The man in the red shirt
Giuseppe Garibaldi was born in Nice in 1807 and went to sea as a boy. He joined Mazzini's movement, took part in a failed plot in 1834 and was sentenced to death in his absence. He escaped and spent about twelve years in South America, fighting for a breakaway republic in southern Brazil and then for Uruguay. There he learned guerrilla warfare, met his wife Anita, and dressed his Italian Legion in the red shirts that became his trademark. His defense of Rome in 1849 made him famous across Europe. In Britain especially he became a popular hero, admired as a simple, honest man of action.
Sicily rises
In April 1860 a revolt broke out in Palermo at the Gancia convent. It was quickly suppressed in the city, but bands of rebels kept fighting in the countryside. Exiles such as Francesco Crispi pressed Garibaldi to go to their aid. Cavour's position was ambiguous. He did not want an open war with Naples that might anger the powers, and he feared Garibaldi's republican friends, but he did not stop the expedition either. He waited to see whether it would fail or succeed.
On the night of 5 to 6 May 1860 Garibaldi sailed from Quarto, near Genoa, on two steamers with a little over a thousand volunteers. Most were young men from the north, many of them students, artisans and professionals; very few were southerners. The only woman among them was Rosalie Montmasson, Crispi's wife, who later nursed the wounded. Badly armed and lacking almost everything, they landed at Marsala in western Sicily on 11 May, helped by the presence of British warships in the harbor, which made the Neapolitan navy hesitate.
From Marsala to Naples
At Salemi Garibaldi declared himself dictator of Sicily in the name of Victor Emmanuel, a sign that the expedition would serve the monarchy rather than a republic. On 15 May his volunteers won their first battle, a bayonet charge uphill at Calatafimi, against a larger Bourbon force. The victory was small in numbers and huge in effect. Sicilian rebels joined him, and at the end of May he fought his way into Palermo. The Bourbon army there was much larger but badly led and demoralized, and it agreed to withdraw.
Volunteers flooded in from the north. After a victory at Milazzo in July, Garibaldi crossed the Strait of Messina in August and advanced up the mainland, often meeting little resistance as Bourbon units melted away. On 7 September he entered Naples by train, ahead of his own army. King Francis II had withdrawn to the fortress of Gaeta.
Cavour moves south
Garibaldi's success alarmed Cavour. The general talked of marching on to Rome. That would mean a clash with the French garrison protecting the pope, and possibly a war that could undo everything. Cavour also feared that the south would fall under the influence of Mazzini and the democrats. So he sent the Piedmontese army through the papal provinces of the Marche and Umbria, to stop Garibaldi from reaching Rome and to take control of the revolution. The army defeated the papal forces at Castelfidardo on 18 September but carefully avoided Rome itself.
Garibaldi beat the Bourbon army in a hard battle on the Volturno River at the start of October. Plebiscites held on 21 October in the south and Sicily approved union. On 26 October, near Teano, Garibaldi met Victor Emmanuel and handed over his conquests to the king. He asked to govern the south for a year and was refused. His volunteers were disbanded, and few of their officers were taken into the royal army. Garibaldi sailed home to his small island of Caprera, refusing titles and rewards.
A people's war or a royal war?
Historians still argue about 1860. One view stresses the energy of the volunteers and the Sicilian rebels: a popular movement that a cautious government could only follow. Another stresses Cavour's skill in using Garibaldi and then reining him in, so that the result was a monarchy, not a revolution. Both are partly true. Neither Garibaldi nor Cavour alone could have made the outcome.
Worked example: Bronte, August 1860
In early June Garibaldi's government had promised to divide common lands among those who fought for the cause. Sicilian peasants took that promise seriously. At Bronte, on the slopes of Etna, much of the land belonged to an estate granted to the British admiral Horatio Nelson in 1799 and still held by his heirs. In August peasants rose, burned buildings and killed a number of local notables. Garibaldi sent his lieutenant Nino Bixio, who held a rapid military trial and had five men shot, including a lawyer who had tried to calm the crowd and was probably innocent.
The episode is uncomfortable for admirers of the Risorgimento. The revolution had raised peasant hopes, but when peasants acted, the new authorities sided with property and order, partly to reassure landowners and foreign governments. A humanist reading asks what due process and equal worth meant when a summary court decided lives in a day. Bronte is a reminder that a liberation story can contain injustice, and that the same people can be liberators and oppressors at once.
