The Wall Street crash of October 1929 is the most famous image of the Depression, but it was the beginning of the story, not the whole of it. The deeper damage came over the next three years, as spending dried up, prices fell and thousands of banks closed their doors. The American collapse matters because the United States was the world's largest economy and its largest lender.
Boom and crash
The Dow Jones Industrial Average, an index of leading American shares, roughly quadrupled between 1924 and its peak on September 3, 1929. Many buyers paid only a fraction of the price in cash and borrowed the rest from brokers, a practice called buying on margin. When prices fell, brokers demanded more cash, and buyers who could not pay were sold out, pushing prices lower still.
Prices slid in September and early October. On Thursday, October 24, panic selling began, and a group of bankers bought shares to steady the market. The relief did not last. On Monday, October 28, and Tuesday, October 29, the market fell by about a quarter in two days, and some sixteen million shares changed hands on the Tuesday. The fall then continued in stages. By July 1932 the Dow had lost about 89 percent of its 1929 value, and it did not regain its peak until 1954.
Did the crash cause the Depression?
Most economists now say the crash alone could not have caused a decade of slump. Only a small share of Americans owned shares. The crash mattered in other ways. It destroyed wealth, made consumers and firms nervous, and led many households to stop buying cars, furniture and other goods bought on credit. The economist Christina Romer argued that the crash's main effect was uncertainty, which made people hold off on large purchases until they knew what would happen. By itself, 1930 looked like a bad recession. What turned it into a depression came next.
Banks fail in waves
In the late 1920s the United States had about 25,000 banks, most of them small and serving a single town. There was no federal deposit insurance, so a rumor that a bank was in trouble could send every depositor to withdraw at once, and a bank that had lent its money out could not pay them all. When one bank closed, depositors at neighboring banks grew afraid too.
The first great wave of failures came in late 1930, starting among farm banks in the South and Midwest. In December the Bank of United States in New York, with some 400,000 depositors, closed, the largest American bank failure up to that time. Further waves followed in 1931 and in the winter of 1932 to 1933. Between 1930 and 1933 about 9,000 American banks failed, and every failure took savings with it and cut off credit to local farms and shops.
As banks failed, the public hoarded cash and surviving banks kept more reserves and lent less. The amount of money in circulation shrank. Prices fell by about a quarter between 1929 and 1933. Falling prices sound pleasant, but they meant falling wages and incomes, while debts stayed fixed in dollars, so every farmer and homeowner with a mortgage found the burden growing heavier.
Hoover's response
Herbert Hoover, president from 1929 to 1933, is often remembered as doing nothing. That is not accurate. In late 1929 he called business leaders to the White House and asked them to keep wages and employment up. He expanded federal public works and in 1932 created the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, which lent government money to banks, railroads and other firms. He also supported higher tariffs and, in 1932, a large tax increase meant to balance the budget, which most economists now judge to have made things worse.
Hoover believed relief for the poor was a job for local governments and charities, and he resisted direct federal payments to the unemployed. When some 20,000 jobless veterans, the "Bonus Army," camped in Washington in 1932 to demand early payment of a promised bonus, army troops under General Douglas MacArthur drove them out and burned their camp. The image of a government using force against hungry veterans helped seal Hoover's defeat that November.
By early 1933 output had fallen by about a quarter since 1929, and unemployment reached about 25 percent.
Worked example: one town's bank closes
Picture a farming town in Iowa in 1931. The local bank has lent to farmers whose corn now sells for a fraction of its 1920s price, so many loans are not being repaid. A rumor spreads that the bank is short of cash. Depositors line up at the door; the bank pays out what it can, then closes. Families lose savings they had kept for years. The hardware store, which banked there, cannot pay its suppliers or its clerk. Farmers who need a loan to buy seed cannot get one. The neighboring town's depositors, hearing the news, rush to their own bank. Multiply this by thousands, and the national fall in money and spending follows. Each choice made sense alone; together they ruined the community.
