The settlement at Verdun did not end the empire's divisions; it began a new round of them. Kingdoms were shared again among heirs, and uncles schemed against nephews. Within about a century and a half, the Carolingian family had lost every throne it held. Yet the memory of Charlemagne grew larger the further he receded into the past.
The middle kingdom falls apart
When Lothar I died in 855, his middle kingdom was split among his three sons. The northern part, between the Rhine and the Meuse, went to Lothar II, and it was named after him. The name Lorraine comes from Lotharingia, the kingdom of Lothar II. Lothar II spent years trying to divorce his wife Theutberga, who had no children, so that he could marry his partner Waldrada and make their son his heir. Frankish bishops backed him, but Pope Nicholas I blocked Lothar II's attempt to divorce Theutberga, deposing two archbishops who supported it. When Lothar II died in 869 without a lawful heir, his uncles moved in. The Treaty of Meerssen in 870 divided Lotharingia between Charles the Bald and Louis the German, and the strip between France and Germany became a borderland the two would dispute for more than a thousand years.
Pressure from outside
Ninth-century rulers faced raiders on every side. Scandinavian fleets attacked the river valleys of the west. Muslim raiders from North Africa struck Italy and in 846 plundered the churches outside Rome's walls, including St Peter's. In the east, from the 890s, Magyar horsemen raided deep into Germany and Italy.
Historians once saw a turning point in a decree issued at Quierzy in 877, when Charles the Bald, about to leave for Italy, provided that if a count died while the king was away, the count's son could hold the office until the king returned. Older textbooks called this the birth of hereditary counties. Many historians now read the Capitulary of Quierzy as a temporary measure, not the start of hereditary counties, since sons had often succeeded fathers before it and kings still removed counts after it.
For a moment the empire came back together. Charles the Fat, a son of Louis the German, became emperor in 881 and by 884 ruled almost all of Charlemagne's lands. But he was ill and failed to stop the Viking attacks on the west. In 887 Charles the Fat was deposed by the eastern nobles in favor of his nephew Arnulf, and he died early the next year. In several kingdoms men from outside the Carolingian line now became kings for the first time.
The end of the line
In the east the last Carolingian king, Louis the Child, died in 911, and the nobles chose kings from other families; a Saxon dynasty soon took over. In the west Carolingians and their rivals traded the crown for a century. In 987 Hugh Capet, a powerful duke, replaced the Carolingians in West Francia, elected king after the young Louis V died in a hunting accident. Hugh's descendants, the Capetians and their later branches, would hold the French throne for most of the next eight centuries.
Memory
Charlemagne's image was being shaped even in his lifetime. A Latin poem about his meeting with Leo III in 799 already called him the father of Europe, though "Europe" then meant his own Latin Christian lands. Later rulers claimed him as an ancestor or a model. Frederick Barbarossa had Charlemagne declared a saint in 1165, through an antipope he supported, Paschal III, in the middle of the emperor's struggle with the papacy. Rome never formally confirmed the step, though Aachen kept the cult. Napoleon visited Aachen in 1804 as Charlemagne's self-proclaimed heir, and in 1944 a unit of French volunteers fighting for Nazi Germany took his name. Since 1950 the city of Aachen has awarded the Charlemagne Prize for work toward European unity.
What was the empire?
Historians still weigh two pictures. One stresses ambition and reach: written law, oaths, envoys, schools and a shared Latin culture across a vast area. The other stresses fragility: an empire built on personal loyalty, held together by plunder and rewards while conquest lasted, and divided whenever a ruler died. The Carolingians also left uglier legacies, among them forced conversion and a trade in captives, many of them pagan Slavs, sold on toward Muslim Spain.
Worked example: four Charlemagnes
Line up four uses of the same man. In 1165 Barbarossa's saint was a holy emperor whose authority came from God, not from the pope. In 1804 Napoleon's Charlemagne was a conqueror who had united Europe under a new imperial order. In 1944 the Nazi unit's Charlemagne stood for a Europe united against Bolshevism under German leadership. In 1950 Aachen's Charlemagne stood for peaceful cooperation between France and Germany, whose lands he had once ruled together.
None of these figures is simply the ninth-century king. Each says more about the needs of its own moment: papal rivalry, revolutionary empire, fascist propaganda, postwar reconciliation. For any figure who becomes a symbol, ask who is invoking him, what they want, and which parts of the record they leave out. A man who forced baptism at sword point and a man whose scholars saved Tacitus were the same man. Honest history keeps both in view.
