Ask people where new money comes from and most will picture a printing press at the central bank. Printed notes and minted coins are a small and shrinking part of the story. In most rich economies the great bulk of money exists as numbers in bank accounts, and those numbers are created in a way that surprises almost everyone the first time they hear it.
Loans create deposits
The common picture of a bank is a warehouse: savers deposit money, and the bank lends that same money out to borrowers. In 2014 the Bank of England published an article titled "Money creation in the modern economy" that set out to correct this picture. It explained that commercial banks create most new money by making loans. When a bank approves a loan, it does not hand over someone else's savings. It types a new deposit into the borrower's account, matched by the loan on its own books. The borrower now has spendable money that did not exist the day before.
The process runs in reverse too. When a borrower repays a bank loan, the matching money disappears from the economy, because the deposit and the debt cancel out. The total amount of money therefore rises and falls with the willingness of banks to lend and of people and firms to borrow. The same article estimated that notes and coins made up only about 3 percent of the money held by the British public; the rest was bank deposits.
What stops banks from creating without limit
If banks can create money by lending, why do they not lend endlessly? Several brakes apply. A bank must find borrowers it expects to repay, because bad loans eat its profits. Regulators require banks to hold a cushion of their owners' money, called capital, against losses, so a bank that lends recklessly runs into legal limits. And when a borrower spends the new deposit, it usually moves to another bank, which the first bank must settle using reserves held at the central bank.
The most important brake is price. Central banks steer the economy mainly by setting a short-term interest rate that ripples through the rates banks charge. Higher rates make borrowing costlier, so fewer loans are made and less new money is created; lower rates do the opposite. A central bank also acts as a lender of last resort in a panic. The Victorian journalist Walter Bagehot, in Lombard Street (1873), set out the classic guide. Bagehot's rule: in a crisis, lend freely to sound institutions against good security, but at a high rate, so that the help is not abused.
From gold to trust
For much of modern history, many currencies were tied to gold, and holders could in principle exchange notes for metal at a fixed price. The ties loosened over the twentieth century. On 15 August 1971 President Richard Nixon announced that the United States would stop converting dollars into gold for foreign governments, ending the last major link between the world's money and precious metal. Since then major currencies have been fiat money: money whose value rests on law and trust rather than on a promise to pay in metal.
Critics of fiat money argue that it gives governments and banks too much freedom to expand the money supply, and that a gold standard imposed welcome discipline. Defenders reply that the gold standard spread local shocks into worldwide slumps, because countries could not expand money when their economies collapsed, and that the supply of money should follow the needs of the economy rather than the output of mines. Most economists side with the defenders, but the argument about who controls money creation, and in whose interest, is a fair one for citizens to have.
Digital currencies
In 2008 a person or group using the name Satoshi Nakamoto published a design for Bitcoin, a digital currency run by a network of computers rather than by a bank or state. Bitcoin's rules cap its total supply at 21 million coins, a deliberate echo of gold's scarcity. Supporters see it as money that no government can inflate or freeze. Critics point to its wild price swings, its use in fraud and ransom payments, and the fact that a currency whose value can halve in months works poorly for paying rent or measuring debts. Whatever one thinks of it, Bitcoin is a living experiment in the old question of what makes people trust money.
Worked example: a loan for a delivery van
Amara runs a small bakery and wants a van to deliver to cafés. Her bank approves a loan of 30,000. The bank does not take this from anyone's savings account. It adds 30,000 to Amara's deposit account and records a 30,000 loan that she owes. New money has appeared. Amara pays the van dealer, and the deposit moves to the dealer's bank. Over five years she repays the loan, and with each repayment part of that money vanishes again. Meanwhile the central bank raises its policy rate, so the bank's next loan to a bakery costs more, and some bakers decide to wait. That decision, repeated across thousands of businesses, slows the creation of money across the whole economy.
