Skip to main content

By 1431 the Hussites had won every major battle, and they were exhausted. Their lands had been fought over for twelve years, trade had collapsed and many people longed for peace. Their enemies had learned that crusades did not work. The result was something almost unheard of in medieval Europe: the church negotiated with people it had condemned as heretics.

Debating as equals

The Council of Basel opened in 1431, and after Domažlice its leaders invited the Hussites to come and be heard. The Hussites demanded, and won, guarantees that they would be treated as equals and judged by Scripture and the practice of the early church. In January 1433 a Bohemian delegation rode into Basel. At Basel a church council debated with condemned heretics as equals, something that had not happened at Constance. For some fifty days the two sides argued over the Four Articles. Jan Rokycana, a Prague master, defended the chalice. Prokop Holý himself attended.

Neither side converted the other, but talks moved to Prague, where envoys of the council drafted a compromise in November 1433. It was called the Compacts.

Lipany

Before any deal could hold, the Hussites had to settle who spoke for them. Moderate lords and the Old Town of Prague were ready to accept the council's terms. The field armies of Tábor and the Orphans were not. In 1434 the moderates joined Catholic lords in a league to restore order. At Lipany on 30 May 1434, a league of Utraquist and Catholic nobles defeated the field armies of Tábor and the Orphans. Prokop Holý was killed. The armies that no crusade could beat had been beaten by other Czechs, some of whom had fought beside them.

Lipany did not end Hussitism. It ended the radicals' military power and handed leadership of the movement to the lords and the moderate clergy. Later Czech writers would mourn Lipany as a national tragedy, while others saw it as the price of ending a war that had drained the country. Both readings capture part of the truth: the battle saved the chalice and sacrificed the dream of a society without lords.

The Compacts

The compromise was proclaimed in the Moravian town of Jihlava on 5 July 1436. The Compacts allowed communion in both kinds for those in Bohemia and Moravia who wanted it. The other three articles were accepted only in softened forms: preaching would be free, but under church order; sins would be punished, but by proper authority; clergy could own property, but should manage it honestly. In return, Bohemia was received back into the church and Sigismund was accepted as king. He did not enjoy it long and died in December 1437.

Many questions were left open. In 1435 the Bohemian estates elected Jan Rokycana archbishop of Prague, but the pope never confirmed him. For most of the following century, Bohemia's Utraquist church had no recognized archbishop and had to send candidates abroad to be ordained.

A Hussite king

The next decades belonged to a Utraquist noble, George of Poděbrady. He took control of Prague in 1448 and became regent. Tábor surrendered to him in 1452, ending its life as a separate radical community. In 1458 the Bohemian estates went further and elected George king, though he was a Bohemian noble with no royal blood. He was the only Hussite ever to wear the crown.

The papacy never accepted the arrangement. In 1462 Pope Pius II declared the Compacts void, and in 1466 his successor excommunicated George. Seeking allies, George's court circulated a plan for a permanent league of Christian princes, with a common assembly and a court to settle disputes between them. Historians sometimes describe the plan as an early idea for European union, though its first purpose was to protect a king the pope wanted removed. George died in 1471.

The long stalemate finally produced a lasting settlement. In 1485 the Peace of Kutná Hora let Catholics and Utraquists in Bohemia keep their own faith, at first for thirty-one years, and it was later renewed. It was an early legal agreement in Europe that two churches would share one kingdom.

Worked example: reading the Compacts

Set the Four Articles beside the Compacts and compare. On the cup, the Hussites won the substance: lay communion in both kinds became legal in Bohemia. On preaching, they won the word "free," but the church kept the power to license preachers. On church wealth, they lost the principle, since clergy kept the right to own land, but in practice many monastery estates seized after 1419 stayed in the hands of nobles. On punishing sin, the article survived in a form that any church could accept.

So who won? The answer depends on whose goals you measure. The university masters won most of what they wanted. Many lords won land. The peasants and radicals of Tábor, who had hoped for a world without lords, lost. A compromise can end a war and still decide, quietly, which of the winners actually won.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was new about the Hussite delegation's visit to Basel in 1433?
2. Who defeated the field armies of Tábor and the Orphans at Lipany in 1434?
3. What did the Compacts allow in Bohemia and Moravia?
4. What happened after the estates elected Jan Rokycana archbishop in 1435?
5. Who captured Tábor in 1452?
6. What was unusual about George of Poděbrady's election in 1458?
7. What did Pope Pius II do in 1462?
8. What did the Peace of Kutná Hora of 1485 do?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia