Skip to main content

Play hide and seek with a two-year-old and you may find her "hiding" in plain sight with her hands over her eyes. If she cannot see you, she seems to reason, you cannot see her. Two or three years later the same child can hide properly, keep a secret and tell a convincing fib. Between those moments lie some of the biggest changes in human thinking: learning that other people have minds of their own, and learning to steer one's own.

Other minds

Theory of mind is the understanding that other people have beliefs, desires and intentions that can differ from one's own, and from reality. In 1983 the Austrian psychologists Heinz Wimmer and Josef Perner tested it with a story. A boy named Maxi puts his chocolate in a cupboard and goes out to play. While he is gone, his mother moves it to another cupboard. Where will Maxi look when he comes back? Most three-year-olds point to where the chocolate really is. By about four to five, most children say Maxi will look where he left it, because they grasp that he holds a false belief. In 1985 Simon Baron-Cohen, Alan Leslie and Uta Frith used a similar task with two dolls, Sally and Anne, and reported that most autistic children in their study failed it. That claim has since been heavily qualified, and many autistic adults reject the idea that they lack interest in, or care for, other minds.

Some researchers argue that the ability starts earlier than spoken tasks reveal. In 2005 Kristine Onishi and Renée Baillargeon tracked where 15-month-olds looked during a wordless version and reported that the infants seemed surprised when an actor searched in the "wrong" place. Attempts to repeat such looking studies have produced mixed results, and the debate about how early theory of mind begins is still open.

Surprised babies

The same looking-time logic has been used to probe what infants expect about the physical world. In violation-of-expectation studies, researchers show babies an impossible event and measure whether they stare longer at it. In 1992 Karen Wynn showed five-month-olds one doll placed behind a screen, then a second doll added. When the screen dropped to reveal only one doll, the babies looked longer than when it revealed two. Elizabeth Spelke and others argue that humans start life with core knowledge about objects, number and agents. Critics reply that longer looking may reflect simple novelty or visual differences rather than real expectations, so these findings are taken seriously but cautiously.

Steering one's own mind

Alongside understanding others, children are learning to manage themselves. Psychologists group these skills under executive function, usually described as three parts: inhibitory control, working memory and cognitive flexibility. Inhibitory control stops an automatic response, working memory holds information in mind while using it, and flexibility shifts between rules or viewpoints. All three improve sharply between about three and five.

Lev Vygotsky noticed that young children often talk aloud to themselves while working. He argued that this private speech is a tool children use to guide their own actions, and that it gradually moves inward to become silent thought.

Self-control in childhood seems to matter much later. The Dunedin Study in New Zealand has followed about 1,000 people born in 1972 and 1973. In 2011 Terrie Moffitt and colleagues reported that children with better self-control grew into adults with better health, more financial security and fewer criminal convictions at age 32, even after taking account of intelligence and family background.

The marshmallow test, revisited

The best-known measure of self-control comes from Walter Mischel's studies at Stanford University's nursery school in the late 1960s and early 1970s. A child could eat one treat now or wait alone for two. Follow-ups around 1990 linked longer waiting with higher test scores in adolescence. In 2018 Tyler Watts, Greg Duncan and Haonan Quan repeated the analysis with a larger and more diverse sample. The link with later achievement was weaker, and it shrank greatly once family background and early abilities were taken into account.

A study by Celeste Kidd, Holly Palmeri and Richard Aslin in 2013 first let some children watch an adult break a promise. Children who had seen the adult break a promise waited far less, often only a few minutes. Waiting is partly a judgment about whether the world will keep its word, and children who live with unreliable adults may be acting sensibly when they take the sure thing.

Worked example: a preschool morning

A teacher watches two children. Three-year-old Ana snatches a toy and then insists, with the toy in her hand, that she does not have it. Five-year-old Ben hides a toy and tells his friend it is in the sandbox, grinning because he knows his friend will look there. Ana's fib is clumsy because she cannot yet model what her friend believes; Ben's works because he can. Later, during a game of "Simon says," Ana keeps clapping when she should freeze, while Ben mutters "wait, wait" to himself. Ana's inhibitory control is still developing, and Ben is using private speech to hold back. Games with rules, pretend play and turn-taking all exercise the same skills, and a classroom where adults keep their promises gives children a good reason to practice waiting.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What is theory of mind?
2. By what age do most children pass the Maxi false-belief task?
3. How does a violation-of-expectation study work?
4. Which three skills make up executive function?
5. What did Vygotsky think private speech does?
6. What did the Dunedin Study find about childhood self-control?
7. What did the 2018 replication of the marshmallow test find?
8. How did children who saw an adult break a promise behave?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia