Skip to main content

In October 1830, the lieutenant governor of Van Diemen's Land, George Arthur, ordered more than 2,000 soldiers, settlers and convicts to form a human chain across the settled districts and sweep the island's Aboriginal people into a peninsula in the southeast. After seven weeks of marching, the Black Line had captured two people, and two others had been shot. The plan failed, but the war it was meant to end had already cost hundreds of lives. Scenes like it were repeated, in different forms, across the continent for a century.

Settled, not conquered

British law treated Australia as a colony acquired by settlement rather than conquest, as though the land had no owners recognized by law, an idea later summed up as terra nullius. One result was that Britain made no treaties with Aboriginal peoples, unlike its practice in parts of North America and New Zealand. Aboriginal people were declared British subjects, protected in theory by British law, while their land was taken without payment.

From the 1820s, the wool boom drove pastoralists, known as squatters, far beyond the official limits of settlement. Sheep and cattle trampled yam fields, fouled waterholes and drove off game. Aboriginal people resisted by spearing stock, raiding huts and attacking shepherds, and settlers and police struck back, often far harder. Near Bathurst, conflict with the Wiradjuri led the governor to declare martial law in 1824.

Counting a hidden war

How many died is hard to know, because many killings were never recorded or were deliberately hidden. Historians commonly estimate that settler deaths numbered in the low thousands, while Aboriginal deaths from frontier violence ran into the tens of thousands, with Queensland the bloodiest colony. A project led by the historian Lyndall Ryan has mapped more than 400 massacres. Disease and loss of food killed many more than bullets did.

In Queensland, the Native Mounted Police, troopers who were Aboriginal men from other districts led by white officers, carried out what official reports called "dispersals," a word that often meant killings. Violence continued into the twentieth century. At Coniston in Central Australia in 1928, after a white dingo trapper was killed, police-led parties shot at least 31 Warlpiri, Anmatyerre and Kaytetye people, and probably many more; an official inquiry found the killings justified.

Van Diemen's Land

The fighting in Van Diemen's Land, later called the Black War, was among the most intense. Arthur declared martial law in 1828, and after the Black Line failed, the preacher George Augustus Robinson persuaded the survivors to go with him to Wybalenna on Flinders Island, where many died of disease. When Truganini died in 1876, she was widely called "the last Tasmanian." That label was wrong, because Tasmanian Aboriginal people survived, many descended from women who lived with sealers on the Bass Strait islands, and they remain a living community today.

Protection and control

From 1869 in Victoria and 1897 in Queensland, colonies passed "protection" laws. In practice protectors gained power over where Aboriginal people lived, worked and married, and wages paid into government trust funds were often never returned. Reserves and missions gave some refuge from violence but came with tight controls. At Coranderrk, near Melbourne, Wurundjeri and other residents led by William Barak built a successful farm and petitioned until the government held a public inquiry in 1881. A later law expelled residents of mixed descent, and the station was eventually closed.

The history wars

For much of the twentieth century, Australian history books said little about the frontier. In 1968 the anthropologist W. E. H. Stanner described this as a kind of forgetting practised on a national scale. In 1981 the historian Henry Reynolds drew on settler diaries, letters and official records to show sustained Aboriginal resistance, and others followed. Critics, notably Keith Windschuttle in 2002, argued that historians had exaggerated deaths in Van Diemen's Land, relied on weak evidence and turned the past into a morality tale. His opponents replied that he dismissed oral history and indirect evidence and set standards of proof that hidden killings could never meet. The debate was bitter, but it pushed both sides back to the sources.

Worked example: Batman's treaty

In June 1835, John Batman, a grazier from Van Diemen's Land, sailed across Bass Strait to Port Phillip. He produced a deed by which, he said, Wurundjeri elders granted him about 600,000 acres in return for blankets, knives, mirrors, flour and a yearly tribute of goods. It is the only known attempt by colonists to make a treaty for Aboriginal land.

In August 1835 Governor Richard Bourke declared the deed void. His reason shows the logic of this level: the land, he said, already belonged to the Crown, so no private person could buy it from its Aboriginal inhabitants. What the elders understood the ceremony to mean is unclear; it may have looked to them like a ritual granting visitors temporary access to Country, not a sale. Either way, the episode captures the frontier in miniature: settlers moving faster than the law, Aboriginal law ignored, and a colonial government asserting that the land had never been anyone else's to give.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the Black Line of 1830 achieve?
2. What followed from treating Australia as a settled colony?
3. How do historians commonly estimate Aboriginal deaths from frontier violence?
4. Where did a police-led massacre take place in 1928?
5. Why was calling Truganini "the last Tasmanian" wrong?
6. What powers did protection laws give to protectors?
7. What did Coranderrk residents achieve in 1881?
8. What did Henry Reynolds show in 1981?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia