Sasun, 1894
The first great wave of killing began in the mountains of Sasun, south of Mush. Armenian villagers there had long paid dues to Kurdish chiefs, and when Ottoman officials pressed for state taxes as well, villagers resisted paying a double tax, encouraged by Hunchakian activists. In the summer of 1894 regular troops and Hamidiye units moved in. They crushed the resistance and massacred villagers, burning settlements across the district. The number killed is disputed, with estimates usually in the thousands. News leaked out through missionaries and consuls, and a commission of inquiry, with British, French and Russian delegates attached, gathered testimony in 1895.
Under pressure of that testimony, Britain, France and Russia pressed the sultan to accept a reform plan for the eastern provinces in the spring of 1895. It called for governors approved by the powers, mixed Muslim and Christian police, and a commission to oversee reform. Abdülhamid stalled for months.
From the capital to the provinces
On September 30, 1895, Hunchakian activists led Armenians in a march to present demands at the Sublime Porte, the seat of the government in Constantinople. Police clashed with the marchers, and over the following days mobs killed Armenians in the city. In October, under heavy pressure, the sultan signed the reform plan. Within days massacres spread across the east: Trebizond, Erzurum, Bitlis, Diyarbekir, Kharput, Sivas and dozens of smaller towns. Witnesses reported a striking regularity. Many of the massacres began and ended on a signal, a bugle or a call at an agreed hour, after which crowds and soldiers stopped and the looting of Armenian shops was counted. Men were the main targets; in many places whole villages were forced to convert to Islam to survive, and some returned to their church years later.
Historians debate how directly the sultan ordered the killings. No single written order has been found, and local hatreds, land disputes and fear of revolution all played a part. But the pattern across many provinces, the role of troops and the impunity that followed point to official tolerance at the least, and many scholars see central direction.
The Ottoman Bank
In August 1896, about two dozen members of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation seized the Imperial Ottoman Bank in Constantinople, a bank run largely with French and British capital. Armed with bombs, they demanded reforms and an amnesty, hoping to force European intervention. After a night of negotiation they were allowed to leave the country on a European ship. The response fell on people who had nothing to do with the raid: over the next two days mobs armed with clubs killed thousands of Armenians in the capital, many of them poor laborers from the provinces, while police looked on. Foreign ambassadors protested, and some Europeans who saw the killings from their windows described attackers who seemed to know exactly whom to find.
Aims and numbers
The Ottoman government said it was restoring order against armed revolutionaries, and it is true that revolutionaries sought to provoke a crisis. Yet most of the dead were unarmed villagers and townspeople, including women and children. Estimates of the total killed from 1894 to 1896 run from about 100,000 to 300,000. On the question of purpose, most historians see the 1890s killings as meant to subdue Armenians, not to destroy them: to break their political hopes, reduce their numbers and wealth, and show that European protest brought only more suffering. That distinction matters, because it lets historians compare the 1890s with what came later and see what had changed.
Watching from abroad
Western newspapers, missionaries and consuls carried the story to Europe and America. In Britain the aged Liberal leader William Gladstone gave one of his last great public speeches against the sultan in Liverpool in 1896. In America churches raised money, and Clara Barton led an American Red Cross relief expedition to the Ottoman Empire in 1896, sending agents into the stricken provinces with food, seed and tools. The powers, divided among themselves, did nothing to enforce the reforms the sultan had signed.
Worked example: the cathedral at Urfa
Urfa, in the southeast, had a large Armenian quarter. In late December 1895, after a first massacre in October, troops and crowds attacked again. On the second day several thousand Armenians, mostly women, children and old men, took refuge in the great Armenian cathedral, trusting that no one would violate a church. Attackers broke in, shot many of those inside, then poured lamp oil on the wooden gallery and set it alight. A British consul, Gerald Fitzmaurice, investigated soon after and reported that about three thousand people died in the cathedral alone.
What makes Urfa useful for understanding the period is its evidence chain. A consular investigator with no stake in Armenian politics reached the town within months, interviewed survivors and officials, and wrote a report that fits missionary accounts and Armenian testimony. The government's version, that rebels had attacked and troops had restored order, does not explain the burning of a church full of families. Urfa also shows the limits of outside concern: the report was read in London, and nothing followed. Two decades later the same town would face destruction again.
