Skip to main content

The conquest of Poland in September 1939 put about two million Polish Jews under German rule, far more than lived in Germany itself. German forces killed thousands of Poles and Jews in the first weeks. On 21 September Reinhard Heydrich, head of the SS security apparatus, ordered that Jews be concentrated in larger towns near railway lines and that each community be run by a council of elders. These Jewish councils, called Judenräte, were ordered to carry out German demands: registering people, collecting goods, supplying forced labor and later drawing up lists for deportation.

Walls and armbands

The first ghetto was set up in Piotrkow Trybunalski in October 1939. Lodz, renamed Litzmannstadt, was sealed in spring 1940, and Warsaw in November 1940. In occupied Poland Jews had to wear armbands with a Star of David, and from September 1941 Jews in Germany aged six and older had to wear a yellow star on their clothes. At first ghettos were seen by many German officials as a temporary holding measure while leaders considered expelling Jews altogether. In 1940 they weighed the Madagascar Plan, to ship Europe's Jews to the French island colony. It was dropped when Britain, still in control of the seas, refused to make peace.

Hunger and dignity

Life in the large ghettos was a slow assault. Families crowded several to a room. Official food rations were a small fraction of what an adult needs, so survival depended on smuggling, much of it done by children who slipped through gaps in the wall, and on illegal workshops and bribes. Typhus spread through the crowded streets. People still fought to stay human. Self-help committees ran soup kitchens and orphanages. Teachers held banned classes in apartments, and orchestras, libraries and theater groups carried on. In Warsaw, Rabbi Yitzhak Nissenbaum called for "kiddush ha-hayim," the sanctification of life: where earlier generations had honored martyrdom, staying alive with dignity was now itself a holy act. Historians use the Hebrew word amidah, "standing up," for this whole range of unarmed resistance, from diaries and secret archives to forged papers.

The councils' dilemma

The Jewish councils faced choices with no good answers. They could comply in the hope of saving some, or refuse and be replaced by others, often at the cost of their lives. When mass deportations from Warsaw began on 22 July 1942, the council chairman, Adam Czerniakow, was told to supply thousands of people a day, including children. Czerniakow killed himself the next day rather than sign the deportation orders. Over the following weeks more than a quarter of a million people were sent from Warsaw to Treblinka. Among them was Janusz Korczak, a doctor and writer famous for his books on children's rights, who ran an orphanage in the ghetto. Korczak refused offers of rescue and went to Treblinka with the children in his care in August 1942.

Taking up arms

Armed resistance faced huge obstacles: few weapons, a hostile or frightened population outside the walls, and German collective reprisals that could doom whole families. Many fighters were young people without children of their own. When the Germans moved to clear what remained of the Warsaw ghetto, the uprising began on 19 April 1943, the eve of Passover. Mordecai Anielewicz, aged about 24, led the Jewish Fighting Organization, and a second group, the Jewish Military Union, also fought. The fighters knew they could not win; they chose how to face death. Revolts also broke out in Bialystok and other ghettos, and some young people escaped to join partisans in the forests.

The ghetto at Theresienstadt, in the Czech lands, served a different purpose: it held many elderly and well-known Jews from Germany, Austria and Czechoslovakia, and it was a way station to the killing centers. In June 1944 the SS staged a beautified tour of Theresienstadt to deceive visiting Red Cross officials, with fresh paint, a café and a children's opera. The visitors filed a reassuring report.

Worked example: "work to live" in Lodz

Chaim Rumkowski, chairman of the Lodz council, bet everything on one idea: if the ghetto produced goods the German army needed, the Germans would keep its workers alive. He built a vast system of workshops, ran the ghetto with an iron hand and was hated by many for privileges he gave to some. In September 1942, ordered to hand over children and the elderly, he gave a public speech begging parents to give up their children so that others might live.

Weigh the strategy fairly. Defenders point out that Lodz lasted longer than any other major ghetto: it was not destroyed until August 1944, when most of its remaining people were sent to Auschwitz, and Rumkowski with them. Soviet troops stood not far away and reached the city in January 1945. If the ghetto had held out a few months more, tens of thousands might have survived. Critics answer that the strategy assumed the Germans were rational exploiters, when their goal was murder, and that it made Jewish leaders tools of selection. Both views can be true at once. The real lesson concerns the trap itself: the Nazis designed a system in which victims were forced to choose among victims, and the moral weight of each choice belongs first to those who built it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Rabbi Yitzhak Nissenbaum call for in the Warsaw ghetto?
2. What did Janusz Korczak do in August 1942?
3. What was the Madagascar Plan of 1940?
4. What were Jews in Germany required to wear from September 1941?
5. Who led the Jewish Fighting Organization in the Warsaw ghetto?
6. What did Adam Czerniakow do when the Warsaw deportations began?
7. When did the Warsaw ghetto uprising begin?
8. What were the Jewish councils, or Judenräte, ordered to do?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia