevitable, and the cost of both fell above all on soldiers, on villagers along the road to Beijing and on the prisoners of 1860.
