Skip to main content

A changed burden

Across most of the world, diet now harms more people through excess and poor quality than through shortage. Obesity rates have roughly tripled since the 1970s, type 2 diabetes has spread to every continent, and high blood pressure, driven partly by salt, is a leading cause of stroke. Global studies rank poor diet among the top causes of death and disability, alongside smoking and high blood pressure. The question is no longer only what to eat, but what governments, companies and communities should do about it.

Ultra-processed food

The Brazilian epidemiologist Carlos Monteiro and colleagues developed a classification called NOVA. NOVA sorts foods by the extent and purpose of their processing, not by nutrients. Its fourth group, ultra-processed foods, covers industrial products made mostly from refined ingredients and additives, such as soft drinks, packaged snacks, instant noodles and many breakfast cereals.

In 2019 Kevin Hall and colleagues at the US National Institutes of Health tested the idea directly. Twenty adults lived in a research ward for four weeks, spending two weeks on an ultra-processed diet and two on an unprocessed one, matched for calories, sugar, fat, fiber and salt on offer, and ate as much as they liked. On the ultra-processed diet people ate about 500 kilocalories more a day and gained weight; on the unprocessed diet they lost it. Supporters see this as strong evidence. Critics reply that the trial was small and short, that NOVA's categories are broad enough to lump wholemeal bread with sweets, and that the cause, whether speed of eating, energy density or flavor, is still unclear.

Taxes

Governments have borrowed tools from tobacco control. In 2014 Mexico added a tax of one peso per liter to sugary drinks, about 10 percent of the price. Purchases of taxed drinks fell, by about 6 percent on average in the first year and more among poorer households, while purchases of water rose. Health effects take longer to show.

The United Kingdom chose a different design. Its Soft Drinks Industry Levy, announced in 2016 and in force from 2018, charges makers rather than shoppers and sets two rates by sugar content, with no levy below a threshold. The tiers were meant to reward makers who cut sugar, and many reformulated their drinks before the levy began, so the sugar in soft drinks sold fell sharply even where prices barely changed.

Not every tax survives. In 2011 Denmark taxed foods by their saturated fat content. Shoppers crossed the border to buy butter in Germany, businesses complained of the paperwork, and the Danish fat tax was repealed after about a year.

Labels and reformulation

In 2016 Chile began requiring black stop-sign warnings on packaged foods high in sugar, salt, saturated fat or calories, and banned such foods from schools and from advertising aimed at children. Studies found that purchases of sugary drinks fell by about a quarter in the first year and that many companies reformulated products to escape the labels. Several Latin American countries followed.

Quiet reformulation can matter as much as taxes. From 2003 the United Kingdom set voluntary salt reduction targets for food makers. Average salt intake fell by roughly 15 percent over the following decade, a change most consumers never noticed.

Whole communities

In 1972 the region of North Karelia in eastern Finland had among the highest rates of heart disease in the world. The North Karelia Project relied on community-wide changes in diet and smoking, working through shops, schools, farmers, dairies and local organizations, and encouraging vegetable oils and lower-fat milk in place of butter. Heart disease deaths among working-age men fell dramatically over the following decades, in North Karelia and across Finland, though falling smoking and better treatment also played large parts.

The case against

Opponents raise serious objections. Some see food rules as paternalism that treats adults as unable to choose. Critics also call food taxes regressive, because they take a larger share of poorer people's income. Defenders answer that poorer households also suffer more diet-related disease and so stand to gain most, and that revenue can fund water fountains or school meals. Another debate concerns new appetite-suppressing drugs that mimic a gut hormone; some see them as a medical answer that makes policy less urgent, others as treatment that leaves the food environment unchanged.

Worked example: a city weighs a soda tax

A city council debates a tax on sugary drinks. A shop owners' group warns that customers will buy across the city line. A pediatrician points to child tooth decay and diabetes. An economist notes that the tax would cost low-income families more as a share of income, but that they also cut purchases the most. A council member asks whether a tiered levy on makers, as in Britain, might push reformulation without raising prices much. The council finally adopts a modest tax, with revenue earmarked for school water stations and a review after three years. Whatever one thinks of the result, the debate weighed evidence, liberty and fairness in the open, which is how a free public should settle questions about its shared food environment.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Kevin Hall's 2019 ultra-processed diet trial find?
2. How does the NOVA system sort foods?
3. What happened after Mexico's 2014 tax on sugary drinks?
4. Why did the UK sugar levy set tiers based on sugar content?
5. What happened to Denmark's 2011 tax on saturated fat?
6. What did Chile's 2016 food law require?
7. What did the North Karelia Project rely on?
8. Why do critics call food taxes regressive?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia