Skip to main content

The crusade began as a war against Muslims for Jerusalem. Within a century it had become a flexible tool that popes could aim at almost any enemy of the church, including Christians. The Fourth Crusade and the war against the Cathars of southern France show how far, and how fast, the idea could travel.

The Fourth Crusade: a contract and a debt

Pope Innocent III called a new crusade in 1198, aiming at Egypt, the heart of Muslim power. Its leaders hired the Republic of Venice to build and crew a fleet. The crusaders contracted Venice to carry 33,500 men, but only about a third that number came, leaving them unable to pay the agreed 85,000 marks. Venice, under its elderly and nearly blind doge Enrico Dandolo, had halted its trade for a year to build the ships. It wanted its money.

Dandolo proposed a bargain. To work off part of the debt, the crusaders captured Zara, a Christian city on the Adriatic coast, in 1202. Zara belonged to the king of Hungary, who had himself taken the cross. Innocent III excommunicated the crusaders for attacking Zara, though he later lifted the sentence from the non-Venetians.

Then came a second offer. A young Byzantine prince, Alexios Angelos, whose father had been deposed and blinded, promised the crusaders money, troops for Egypt and the submission of the Greek church to Rome if they would put him on the throne. In 1203 they did. He could not pay, his subjects despised him, and a rival murdered him early in 1204. The crusaders, unpaid and camped outside the richest city in Christendom, stormed and sacked it in April 1204. Churches were stripped, relics carried west and the four bronze horses of the Hippodrome shipped to Venice, where they still stand at Saint Mark's. The Latin Empire of Constantinople lasted until 1261, when the Byzantines retook the city, but the empire never recovered its former strength. In 2001, visiting Athens, Pope John Paul II expressed sorrow for the sack.

The Albigensian Crusade

In Languedoc, in southern France, many people followed the Cathars, Christians who held that the material world was the work of an evil power and who rejected the Catholic clergy. Preaching missions failed to win them back. The murder of the papal legate Peter of Castelnau in 1208 led Innocent III to call a crusade against the Cathars and their protectors. The crusade offered northern French knights the same spiritual rewards as a journey to Jerusalem, for forty days' service close to home.

In July 1209 the crusaders took Béziers and slaughtered much of its population, Catholics and Cathars alike. The most famous line of the whole war belongs to this massacre: a papal legate supposedly told soldiers to kill everyone, since God would know his own. Yet the line first appears in a collection of stories by a German monk, Caesarius of Heisterbach, written more than a decade later. It may capture the spirit of the day, but it is not reliable testimony. Under Simon de Montfort the war became a conquest of the south by northern lords, and it ended with the region under the French crown. Papal inquisitors arrived in the 1230s to hunt out remaining heretics.

Crusades of politics

Popes also declared crusades against Christian rulers who threatened the papacy's lands in Italy. Popes declared crusades against the Hohenstaufen emperor Frederick II and his heirs, the German dynasty that also ruled Sicily. Critics at the time, including some poets and chroniclers, complained that money raised for the Holy Land was being spent on Italian politics.

Meanwhile crusading enthusiasm could surge from below. In 1212 crowds in France and the Rhineland followed young leaders who promised to recover Jerusalem without weapons. Legend made this a "Children's Crusade," but the Latin word pueri used in the sources could mean young laborers or the poor, not only children, and many historians now see a movement of the young and landless. Most never left Europe; some reached Italian ports and found no miracle parting the sea.

Worked example: plot or accident?

Why did an army raised to fight in Egypt end up sacking Constantinople? For centuries writers looked for a villain. Some blamed Venice, said to have secretly struck a deal with Egypt to protect its trade. Others suspected the German king Philip of Swabia, brother-in-law of the young Alexios, of steering the expedition from the start. No convincing evidence for either plot has been found.

Historians such as Donald Queller argued instead for a chain of decisions, each one reasonable to the people making it. The leaders overestimated how many would come. The shortfall created a debt. The debt made Zara attractive. Alexios's offer seemed to solve both the money problem and the Egypt problem at once. When he failed, an unpaid army faced a hostile city with no way home. The lesson reaches beyond 1204. Disasters often come not from a single plan but from a series of commitments, each narrowing the next choice, until people do something none of them set out to do.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why did the Fourth Crusade fall into debt to Venice?
2. Which Christian city did the Fourth Crusade capture in 1202?
3. How did Innocent III respond to the attack on Zara?
4. When did the Byzantines retake Constantinople?
5. What led Innocent III to call a crusade against the Cathars?
6. Where does the line telling soldiers to kill everyone at Béziers first appear?
7. Against which ruler did popes declare crusades in Italy?
8. What could the word pueri in sources on the 1212 movement mean?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia