Skip to main content

The Hanse did not collapse in a single crisis. Over about two centuries the conditions that had made it useful changed one by one. New competitors appeared, kings and princes grew stronger, and trade found new routes. Some Hanseatic towns declined, while others adapted and grew rich in new ways. By the seventeenth century the network had faded into a memory and a title.

The Dutch challenge

The most dangerous rivals came from Holland and Zeeland. Dutch skippers sailed directly from the North Sea through the Sound, the strait between Denmark and Scania, into the Baltic. They bypassed Lübeck and its overland link to Hamburg, and they carried grain, timber and salt more cheaply in efficient ships.

Lübeck and its neighbors tried to stop them by force. A war between the Wendish towns and Holland ended in the Peace of Copenhagen of 1441, which left Dutch ships free to trade in the Baltic. The Danish kings, who collected tolls from every ship passing the Sound from the 1420s onward, had good reason to welcome more traffic, whoever carried it. The herring also let the Hanse down. In the fifteenth century the Scanian catches grew less reliable, while Dutch fishermen built a large herring fishery of their own in the North Sea. Prussian and Livonian towns such as Danzig and Riga were often happy to sell to the Dutch, which split the Hanse along the lines of its members' interests.

Stronger rulers

The Hanse had flourished in a world of weak kings and divided lands. That world was passing. In Russia, Moscow's rulers absorbed Novgorod and closed the Peterhof. Inside Germany, princes brought towns under control: in the 1440s the elector of Brandenburg forced Berlin and Cölln to submit to his authority, and other inland towns followed.

In Scandinavia the turning point came with Sweden. In 1523 Lübeck helped Gustav Vasa win the Swedish throne, and in return he granted Lübeck wide trading privileges. Once secure, he broke Lübeck's grip and opened Swedish trade to others. Lübeck tried one last great gamble. Under its mayor Jürgen Wullenwever it intervened in a Danish civil war, known as the Count's Feud, in 1534 to 1536. The intervention failed, Wullenwever was overthrown and executed in 1537, and Lübeck never again dictated terms to a Scandinavian king.

England turns

English merchants, organized in the Company of Merchant Adventurers, shipped cloth directly to the Low Countries and Germany and wanted the Hanse's privileges ended. In 1597 the emperor, under pressure from the Hanse, expelled the Merchant Adventurers from the Holy Roman Empire. Elizabeth I closed the Steelyard in reply the following year. The Hanse's last foothold in England was gone.

Attempts at reform

The towns did try to modernize. In 1556 they appointed the Cologne lawyer Heinrich Sudermann as their first syndic, and he worked for decades to revive the network. They built a grand new house for their Kontor in Antwerp, finished in 1568, just before war wrecked the city's trade. Yet each reform depended on towns paying their dues and attending meetings, and fewer did so each decade. Delegates complained that the same few towns carried the costs while the rest enjoyed the privileges.

The end of the assemblies

The Thirty Years' War of 1618 to 1648 devastated much of Germany and left Swedish and Danish power dominant on the Baltic coast. Lübeck, Hamburg and Bremen drew closer together to protect their own interests. The last general assembly of the Hanse met in 1669, attended by only nine towns. No later meeting was ever called.

Decline or adaptation?

Older histories, many written by nineteenth century German scholars, told this as a story of decline, of a great German power betrayed by disunity. More recent work questions that picture. The Hanse was never a state, so it could not decline like one. Many of its towns thrived. Hamburg in particular grew into one of Europe's leading ports in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, welcoming Dutch, English and Portuguese merchants. Danzig became the great grain port of the Baltic. What faded was the old system of shared privileges abroad, which mattered less as states made their own trade treaties and merchants found new partners.

Worked example: a Danzig grain merchant in 1580

Imagine a grain merchant in Danzig in 1580. Polish nobles send rye down the Vistula to his warehouses. He can sell it to a Lübeck merchant, who will ship it west through his own town and take a share of the profit. Or he can sell it straight to a Dutch skipper waiting in the harbor, who will carry it through the Sound to Amsterdam.

The Dutch buyer pays more, comes more often and carries larger cargoes. Selling to him breaks no law of Danzig and earns the goodwill of the Polish king, Danzig's overlord. What does the merchant lose? Only the vague solidarity of the Hanse, which does little for him in Amsterdam. The choice is easy. Multiply it by thousands of merchants and decades of trade, and the slow unravelling makes sense. The network did not fall; its members found that they no longer needed it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the Peace of Copenhagen of 1441 allow?
2. Why did Danish kings welcome more traffic through the Sound?
3. Which ruler did Lübeck help to the Swedish throne in 1523?
4. What happened to Jürgen Wullenwever?
5. Why did Elizabeth I close the Steelyard?
6. When did the last general Hanseatic assembly meet?
7. Who became the first syndic of the Hanse in 1556?
8. Which former Hanseatic town grew into a leading European port by the 1600s?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia