Skip to main content

A philosopher of his age

Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770 to 1831) finished his first great book, the Phenomenology of Spirit, in Jena in October 1806, as Napoleon's army fought outside the town. The day before the battle he watched the emperor ride through the streets and wrote to a friend that he had seen the world soul on horseback. He became professor in Berlin in 1818 and was Germany's most influential thinker when he died.

Dialectic

Hegel's method is called dialectic, and it is often summed up as thesis, antithesis, synthesis. That slogan is misleading: Hegel rarely used the triad; others popularized it. His idea is subtler. Take any concept or way of life and think it through honestly, and it turns out to contain tensions it cannot resolve on its own terms. It passes over into its opposite, and the conflict gives rise to a richer form that keeps what was true in both.

Hegel's word for this movement is Aufhebung, usually translated "sublation." The German verb has several meanings at once, and Hegel used them all: canceling while preserving and raising up. In his logic the first example is pure being, which, being wholly empty, proves indistinguishable from nothing; the truth of both is becoming.

Hegel insisted that "the truth is the whole." No single idea or stage is true in isolation; each gets its meaning from its place in a developing system. And the whole is Spirit, Geist: mind not as a private possession but as the shared life of a community, its language, laws, art, religion and science.

Lord and bondsman

The most famous passage of the Phenomenology describes how self-consciousness arises. A self wants to be recognized by another self as free. Two such selves meet, each demanding recognition, and they fight. The one who fears death more submits and becomes the bondsman; the other becomes lord.

Then the story turns. The lord gets recognition, but it comes from someone he does not recognize as an equal, so it is worthless as confirmation of his freedom. Meanwhile he grows dependent on the bondsman's labour. The bondsman, forced to work, shapes the world through his work, sees his own mind in what he makes, and gains a self-reliance the lord lacks. The lesson Hegel drew: true recognition can only be mutual. Freedom is not something one person can have alone, at another's expense.

History as the story of freedom

In his Berlin lectures on the philosophy of history, Hegel stated his thesis in a sentence that J. Sibree's 1857 translation gives as: "The History of the World is none other than the progress of the consciousness of Freedom." In the ancient Oriental world, he claimed, only one, the ruler, was known to be free; among the Greeks and Romans, some; in the modern Christian world, all, as human beings. The scheme was crude and Eurocentric. But the guiding idea, that freedom is a historical achievement embodied in institutions, proved powerful.

Hegel thought history works through human passions. Individuals pursue their own aims, yet through them reason achieves larger ends, which he called the cunning of reason. And philosophy always arrives late. In the preface to the Philosophy of Right (1820) he wrote that the owl of Minerva takes flight only as dusk falls: philosophy grasps an age only as it is ending, not in time to give it instructions.

Ethical life and the critique of Kant

Hegel admired Kant's idea of autonomy but accused his moral law of empty formalism, lacking any content of its own. A rule about universalizability, he argued, can test whether maxims are consistent, but it cannot by itself tell us what our duties are. Real duties take shape in what Hegel called ethical life, Sittlichkeit: the family, civil society with its markets and professions, and the state, each with its own roles and obligations.

The state was the crown of this structure, and Hegel's praise of it alarmed later liberals, who saw in him an ancestor of authoritarian worship of power. His defenders reply that the state he described was a constitutional monarchy with the rule of law, a free economy, public opinion and freedom of conscience. After his death his followers split into a conservative right and a radical left, and from the left came Feuerbach and Marx.

Worked example: Haiti and the bondsman

Between 1791 and 1804, enslaved people in the French colony of Saint-Domingue rose up, defeated the armies sent against them, and founded Haiti. Hegel's Jena years coincided with these events, and they were reported at length in a journal he is known to have read.

In 2000 the philosopher Susan Buck-Morss argued that the lord and bondsman passage was shaped by news from Haiti. The claim is contested, since Hegel never names Haiti in the passage, and it remains a hypothesis rather than a settled fact. The planters received obedience from people they refused to recognize as persons, and that obedience gave them no security. The revolution turned on the enslaved demanding recognition, at the risk of death, as free human beings.

A society in which some are recognized and others are only used is unstable at its core. Freedom becomes real only when recognition runs both ways and is built into laws and institutions.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Hegel call Napoleon after seeing him in Jena in 1806?
2. How did Hegel use the triad thesis, antithesis, synthesis?
3. What does Hegel's term Aufhebung (sublation) combine?
4. Why is the lord's recognition worthless to him?
5. How does the bondsman gain independence in Hegel's story?
6. How did Hegel describe the history of the world?
7. What did Hegel mean by the owl of Minerva flying at dusk?
8. What was Hegel's charge against Kant's moral law?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia