The empire falls
The monarchy outlived slavery by only eighteen months. Planters who lost their workers without compensation turned against it. Many army officers, taught by the mathematician Benjamin Constant Botelho de Magalhães, embraced positivism, the philosophy of Auguste Comte, which promised government guided by science and order. The Catholic Church resented the state after a clash in the 1870s, and the heir, Princess Isabel, was unpopular with many and married to a French prince. On 15 November 1889 Marshal Deodoro da Fonseca led troops in Rio in a coup that ended the empire almost without a shot. Pedro II, old and ill, left quietly for exile and died in Paris in 1891. A republican journalist wrote that the people watched dumbfounded, many believing they were seeing a military parade.
A republic of governors
The Constitution of 1891 made Brazil a federal, presidential republic modeled partly on the United States. It separated church and state and gave the states wide powers, including their own militias and the right to borrow abroad. It dropped income requirements for voting but kept a literacy requirement and excluded women, so only a small share of Brazilians, often a few percent of the population, voted. From about 1898 a stable arrangement emerged, the politics of the governors, in which the federal government backed whichever faction ruled each state in return for loyal congressional delegations. The two richest states, coffee-growing São Paulo and dairy-producing Minas Gerais, held the presidency so often that the system was nicknamed café com leite, coffee with milk, for São Paulo and Minas sharing power. In the countryside, local bosses called coronéis delivered votes in exchange for favors, a system known as coronelismo, and open voting and fraud made results predictable.
Immigrants and whitening
To replace enslaved labor, São Paulo paid the passage of European workers, and millions of immigrants arrived between the 1880s and 1930, above all Italians, Portuguese and Spaniards, along with Germans, Syrians and Lebanese. In 1908 the ship Kasato Maru brought the first organized group of Japanese immigrants to Santos, beginning what became the largest Japanese community outside Japan. Many in the elite welcomed Europeans as part of a project of whitening, the hope that immigrants would make Brazil whiter through intermarriage, which they equated with progress. Freed people and their descendants were often passed over for jobs and pushed to the edges of the cities. At a race congress in London in 1911, the Brazilian scientist João Batista de Lacerda predicted that Brazil would be white within a century.
Revolts from below
The republic faced challenges from people it excluded. In 1904 Rio's poor rose against compulsory vaccination, which came amid demolitions of crowded tenements to make way for new boulevards, and the Vaccine Revolt raged for a week. In November 1910 sailors of the navy, most of them Black or of mixed race, seized the country's newest battleships in Guanabara Bay and aimed their guns at the capital. This Revolt of the Lash, led by the sailor João Cândido, demanded an end to flogging in the navy. It won an amnesty and the abolition of the lash, but within weeks many rebels were arrested, and some died in prison cells or on a ship to the Amazon.
New voices
In February 1922, the centenary of independence, artists and writers staged a Modern Art Week in São Paulo, calling for an art both modern and Brazilian. Oswald de Andrade's Cannibal Manifesto of 1928 proposed devouring foreign culture to make it Brazilian, punning in English, "Tupi or not tupi, that is the question." Young army officers, the tenentes, rose against the oligarchy in 1922 and 1924, and a rebel column led by Luís Carlos Prestes marched some 25,000 kilometers through the interior between 1925 and 1927 without being defeated. When world coffee prices collapsed in 1929 and the outgoing president, a São Paulo politician, chose another paulista as his successor, breaking the alternation with Minas, the old order cracked.
Worked example: Canudos
In the dry backlands of Bahia, a wandering lay preacher, Antônio Conselheiro, the Counselor, founded a settlement called Canudos in 1893. Poor farmers, former slaves and Indigenous people flocked there, and by 1897 it may have held twenty thousand or more. Conselheiro rejected the republic's civil marriage and taxes and preached that the new order was the work of the Antichrist. To the government and the press in Rio, Canudos looked like a monarchist plot. Three military expeditions were beaten back. The fourth, with thousands of soldiers and artillery, destroyed the town in October 1897, and many prisoners had their throats cut. The engineer and journalist Euclides da Cunha covered the campaign and in 1902 published Os Sertões, translated as Rebellion in the Backlands. He treated the backlanders as a racially backward people doomed by progress, yet wrote that "the sertanejo is, above all, a strong man," and in his opening note called the campaign a crime. Notice how the book splits in two. Its racial science reflects the theories of its time, which a modern reader must reject. Its moral verdict, that the coastal republic slaughtered its own people because it could not understand them, still stands. A source can be wrong in its theory and right in its witness.
