A common picture of the wars shows Americans fighting Spaniards. The reality was messier. Most soldiers on the royalist side were born in the Americas themselves. Spain sent several large expeditions, but disease, desertion and battle wore them down, and their ranks were refilled with local recruits. In many places the wars were civil wars, fought among neighbors, regions, classes and races, with each side trying to recruit the people the other feared.
Soldiers from below
Both sides recruited enslaved men by promising freedom. In the Río de la Plata, the government bought or drafted thousands of enslaved men for its armies, and Black soldiers made up a large share of the infantry that crossed the Andes. In Venezuela, Bolívar's decrees offered freedom for service, and Páez's llaneros were mostly of mixed African, Indigenous and European descent. Many of these men never came home, and some historians argue that patriot leaders used slave soldiers partly to spare free men from the draft.
Indigenous people also fought on both sides, often for their own reasons. In the highlands of Upper Peru, the republiquetas, small patriot guerrilla zones, kept up resistance for years after the regular armies were beaten. Elsewhere, as in the region around Pasto in southern Colombia, Indigenous and mixed communities fought fiercely for the king, who had protected their lands and whom they saw as a safer master than the creole elite.
Women in the wars
Women carried messages, hid fugitives, raised money and sometimes fought. Juana Azurduy led guerrilla forces in Upper Peru with her husband, Manuel Ascencio Padilla, and was given the rank of lieutenant colonel in 1816. She lost her husband and four of her children during the wars and died poor in 1862. In Bogotá, Policarpa Salavarrieta, a seamstress who spied for the patriots, was shot by the royalists in 1817. In Mexico, Leona Vicario used her fortune to aid the insurgents and was imprisoned for it. Such women were honored after the wars, but none of the new republics gave women the vote.
The mutiny that saved the revolution
In 1819 Spain gathered a large army near Cádiz to reconquer the Río de la Plata. Many soldiers dreaded the voyage, and liberal officers had been plotting against Ferdinand's absolutism. On 1 January 1820, an officer named Rafael del Riego led a mutiny of these troops for the Constitution of 1812, which they proclaimed. The revolt spread, and in March the king had to swear to the constitution. No new expedition ever sailed. The liberal government in Madrid tried negotiation in America, and royal commanders received confusing orders. Royalists in Peru split between liberals and absolutists, and in Upper Peru the commander Pedro Antonio de Olañeta turned against the viceroy.
The final campaigns
Bolívar's lieutenant Antonio José de Sucre, a Venezuelan general still in his twenties, marched into the highlands of Quito. On 24 May 1822 he won the battle of Pichincha on the slopes of the volcano above the city, freeing what became Ecuador. In 1823 Peru's congress invited Bolívar to take charge of the war, and in 1824 it made him dictator. On 6 August 1824 patriot cavalry won the battle of Junín, fought almost entirely with lances and sabers. On 9 December 1824, at Ayacucho, an army commanded by Antonio José de Sucre defeated the main royal army and captured the viceroy. The surrender terms let Spanish officers go home.
In Upper Peru, Olañeta held out until he was killed in a clash with mutinous troops of his own in April 1825. An assembly in Chuquisaca then declared independence and named the new country after Simón Bolívar, first as the Republic of Bolívar and soon as Bolivia. A Spanish garrison in the fortresses of Callao, near Lima, held out until January 1826, by which time thousands of the soldiers and civilians inside had died of hunger and disease. Spain kept only Cuba and Puerto Rico in the Americas.
Worked example: the trial of Manuel Piar
Manuel Piar was one of the ablest patriot generals in Venezuela, the son of a Canary Islander and a woman of mixed descent from Curaçao. In 1817 he won important victories in the Guayana region. He also quarreled with Bolívar, and he was accused of stirring up the pardos against the white officers. He was arrested, tried by a court martial and shot at Angostura on 16 October 1817. Bolívar confirmed the sentence.
How should we judge the case? Bolívar's defenders argue that discipline required it: the patriots could not survive a split between leaders, still less a race war like the one many feared after Haiti. His critics say the execution showed that creole leaders welcomed pardo soldiers but not pardo leaders with their own following. Both readings can be partly true. The case shows the central tension of the wars: the patriots needed the poor and people of color to win, but many leaders feared what those people might demand once they had won. The new republics abolished legal caste distinctions, yet power stayed mostly in creole hands.
