Skip to main content

Under Greek kings

In 332 BCE Alexander the Great swept through the Levant, and after his death Judea passed first to the Ptolemies of Egypt and then, after Antiochus III won the battle of Panium in 200 BCE, to the Seleucid kings of Syria. Greek language, cities and customs spread through the region. In Alexandria, home to a large Jewish community, the Torah was translated into Greek in the third century BCE. A later legend in the Letter of Aristeas says seventy two scholars made the translation for King Ptolemy II, which is why it is called the Septuagint, from the Latin for seventy. It made Jewish scripture readable across the Greek speaking world, and the earliest Christians would later read their Bible mostly in this form. Greek influence ran deep in other ways too. Jewish thinkers in Alexandria, above all the philosopher Philo in the first century CE, read the Torah through the ideas of Plato and the Stoics.

The crisis under Antiochus IV

Many Jews, especially in the priestly elite, adopted Greek ways. In 175 BCE a man named Jason paid the new Seleucid king, Antiochus IV Epiphanes, to make him high priest and to let him found a gymnasium in Jerusalem. A rival, Menelaus, then outbid him. Conflict between factions turned violent. In 167 BCE Antiochus IV banned the practice of Judaism: circumcision, sabbath keeping and the reading of the law were forbidden, and the temple was rededicated with an altar to Zeus Olympios. The books of Maccabees tell of martyrs who chose death rather than eat pork.

Why would a king normally tolerant of local cults do this? Historians disagree. Elias Bickerman argued in 1937 that radical Jewish Hellenizers in Jerusalem pushed for the decrees as a way of reforming their own religion. Victor Tcherikover held instead that the persecution was a response to a rebellion already under way. Others stress the king's need for money and control after a humiliating retreat from Egypt.

The Maccabean revolt

Resistance began, according to First Maccabees, in the village of Modein, where an old priest named Mattathias killed a Jew about to sacrifice on a royal altar and fled to the hills with his sons. His son Judah, called Maccabee, probably meaning "the hammer," led a guerrilla war. In 164 BCE Judah's forces retook Jerusalem and rededicated the temple, the event celebrated each winter at Hanukkah. The story of a single jar of oil burning for eight days appears much later, in the Talmud. First and Second Maccabees are not part of the Hebrew Bible but are included in Catholic and Orthodox Christian Bibles.

The Hasmonean state

Judah's brothers carried on, and by about 140 BCE Simon had won effective independence. His family, the Hasmonean dynasty, combined the offices of high priest and ruler, and later took the title of king. They expanded Judea's borders greatly. John Hyrcanus destroyed the Samaritan temple on Mount Gerizim and, according to Josephus, made the Idumeans to the south adopt circumcision and Jewish law. Alexander Jannaeus fought a civil war against his own subjects. Rivalry between two Hasmonean brothers ended when the Roman general Pompey took Jerusalem in 63 BCE and entered the temple's inner sanctuary.

Sects and scrolls

The historian Josephus describes Jewish "philosophies" of this period. Pharisees taught an oral tradition alongside the written law and believed in resurrection. Sadducees, linked with the priestly aristocracy, accepted only the written law and denied resurrection. Essenes lived in disciplined communities. In 1946 or 1947 a Bedouin shepherd found jars of scrolls in a cave near Qumran on the Dead Sea. Eleven caves eventually yielded the remains of some 900 manuscripts, about a quarter of them biblical. The Great Isaiah Scroll is roughly a thousand years older than the earliest complete Hebrew Bible manuscripts previously known, and it shows the text was copied with remarkable care. Many scholars link the scrolls to an Essene group at Qumran, though some argue they came from Jerusalem libraries hidden during war.

Worked example: Liberators who became conquerors

The Maccabees fought for the right to practice their religion against a king who forbade it. Within two generations their descendants were forcing a neighboring people to adopt that religion. How should a historian judge this?

One answer is that the Idumeans may have accepted Judaism more willingly than Josephus suggests; the Greek geographer Strabo describes them as joining the Judeans by choice. Another notes that ancient states commonly expected conquered peoples to share their rulers' cults, so the Hasmoneans were behaving like other kings. A third answer simply accepts the irony. A movement born from resistance to coercion adopted coercion once it held power.

The case is not unique. Many liberation movements, ancient and modern, have struggled to extend to others the freedom they demanded for themselves. Studying the Hasmoneans offers a question worth carrying forward: is a principle like freedom of conscience a weapon for one's own side, or a rule that binds the winners too?

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Which battle brought Judea under Seleucid rule in 200 BCE?
2. Where does the name Septuagint come from?
3. What did Antiochus IV do in 167 BCE?
4. What did Elias Bickerman argue about the decrees of 167 BCE?
5. What did Judah Maccabee's forces do in 164 BCE?
6. What offices did the Hasmonean dynasty combine?
7. What did the Pharisees teach alongside the written law?
8. Why is the Great Isaiah Scroll important?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia