Skip to main content

How do you overturn a Supreme Court precedent on which a whole region's political order depends? The NAACP's answer took about twenty years and was carried out by a small group of Black lawyers trained largely at one school. In 1930 a report by the attorney Nathan Margold, paid for by a philanthropic fund, proposed attacking segregation by showing that Southern states never actually made separate facilities equal.

Houston and Marshall

Charles Hamilton Houston, vice-dean of Howard University's law school from 1929, turned it into a training ground for civil rights lawyers. He insisted that a Black lawyer should use the law as a tool for changing society rather than simply earn fees, and he drilled his students without mercy. His best-known student was Thurgood Marshall, who became the NAACP's chief lawyer and in 1940 headed its new Legal Defense and Educational Fund, known as the LDF. Marshall later became the first Black justice of the Supreme Court, in 1967. Houston's strategy started where segregation was weakest. Southern states offered almost no graduate or professional schools for Black students, so the inequality was plain and no court could pretend otherwise. Judges, as lawyers themselves, might also grasp the value of a law school more readily than that of a rural elementary school.

Graduate school cases

In 1935 Houston and Marshall won Murray v. Pearson in Maryland's courts, forcing the University of Maryland law school to admit Donald Murray. In Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada (1938) the Supreme Court ruled that Missouri could not meet its duty by paying for a Black student to attend law school in another state. The decisive pair came in 1950. In Sweatt v. Painter, Texas had hastily created a separate law school for Heman Sweatt; the Court ordered him admitted to the University of Texas, reasoning that a law school's worth lay partly in intangibles such as faculty reputation, alumni connections and the chance to argue with future colleagues. In McLaurin v. Oklahoma State Regents, George McLaurin had been admitted to a doctoral program but made to sit, eat and study apart from white students, at a separate desk, a separate table and a roped-off seat. The Court ruled this unconstitutional too. Neither case overruled Plessy, but together they suggested that segregation could almost never be equal.

Brown v. Board of Education

Meanwhile the LDF won Smith v. Allwright (1944), which outlawed the white primary, and Shelley v. Kraemer (1948), which barred courts from enforcing racial covenants in housing deeds. By 1950 Marshall decided to challenge school segregation head on, arguing not only that Black schools were unequal but that segregation itself violated the Constitution. Cases from Kansas, South Carolina, Virginia, Delaware and the District of Columbia reached the Supreme Court together under the name of the Kansas case, brought on behalf of Linda Brown of Topeka. The lawyers presented research by the psychologists Kenneth and Mamie Clark suggesting that segregation damaged Black children's sense of self. After Chief Justice Fred Vinson died, the new Chief Justice, Earl Warren, worked to produce a single voice. On May 17, 1954, the Court ruled unanimously that segregated public schools violated the equal protection clause, because separating children by race made their education unequal by its very nature. A year later, in a second decision known as Brown II, the Court left desegregation to local judges under a timetable that was prompt in words but flexible in practice, and Southern officials treated that wording as permission to delay.

Massive resistance

Southern political leaders answered with what Virginia senator Harry Byrd called massive resistance. In 1956, 101 members of Congress signed the Southern Manifesto, denouncing Brown as an abuse of judicial power. Put at its strongest, their argument was that the Constitution left schooling to the states, that the Court had leaned on social science rather than law, and that it had overturned nearly sixty years of precedent. In 1957 Arkansas governor Orval Faubus used the National Guard to keep nine Black students out of Little Rock Central High School, and President Eisenhower sent the 101st Airborne Division to escort them inside. Prince Edward County, Virginia, closed its public schools entirely from 1959 to 1964 rather than integrate. Ten years after Brown, only about one percent of Black children in the former Confederate states attended school with white children. In August 1955, fourteen-year-old Emmett Till, visiting from Chicago, was murdered in Mississippi; his mother insisted on an open casket, and photographs of his body shocked the nation. An all-white jury acquitted the killers, who later admitted the crime to a magazine.

Worked example: a school bus in Clarendon County

Brown began, in part, with a request for a bus. In Clarendon County, South Carolina, in the late 1940s, the county ran buses for white pupils but none for Black children, some of whom walked miles each way to schools heated by wood stoves. Parents led by Joseph DeLaine, a minister and teacher, asked for transportation and were refused. With the NAACP's help, parents signed a petition demanding equal schools; the first name on it was Harry Briggs. The signers paid heavily: Briggs lost his job, and DeLaine's house was later burned. Marshall turned Briggs v. Elliott into a direct attack on segregation. A three-judge federal panel upheld segregation in 1951, but Judge J. Waties Waring dissented, arguing that segregation was unconstitutional in itself, the view the Supreme Court adopted three years later. National law was built on local courage: before any lawyer could argue, ordinary people had to put their names on paper.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Which Howard University law school leader trained a generation of civil rights lawyers, including Thurgood Marshall?
2. Why did the NAACP first attack segregation in graduate and professional schools?
3. What did the Supreme Court rule in Missouri ex rel. Gaines v. Canada (1938)?
4. In Sweatt v. Painter (1950), why did the Court find Texas's separate Black law school unequal?
5. How did the University of Oklahoma treat George McLaurin after admitting him?
6. Which practice did the Supreme Court outlaw in Smith v. Allwright (1944)?
7. What was the vote in Brown v. Board of Education (1954)?
8. What did President Eisenhower do in 1957 when Arkansas's governor kept Black students out of Little Rock Central High?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia