Skip to main content

In the far south, the May Revolution of 1810 was never undone. Buenos Aires was the one major center of revolution in Spanish South America that royal armies never retook. Yet its leaders could not hold together the old viceroyalty they claimed to inherit, and the region's history shows how independence could break an empire into pieces as well as free it.

Buenos Aires and its rivals

The junta of 1810 included radicals such as its secretary, Mariano Moreno, who wanted a sweeping break with the past, and moderates around its president, Cornelio Saavedra. It sent armies to bring the rest of the viceroyalty under its authority. They met resistance everywhere. In Upper Peru the patriot army was routed at Huaqui in 1811 by royal forces from Peru, and the region changed hands several times. In Paraguay, local forces defeated the Buenos Aires army in 1811, and then Paraguayans removed the Spanish governor and set up their own government. Paraguay was soon ruled by José Gaspar Rodríguez de Francia, a lawyer who became perpetual dictator in 1816 and sealed the country off from its neighbors until his death in 1840.

East of the Uruguay River, the Banda Oriental, today's Uruguay, followed José Gervasio Artigas, a rancher and former officer. Artigas demanded a confederation of equal provinces rather than rule from Buenos Aires, and he led a League of Free Peoples among several river provinces. He also handed out land to poor farmers, Indigenous people and free Black families. A Portuguese invasion from Brazil in 1816 eventually defeated him, and he spent the last thirty years of his life in exile in Paraguay.

Despite these quarrels, the Buenos Aires governments made real changes. An assembly in 1813 ended the mita, the forced labor draft of the Andes, banned noble titles and torture, and declared that children born to enslaved mothers would be born free. On 9 July 1816 a congress at Tucumán declared the independence of the United Provinces in South America. Some delegates, including the general Manuel Belgrano, proposed crowning a descendant of the Incas as a constitutional monarch, an idea that won applause and went nowhere.

San Martín's plan

José de San Martín was born in 1778 at Yapeyú, a former Jesuit mission on the Uruguay River. Taken to Spain as a boy, he served more than twenty years in the Spanish army before returning to Buenos Aires in 1812 to join the revolution. He concluded that the revolution would never be safe while royal power held Lima, and that the road to Lima ran not through the high plateau of Upper Peru, where patriot armies kept failing, but by sea from Chile.

Chile's own revolution had collapsed in 1814, when royal troops from Peru defeated the patriots at Rancagua. Its leader Bernardo O'Higgins fled across the mountains to Mendoza, where San Martín was governor. There they built the Army of the Andes, about five thousand men, including many formerly enslaved soldiers who had been promised freedom. In early 1817 it crossed the mountains in several columns. At Chacabuco in February 1817 the army defeated the royalists and entered Santiago. O'Higgins became Supreme Director of Chile, which declared independence in 1818. After a surprise defeat, the patriots won the decisive battle of Maipú in April 1818.

From Chile to Lima

Chile then built a navy, hiring a Scotsman and former officer of the Royal Navy, Lord Cochrane, to command it. In 1820 Cochrane's ships carried San Martín's army to the coast of Peru. San Martín moved slowly, hoping Peruvians would rise and the royalists would negotiate. The viceroy withdrew to the highlands, and in July 1821 San Martín entered Lima, proclaimed Peru's independence and took the title Protector of Peru. But the royal army in the Andes remained intact, Lima's elites were nervous, and his government was short of money and men. Peruvian creoles, who remembered the Andean revolts of 1780, had been among the empire's most loyal subjects.

Worked example: the meeting at Guayaquil

In July 1822 San Martín sailed north to meet Bolívar in the port of Guayaquil, which Bolívar had just annexed to Colombia. The two men talked privately over two days. No minutes were kept. Shortly afterward San Martín returned to Lima, resigned his powers before Peru's congress and left for Chile, then Argentina and finally Europe, where he died in 1850. Bolívar would finish the war in Peru.

What happened in that room? Historians have only later letters, some of doubtful authenticity, and the accounts of aides on each side. Argentine writers long portrayed San Martín as a selfless hero who stepped aside to avoid a ruinous rivalry. Venezuelan and Colombian writers often stressed that Bolívar had more troops and a clearer plan. The two men probably also disagreed about government, since San Martín favored a constitutional king for Peru and Bolívar wanted republics. The case is a good lesson in method: when evidence is thin, national loyalties fill the gap, and a careful reader should ask who told each version, when, and for what purpose.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What happened when Buenos Aires sent an army to Paraguay in 1811?
2. What did José Gervasio Artigas demand?
3. What did the assembly of 1813 declare about children of enslaved mothers?
4. Where did a congress declare independence on 9 July 1816?
5. Which battle in February 1817 opened Santiago to San Martín's army?
6. What post did Bernardo O'Higgins take in 1817?
7. Who commanded the navy that Chile built?
8. What title did San Martín take after entering Lima in 1821?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia