Skip to main content

On 24 March 1603 Elizabeth I died, and the king of Scotland, James VI, rode south to become James I of England. For the first time one man wore the crowns of England, Scotland and Ireland. This Union of the Crowns joined three kingdoms under a single monarch, yet each kept its own parliament, laws and church. England was Protestant with bishops; Scotland's church, the Kirk, was Presbyterian in spirit and suspicious of bishops; Ireland's majority was Catholic, ruled by a Protestant elite. Any king who tried to make the three fit one pattern risked trouble in all of them at once.

That is why many historians now prefer the name the Wars of the Three Kingdoms for the conflicts of the 1640s. The fighting did not begin in England, and events in Edinburgh and Dublin repeatedly forced the hand of London.

A king who believed in his calling

Charles I came to the throne in 1625. Shy, devout and stubborn, he took seriously the idea that kings were appointed by God and answerable to God alone. Most English people agreed; the argument was over what that meant in practice. English law and custom held that the king could not make new law or raise ordinary taxes without Parliament, an assembly of the House of Lords and an elected House of Commons that met only when the king summoned it.

Early in the reign Charles fought costly and failing wars against Spain and France. To pay for them he collected a forced loan and jailed some gentlemen who refused it. In 1628 Parliament answered with the Petition of Right, which declared that no one should be taxed without Parliament's consent or imprisoned without a cause shown. Charles accepted it, reluctantly, and soon read it narrowly.

The Personal Rule

In March 1629 a stormy session ended with members holding the Speaker in his chair so that resolutions against the king's policies could be read before he adjourned the House. Charles dissolved Parliament and did not call another for eleven years. This period, from 1629 to 1640, is known as the Personal Rule. It was not a reign of terror, and peace with France and Spain saved money.

Money still had to be found. Lawyers revived old feudal dues, fined gentlemen who had failed to take up knighthood, and sold monopolies. The most famous device was Ship Money, an old levy that coastal towns paid in wartime to provide ships. From 1635 Charles extended Ship Money to inland counties and collected it year after year in peacetime. Together the collections looked like a permanent tax without consent.

Laud and the beauty of holiness

Religion stirred deeper fears. William Laud, Archbishop of Canterbury from 1633, wanted orderly, ceremonial worship: communion tables moved to the east end of churches and railed off as altars, clergy in surplices, more emphasis on sacraments and less on long sermons. Laud called this the beauty of holiness. Many Puritans, the zealous Protestants who wanted the church purged of anything that looked Catholic, saw it as a slide toward Rome, especially with a Catholic queen at court. In 1637 three critics, the lawyer William Prynne, the clergyman Henry Burton and the physician John Bastwick, had their ears cut off by sentence of the court of Star Chamber, and crowds treated them as martyrs.

Scotland lights the fuse

Charles then turned to Scotland. Without consulting the Scottish Parliament or a general assembly of the Kirk, he ordered a new prayer book modeled on the English one. When it was first read in St Giles' in Edinburgh in July 1637, a riot broke out; a later tradition says a woman named Jenny Geddes threw her stool at the preacher. In February 1638 Scots in their thousands signed the National Covenant, a pledge to defend the Kirk against innovations not approved by free assemblies and parliaments. Charles tried force in the Bishops' Wars of 1639 and 1640 and failed. In August 1640 a Scottish army crossed the border and occupied Newcastle, and the king had to agree to pay it £850 a day until a settlement was reached. Only Parliament could raise that kind of money.

Worked example: the Ship Money case

In 1637 John Hampden, a wealthy Buckinghamshire landowner, refused to pay a Ship Money assessment of about twenty shillings. The case went before all twelve judges of the central courts. The king's lawyers argued that the king alone could judge when the realm was in danger and must have power to defend it. Hampden's counsel argued that if the king could decide on his own that danger existed and then tax to meet it, the rule of taxation by consent meant nothing.

In 1638 the judges found for the king, but only by seven votes to five. Apply the ideas above. Charles won the case and lost the argument. The close vote told property owners across England that even the king's own judges doubted him, and Hampden became a hero. Refusals to pay grew, and receipts fell sharply. When Parliament finally met again, it would make Ship Money illegal, and Hampden would be one of the men the king later tried to arrest.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the Union of the Crowns in 1603 create?
2. Why do many historians prefer the name Wars of the Three Kingdoms?
3. What did the Petition of Right of 1628 declare?
4. What was the Personal Rule?
5. What made Ship Money so contentious under Charles I?
6. What did Laud mean by the beauty of holiness?
7. What did signers of the National Covenant of 1638 pledge?
8. What did Charles agree to pay the Scots after they occupied Newcastle?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia