Skip to main content

A round world, a wrong size

A popular story says that Christopher Columbus had to convince people the earth was round. It is false. Educated Europeans had known the earth was a sphere since ancient times. The story was spread largely by Washington Irving's 1828 biography of Columbus, which helped popularize the myth that his critics thought the earth was flat.

The real argument was about size: how far west of Europe Asia lay. Columbus, a Genoese sailor born around 1451, believed Asia lay only a short sail west of Europe. He reached that conclusion by choosing the smallest available estimates for the earth's size and the largest for the eastward stretch of Asia. He also read a medieval Arabic astronomer's figures in shorter Italian miles than the author had meant. Columbus placed Japan roughly 4,400 kilometers west of the Canary Islands, when the true distance is close to 20,000. The scholars who advised the Portuguese and Spanish crowns rejected his plan, and they were right about the numbers. What no one in Europe knew was that two continents lay in between.

The contract at Santa Fe

Portugal turned Columbus down, partly because Dias was close to opening the African route. He spent years at the court of Ferdinand and Isabella of Spain, who were busy with the war against Granada, the last Muslim kingdom in Iberia. Granada fell in January 1492, and that April the monarchs agreed to the Capitulations of Santa Fe, which promised Columbus the titles of admiral, viceroy and governor of any lands he found, plus a tenth of the profits. The terms were generous because the crown expected him to fail.

The first voyage

Columbus sailed from Palos on 3 August 1492 with three ships, the Santa María, the Pinta and the Niña, and about ninety men. He stopped in the Canaries, then caught the trade winds west. On 12 October 1492 he landed on an island in the Bahamas that its Taíno inhabitants called Guanahani. He named it San Salvador. Which modern island it was is still disputed. He went on to Cuba and Hispaniola, convinced he was near China or Japan, and called the people he met Indians.

His journal describes the Taíno as gentle and generous, and in nearly the same breath notes how easily they could be made to serve. On Christmas Eve the Santa María ran aground off Hispaniola. Columbus left about forty men in a small fort and sailed home. When he returned the next year, the fort had been destroyed and the men were dead, killed after they had abused the local people.

Governor of Hispaniola

Columbus made four voyages between 1492 and 1504, reaching the coasts of South and Central America. As governor of Hispaniola he was a disaster for nearly everyone. He imposed a tribute in gold on the Taíno, with harsh punishments for those who failed to meet it, and shipped captives to Spain to be sold. Settlers, too, rebelled against his rule. In 1500 a royal investigator, Francisco de Bobadilla, arrested Columbus and sent him back to Spain in chains. He was freed, but never again allowed to govern.

A new world, a new name

Columbus died in 1506 still insisting that he had reached the edge of Asia. Others drew a different conclusion. The Florentine Amerigo Vespucci wrote widely read letters describing the lands as a new world. The German mapmaker Martin Waldseemüller put the name America on his 1507 world map, in Vespucci's honor, and the name stuck. Meanwhile the Spanish crown moved quickly to secure its claims. In 1493 Pope Alexander VI, himself Spanish, issued a bull granting Spain the lands west of a line in the Atlantic.

Worked example: judging Columbus

Few historical figures are argued over as fiercely. How can a learner weigh the case fairly?

His admirers make a serious argument. He was a skilled navigator who understood the Atlantic wind system and used it both ways. He took a real risk on an unknown ocean, and his voyages permanently joined two halves of the world. On this view, judging him by modern values is unfair to a man of the fifteenth century.

His critics answer that the standards were available in his own time. Spanish settlers and officials complained of his cruelty, and the crown removed him for it. The friars who soon denounced the treatment of the Taíno were his contemporaries. On this view, he chose to treat people as tools of profit when others around him saw that this was wrong.

A careful judgment can hold both points. His navigation was a genuine achievement. His government of Hispaniola was condemned by people of his own century, not only by ours. Separating the skill from the use it was put to is a habit worth taking to any historical figure, admired or despised.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Columbus's critics actually dispute?
2. Whose 1828 biography helped spread the flat earth myth about Columbus?
3. Roughly how far west of the Canaries did Columbus place Japan?
4. What did the Capitulations of Santa Fe promise Columbus?
5. What did the Taíno call the island where Columbus first landed?
6. Who arrested Columbus in 1500?
7. Who first put the name America on a world map?
8. Why was the Santa Fe contract so generous?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia