Haudenosaunee tradition remembers a time before the league as a dark age. The nations raided one another, killings were answered with killings, and grief turned into endless revenge. Out of that world, the story says, came a message of peace. The story exists in many versions, told by different speakers and written down at different times, and the details vary. What follows is the broad outline shared by most tellings.
A messenger from across the lake
The central figure is known as the Peacemaker. In most versions he was born among the Wendat (Huron), north of Lake Ontario, and his birth was marked by signs that he would carry an important message. Out of respect, many Haudenosaunee avoid saying his personal name in ordinary speech and simply call him the Peacemaker. He is said to have crossed the lake in a canoe made of white stone, a sign that his message came from beyond ordinary human power.
One of the first people he met was a woman who fed the warriors who passed her lodge on the warpath. Her name is usually given as Jigonhsasee. When the Peacemaker explained his message, she accepted it and agreed to stop feeding war parties. Because she was the first to take hold of the Great Peace, she is remembered as the Mother of Nations, and her acceptance is one reason the tradition gives women a central role in choosing leaders.
Hiawatha's grief
The Peacemaker's most important ally was Hiawatha, an Onondaga or Mohawk man depending on the version. (He has nothing to do with the hero of Henry Wadsworth Longfellow's 1855 poem, which borrowed the name and attached it to Ojibwe legends.) In the story, Hiawatha's daughters died, in many tellings through the evil work of a powerful Onondaga leader. Overwhelmed, Hiawatha left his home and wandered in the forest.
At a lake he gathered small shells and strung them on cords. He said that if he met anyone in such grief as his, he would lift these strings and speak words of comfort with each. The Peacemaker found him and did exactly that, speaking over each string to wipe away his tears, clear his ears and open his throat so that he could hear and speak again. This first condolence restored Hiawatha's mind, and it became the model for the ceremony the league still uses when a chief dies and a new one is raised.
Straightening a twisted mind
The two men then carried the message from nation to nation: Mohawk, Oneida, Cayuga and Seneca. The hardest case was the Onondaga leader Tadodaho, pictured with snakes in his hair and a body twisted to match his twisted mind. Tadodaho resisted the peace. In the story, the Peacemaker and Hiawatha sang to him and combed the snakes from his hair, and his mind was made straight. To win his agreement, Onondaga was made the capital and Tadodaho's title became the keeper of the council fire. The name Tadodaho is still carried by the chief who holds that office today.
The Tree of the Great Peace
The Peacemaker then planted a tree. It was a white pine, the Tree of the Great Peace, and it became the symbol of the league. Its four white roots stretched to the four directions, so that any nation wishing to shelter under the peace could follow a root back to its source. Under the tree the chiefs buried their weapons, throwing them into an underground current that carried them away, which is the source of the English phrase "bury the hatchet." On top of the tree perched an eagle to watch for danger. The chiefs also linked arms in a circle, a sign that if one fell, the circle and the peace would still hold.
The laws the Peacemaker gave are called the Great Law of Peace, or in Mohawk the Kaianerekowa (spellings vary). They are not a single written document. They were held in memory, recited at councils and tied to particular strings and belts of wampum, which helped trained speakers recall the laws in order. In 1916 the Seneca anthropologist Arthur C. Parker published an English version called The Constitution of the Five Nations, compiled from texts written down at Six Nations of the Grand River around 1900. In it, the Peacemaker says, "I plant the Tree of the Great Peace." Parker's text is valuable, but it is one version among several, shaped by the people who wrote it down.
Worked example: the condolence ceremony today
When a league chief dies, his nation does not simply hold an election. It enters a period of mourning, and the nations on the opposite side of the council fire come to comfort them. This is the Condolence Council. The visitors arrive at the edge of the woods and are welcomed with a speech at the fire. Then, string by string, the condoling side repeats the words first spoken to Hiawatha: wiping the tears from the mourners' eyes, clearing their ears, unblocking their throats, and lifting the darkness from their minds.
Only after this does the ceremony turn to the future. The candidate chosen by the clan mother of the dead chief's clan is presented, his duties are recited, and the antlers, the symbol of his office, are placed on him. He takes the very title his predecessor held, so the name passes down unbroken. The ceremony shows something important about the league's thinking: a grieving mind cannot govern well. Before people can decide anything together, their sorrow has to be acknowledged and lifted. Politics, in this view, begins with healing.
