In March 1892 a Memphis mob took three Black men from jail and shot them to death. Thomas Moss, Calvin McDowell and Will Stewart had run the People's Grocery, a successful store that competed with a white-owned shop across the street. Their friend Ida B. Wells, a journalist and co-owner of the Memphis Free Speech, concluded from the murder of the three grocers that lynching had little to do with the crimes it claimed to punish and much to do with keeping Black people economically and politically in their place. Her response helped launch more than half a century of organized resistance.
Ida B. Wells and the facts of lynching
Wells investigated hundreds of lynchings and found that in most of them the victim was not even accused of rape, the charge white newspapers used to excuse mob killings. When she said so in print, a mob wrecked the Free Speech office while she was out of town, and she was warned not to return. From exile in the North she published Southern Horrors (1892) and later The Red Record (1895), pamphlets that used white newspapers' own reports to document the killings. She lectured in Britain, where public criticism embarrassed Southern boosters seeking investment. She also urged Black Memphians to leave a city that would not protect them, and many did, an early use of economic pressure. Her method, careful documentation published to a wide audience, became a model for the movement's later reliance on publicity.
Washington and Du Bois
The most powerful Black spokesman of the 1890s was Booker T. Washington, head of the Tuskegee Institute in Alabama. In his Atlanta Exposition address of 1895, often called the Atlanta Compromise, he urged Black Southerners to concentrate on economic progress and set aside the fight for social equality for the time being. "In all things that are purely social we can be as separate as the fingers, yet one as the hand in all things essential to mutual progress," he said. His defenders argue that he was a realist working where open defiance meant death, and that he secretly funded legal challenges to segregation. W. E. B. Du Bois, a Harvard-trained historian and sociologist, answered him in The Souls of Black Folk (1903). Du Bois argued that accepting disfranchisement and second-class status would leave economic gains defenseless, and that a Talented Tenth of educated leaders must demand full rights now. The book made a famous prediction: "The problem of the twentieth century is the problem of the color-line." Critics of Du Bois have noted that his early faith in an educated elite sat uneasily with democratic ideals, a view he himself revised later in life.
The Niagara Movement and the NAACP
In 1905 Du Bois and the Boston editor William Monroe Trotter gathered Black activists near Niagara Falls, meeting on the Canadian side. Their Niagara Movement demanded the vote, an end to segregation and equal education, but it stayed small and short of money. Then in August 1908 a white mob rampaged through Black neighborhoods of Springfield, Illinois, Abraham Lincoln's hometown. Shocked white reformers, including Mary White Ovington, Oswald Garrison Villard and William English Walling, joined Du Bois, Wells and others to found the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, the NAACP, in 1909. Du Bois became editor of its magazine, The Crisis, which reached a circulation of around 100,000 by 1919. The NAACP chose two main weapons: lawsuits and public campaigns against lynching. The National Urban League, founded in 1910, focused instead on jobs and housing for newcomers to Northern cities.
Migration and new militancy
Starting around 1916, Black Southerners began moving north in huge numbers, drawn by wartime factory jobs and pushed out by low wages, crop failures and terror. This Great Migration eventually moved some six million people out of the South by 1970 and created Black voting blocs in Northern cities. Black veterans came home from the First World War expecting democracy at home, and in the Red Summer of 1919 white mobs attacked Black communities in Chicago, Washington and dozens of other places; Black residents fought back. In 1921 a white mob destroyed the prosperous Greenwood district of Tulsa. Marcus Garvey's Universal Negro Improvement Association offered another answer, racial pride and economic independence, and built what many historians call the largest Black mass movement up to that time. The NAACP pushed the Dyer Anti-Lynching Bill, which passed the House in 1922 but died in a Senate filibuster led by Southern senators.
Worked example: a flag over Fifth Avenue
From the 1920s until 1938 the NAACP hung a flag from its New York office window whenever a lynching was reported. It read: "A Man Was Lynched Yesterday." The flag combined much of what the early movement had learned. It turned Wells's statistics into something passersby could not ignore. It used a Northern city, where Black people could speak more freely and white allies could be reached, to put pressure on a Southern practice. And it kept the issue before the public while Congress refused to act. The flag came down after the landlord threatened eviction. No federal anti-lynching law passed until the Emmett Till Antilynching Act of 2022, but lynchings had already fallen sharply by the 1930s, partly because publicity made them a national embarrassment.
