Skip to main content

Retirement as a normal stage of life is a recent invention. For most of history, people worked until they could not, and then depended on their children. Public pensions changed that, and they now form one of the largest transfers between generations in any modern state.

Bismarck's experiment

In 1889 the German Empire under Otto von Bismarck created the first national old-age insurance scheme, paid for by contributions from workers, employers and the state. Bismarck's 1889 law created old-age insurance with a pension age of 70, lowered to 65 in 1916, at a time when relatively few workers lived that long. The idea spread, and by the mid-twentieth century most industrial countries had public pension systems.

Two ways to pay

Pension systems come in two broad designs. In a pay-as-you-go system, contributions from today's workers pay the pensions of today's retirees, on the promise that tomorrow's workers will do the same for them. In a funded system, each worker's contributions are saved and invested, and the pension is paid from that pot. Most public pensions, including American Social Security, are largely pay-as-you-go.

Starting a pay-as-you-go system creates a windfall. Ida May Fuller of Vermont, who received the first monthly Social Security check in January 1940, had paid about 25 dollars in contributions. She lived to 100 and collected nearly 23,000 dollars. The first retirees in a pay-as-you-go system receive benefits they never fully paid for, and that gift is effectively financed by every later generation.

What each design returns

In 1958 the American economist Paul Samuelson showed why pay-as-you-go can still be a good deal. If each generation of workers is larger and more productive than the last, everyone can receive more than they put in. The economist Henry Aaron later stated the condition precisely. A pay-as-you-go system pays a return equal to the growth of total wages, from more workers and higher pay, while a funded system earns the return on invested capital. When workforces grew quickly, pay-as-you-go looked excellent. With fewer births and longer retirements, the same arithmetic turns harsh: fewer workers must support more retirees.

Critics sometimes call pay-as-you-go a Ponzi scheme. Defenders reply that the comparison fails: a Ponzi scheme depends on deception and must collapse, while a public pension is openly legislated and backed by the power to tax a continuing society. Still, the structure does depend on each generation honoring the bargain.

The double payment problem

Why not simply switch to funded pensions? The obstacle is the generation caught in the middle. Moving from pay-as-you-go to funding means one generation must pay for its parents' pensions and also save for its own. This is often called the double payment problem. Chile attempted the switch in 1981, replacing its public system with mandatory individual accounts run by private firms, under the military dictatorship of Augusto Pinochet. Supporters credited it with deepening Chile's capital markets. Critics pointed to high fees, low pensions and large gaps for women and informal workers who contributed irregularly. Chile later added a basic state pension in 2008 and a near-universal guaranteed pension in 2022, and in 2025 it passed a reform adding employer contributions.

Self-correcting systems

Some countries have tried to take the politics out of adjustment. Sweden's reform of the 1990s created notional accounts: each worker's contributions are recorded and credited with a return linked to wage growth, though the money actually pays current pensions. Sweden's automatic balancing mechanism slows the growth of pensions when the system's liabilities exceed its assets, without a new vote. Denmark links its retirement age to life expectancy, and in 2025 its parliament voted to raise the age to 70 by 2040. France took the political route, raising the minimum pension age from 62 to 64 in 2023 amid months of mass protests.

A fair rule for sharing the strain

In 1981 the economist Richard Musgrave proposed a principle for dividing the burden. Musgrave's fixed relative position rule keeps the ratio of retirees' benefits to workers' earnings after contributions constant, so that when the system comes under strain, both groups give up a similar share. Neither generation is made to carry the whole adjustment.

Worked example: from four workers to two

Imagine a pay-as-you-go system with four workers for every retiree, paying pensions worth 40 percent of the average wage. Each worker contributes 10 percent of pay. Now the population ages until there are only two workers per retiree. If pensions stay at 40 percent of the wage, the contribution rate must double to 20 percent, and workers carry the whole cost. If contributions stay at 10 percent, pensions must halve to 20 percent of the wage, and retirees carry it all. Musgrave's rule splits the difference: pensions fall to about 36 percent of the wage and contributions rise to about 18 percent, so workers' take-home pay and retirees' pensions each drop by roughly 9 percent. A fourth lever, raising the retirement age, changes the ratio itself by adding workers and removing retirees. It is often the most effective option, but it falls hardest on people who started work young or whose health gives out early.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Bismarck's 1889 law establish?
2. How does a pay-as-you-go pension system work?
3. Who gains a windfall when a pay-as-you-go system begins?
4. What return does a pay-as-you-go system pay, on Aaron's analysis?
5. What is the double payment problem?
6. What did Chile do to its pension system in 1981?
7. What does Sweden's automatic balancing mechanism do?
8. What does Musgrave's fixed relative position rule hold constant?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia