Skip to main content

The second and third essays of the Genealogy turn from good and evil to two other pillars of moral life: the feeling of guilt and the ideal of self-denial. Together they show Nietzsche's genealogical method at full stretch.

What genealogy is

In the book's preface Nietzsche wrote that we need a critique of moral values, in which the value of those values is itself called into question. Earlier writers on the origins of morality, whom he lumped together as "English psychologists" and among whom he counted his former friend Paul Rée, had assumed that moral values were useful and simply asked how they arose. Nietzsche thought they had sneaked their conclusion in at the start. A genealogy, as he practiced it, digs into the messy and often ugly history of a value in order to ask what it has done to the people who hold it.

Debts and the birth of guilt

The second essay opens with a question: how did humans become animals able to make promises, to answer for their own future? Nietzsche's answer was harsh. Memory was burned into people through pain, rituals and punishments, until they could be counted on. He then pointed to a fact of the German language: the word Schuld means guilt, while the plural Schulden means debts. He took this as a clue that the moral idea of guilt grew out of the very material relation between creditor and debtor. In early societies, he argued, a creditor who could not be repaid was granted compensation in another form, the pleasure of inflicting pain on the debtor. Punishment began as a kind of repayment, and cruelty was once a festival.

He drew a lasting lesson from this. Punishment, he argued, has carried many different meanings over its history: rendering an offender harmless, paying back a loss, deterring others, celebrating a victory, waging war on an enemy, making a memory. Purposes have been poured into it one after another, so that by now it has no single definition. In a much quoted line he said that only something without a history can be defined.

The bad conscience

Nietzsche explained the bad conscience, the gnawing sense of being guilty in oneself, by a dramatic event. When humans were first enclosed within the walls of society and peace, their aggressive instincts lost their outlets. The instincts that could no longer discharge outward turned inward, against the self. Humans became their own torturers, and with this inward turning they also grew an inner world, a soul with depth. Later, the sense of debt to ancestors swelled into debt to gods, until Christianity presented a God who sacrificed himself to pay humanity's debt. Nietzsche called this a stroke of genius and also found it horrifying, because it made human guilt infinite and impossible to repay.

The ascetic ideal

The third essay asks what ascetic ideals mean: poverty, chastity, humility, the denial of the body and its desires. For artists they may mean very little; for philosophers they can be practical conditions for independent thought. The key figure is the ascetic priest, who rules over a suffering flock. People can bear almost any suffering if it has a meaning, Nietzsche said; what they cannot bear is meaningless suffering. The priest supplies one. He changes the direction of ressentiment, telling the sufferer: you yourself are to blame for your suffering. This both soothes and deepens the wound, but it keeps life going.

The essay ends with one of Nietzsche's most compressed insights: man would rather will nothingness than not will at all. Even a will against life is still a will, and it can be preferable to having no direction. Most surprisingly, he argued that modern science, with its unconditional will to truth, is the latest and most refined form of the ascetic ideal, not its opponent, since it too sets a value above life that life must serve.

Assessing the method

Anthropologists regard his picture of early punishment as imaginative rather than documented, and linguists note that the history of a word does not prove the history of a society. Yet the essays have been widely influential because they ask a question other theories skip: not only whether a practice is justified, but what it has done to those who live under it.

Worked example: suffering with a purpose

Consider a wellness influencer who promotes extreme fasting, ice baths at dawn and constant self-tracking. Followers report feeling purposeful for the first time: their discomfort now means discipline, purity and progress. A Nietzschean reading notices the shape of the ascetic ideal. A vague, everyday unhappiness has been given a meaning, and the cure is to turn against one's own appetites. Some followers flourish and gain real strength. Others begin to feel that every meal is a failure and that their bodies are enemies to be beaten. Nietzsche would not tell either group simply to stop. He would ask whether the practice serves their life or whether, under the language of health, it has become a quiet war on it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Nietzsche say his kind of critique must call into question?
2. Whom did Nietzsche count among the "English psychologists"?
3. On Nietzsche's account, where did the moral idea of guilt originate?
4. What did Nietzsche conclude about the meaning of punishment?
5. How did Nietzsche explain the bad conscience?
6. What does the ascetic priest tell the sufferer?
7. Which saying closes the third essay of the Genealogy?
8. How did Nietzsche view modern science's will to truth?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia