Skip to main content

Herod the Great

Rome ruled Judea at first through client kings. The most famous was Herod, son of an Idumean official, whom the Roman Senate named king of Judea in 40 BCE; he took Jerusalem with Roman help in 37 BCE and ruled until 4 BCE. Herod was a builder of genius. He created the harbor city of Caesarea, palaces on the rock of Masada, and above all a vast rebuilding of the Jerusalem temple and its platform, whose western retaining wall, the Western Wall, is still a place of prayer. He was also suspicious and cruel, executing his wife Mariamne and several of his sons. Many Jews never accepted him as legitimate, partly because of his Idumean descent and his dependence on Rome.

Roman governors and rising tension

After Herod's death his kingdom was divided among his sons, and in 6 CE Judea became a Roman province ruled by governors. A stone found at Caesarea in 1961 names Pontius Pilate, the prefect under whom Jesus of Nazareth was executed. In these decades many Jews expected God to restore Israel's independence. Josephus describes prophets who gathered crowds in the desert and a "fourth philosophy" that refused to accept any master but God.

The Great Revolt

In 66 CE, after the governor Florus took money from the temple treasury, riots grew into a full revolt against Rome. The rebels drove out the garrison and formed a government. Rome sent Vespasian, who reconquered Galilee. There the rebel commander Joseph son of Matthias surrendered and, according to his own account, predicted that Vespasian would become emperor. When the prophecy came true, he was freed and took the family name Flavius. We know him as Josephus, who went on to write the main history of the war.

Vespasian's son Titus besieged Jerusalem, which was torn by fighting between rebel factions. In the summer of 70 CE the Romans captured Jerusalem and destroyed the Second Temple. The Arch of Titus in Rome still shows soldiers carrying the temple's seven-branched lampstand in triumph. Rome then diverted the tax Jews had paid to their temple into a fund for the temple of Jupiter in Rome. The last rebel fortress, Masada, fell in 73 or 74 CE. Josephus says its 960 defenders killed themselves rather than surrender, a story that excavations by Yigael Yadin in the 1960s neither fully confirmed nor disproved.

From temple to text

With the temple gone, the Sadducees lost their base, and leadership passed to sages in the Pharisaic tradition. Rabbinic tradition says Yohanan ben Zakkai founded an academy at Yavneh, where scholars began reshaping Judaism around study, prayer and the interpretation of law. Their work led to the Mishnah, compiled around 200 CE, and later the Talmuds. Another group of Jews, followers of Jesus, were developing into a separate movement that became Christianity.

Bar Kokhba

Two more revolts followed. From 115 to 117 CE Jews in Egypt, Cyrene and Cyprus rose against Rome and were crushed. Then in 132 CE Judea revolted under Simon bar Kosiba, whom followers called Bar Kokhba, "son of the star," and whom, according to rabbinic tradition, Rabbi Akiva hailed as the messiah. The causes are debated: Cassius Dio blames Hadrian's plan to build a Roman colony, Aelia Capitolina, on the ruins of Jerusalem, while a later Roman source mentions a ban on circumcision. The rebels struck coins dated by the "redemption of Israel." By 135 CE Rome had won. Cassius Dio puts the dead at 580,000, a figure that may be inflated. Jews were barred from Jerusalem, and the province was renamed Syria Palaestina. Jewish life continued in Galilee and across a wide diaspora, carried by the texts and practices formed over the previous thousand years.

Worked example: Can we trust Josephus?

Almost everything we know about the Great Revolt comes from one man who fought on both sides. Josephus wrote in Rome, under the patronage of the emperors whose army destroyed Jerusalem. That should make any reader cautious.

Consider his claim that Titus wanted to save the temple and that a soldier set it on fire against orders. This flatters his patron. A later Christian writer, Sulpicius Severus, possibly drawing on a lost part of Tacitus, says Titus decided the temple must be destroyed. Josephus also blames the war on a few fanatics, which excuses both the Jewish aristocracy he belonged to and the Romans.

Yet Josephus is not useless. Archaeology often confirms his descriptions of buildings, from Herod's palaces to Masada's water system. He records Roman cruelty, including mass crucifixions outside Jerusalem, even when it does Rome no credit. The method is the one used throughout this history: identify the author's interests, check what can be checked against other evidence, and trust most the details that cut against the author's own aims.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who named Herod king of Judea in 40 BCE?
2. What happened to Judea in 6 CE?
3. What began in 66 CE after the governor Florus took temple money?
4. Who wrote the main history of the Great Revolt?
5. What did the Romans do in Jerusalem in 70 CE?
6. According to rabbinic tradition, what did Yohanan ben Zakkai found?
7. What does the name Bar Kokhba mean?
8. What does Cassius Dio give as a cause of the Bar Kokhba revolt?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia