Skip to main content

The Southern Question

Within a few years of unification, writers began to speak of the Southern Question: the persistent gap in wealth, literacy and public order between north and south. Pasquale Villari's Southern Letters of 1875 and the inquiry into Sicily by Leopoldo Franchetti and Sidney Sonnino in 1876 described landless laborers, absentee landlords, private violence and weak public institutions. The English-born patriot Jessie White Mario, who had nursed Garibaldi's wounded, wrote a searing study of poverty in Naples in 1877.

Why the gap? One answer blames unification: high taxes, conscription, free trade that hurt southern industry, and sales of church and common lands that went mostly to the wealthy. Another answer stresses older causes, such as geography, poor soils, malaria and centuries of feudal landholding. Recent economic historians tend to find that the gap in 1861 was real but smaller than it later became, and that it widened sharply in the decades after. These figures rest on reconstructions and are still debated.

Emigration

For millions the answer to poverty was to leave. Between 1876 and 1915 Italy recorded about fourteen million departures, to the rest of Europe, the United States, Argentina and Brazil. Many emigrants returned, some several times, so the number of people was smaller than the number of departures. In the early years most came from the north; after the 1890s the south dominated. Italians abroad often discovered their Italian identity, as others saw them, before many did at home. In New York or Buenos Aires a Calabrian and a Venetian were both simply Italians, and mutual aid societies, newspapers and parishes built a national community that barely existed in their home villages. Money sent home by emigrants paid debts, bought land and became a major support of the national economy.

Unfinished borders

The kingdom of 1871 did not include Trento, Trieste and other lands where many Italian speakers lived under Austrian rule. A movement called irredentism, from the phrase "unredeemed Italy", pressed the claim to Italian-speaking lands still held by Austria. Italy entered the First World War in 1915 partly to win them, and some patriots called that war the fourth war of independence. The price was enormous, and the bitterness that followed the peace helped bring Mussolini to power.

Whose Risorgimento?

Every later regime claimed the Risorgimento. Liberal governments filled squares with statues of Garibaldi and the king. The Fascists presented themselves as completing the Risorgimento's work. Antifascist partisans in the Second World War answered in kind: the largest communist-led partisan formations called themselves the Garibaldi Brigades. A shared past was useful precisely because it could be read in so many ways.

How historians judge it

The Marxist thinker Antonio Gramsci, writing in prison under Fascism, argued that the Risorgimento was a passive revolution: change led from above by moderates, without mass participation, which modernized the state while leaving peasants out. The British historian Denis Mack Smith argued that Cavour was less a master planner than a brilliant improviser who often worked to contain Garibaldi. More recently Lucy Riall has shown how Garibaldi's fame was built through mass media, such as newspapers, prints, songs and biographies, making him one of the first modern political celebrities.

Historians have also recovered people left out of the heroic story. Women ran hospitals, smuggled messages, wrote propaganda and fought, yet the kingdom gave them no political rights. Italian women first voted in national elections in June 1946, in the referendum that abolished the monarchy and the election of the assembly that wrote a new constitution. Peasants, brigands and southern loyalists to the Bourbons, long portrayed as obstacles, are now studied as people with their own reasons.

Mazzini's question

Mazzini himself was disappointed by the kingdom. In The Duties of Man, published in 1860, he had argued that rights must be paired with duties: to family, to nation and above all to humanity. For him the nation was not an end in itself but a step toward a brotherhood of free peoples, and he supported equal rights for women and education for workers. Whether nationalism leads toward that goal or away from it is one of the most important questions the Risorgimento leaves us.

Worked example: reading a monument

In the center of Rome stands the enormous white monument to Victor Emmanuel II, often called the Vittoriano. Work began in 1885; it was inaugurated in 1911, fifty years after the kingdom was proclaimed, and finished only in 1935. Romans nicknamed it the wedding cake and the typewriter. Since 1921 it has held the tomb of the Unknown Soldier of the First World War.

Use it to practice reading a historical symbol. Who paid for it, and who was honored? A king, not Mazzini or the peasants of the south. What did builders destroy to make room? Part of a medieval quarter and its residents. How did later regimes use it? The Fascists staged parades in front of it; the republic holds national ceremonies there. A monument tells you less about the past it shows than about the people who built it, and asking who is missing is often the best place to start.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did writers mean by the Southern Question?
2. About how many departures did Italy record from 1876 to 1915?
3. What did the irredentist movement claim?
4. What did Gramsci mean by a passive revolution?
5. What did Lucy Riall show about Garibaldi?
6. When did Italian women first vote in national elections?
7. What did Mazzini argue in The Duties of Man?
8. What did the communist-led partisan units call themselves?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia