Skip to main content

People have made stone tools for more than three million years, but writing appeared only about 5,000 years ago, and for most places much later than that. Everything before it, and a great deal after it, can be known only from what people left in the ground: broken pots, ash from old fires, the stains of rotted posts, bones, seeds and buildings. Archaeology is the discipline that turns those remains into evidence about how people lived.

The vocabulary of remains

Archaeologists sort what they find into a few working categories. An artifact is a portable object that people made or changed: a flint blade, a coin, a bead. An ecofact is natural material, such as seeds, animal bones or pollen, that reveals human activity even though no one shaped it. A feature is something that cannot be lifted out without destroying it: a hearth, a wall, a storage pit, or a posthole, the dark circle left in the soil where a timber post once stood. A site is any place where artifacts, ecofacts and features cluster, from a single campfire to a city.

Context is everything

The most important word in archaeology may be context. An object's value as evidence comes mostly from where it lay and what lay with it. A bronze pin found in a grave beside a skeleton tells you about dress and burial. The same pin bought from a dealer with no record of its findspot tells you almost nothing beyond its own shape. Archaeologists therefore record provenience, the exact position in three dimensions where an object was found, along with the soil around it (its matrix) and the other things found with it (its associations). Provenience should not be confused with provenance, a word used in museums for an object's later chain of ownership.

A record that has been edited

It is tempting to imagine a site as a moment frozen in time, as if people had simply walked away and left everything in place. Very few sites are like that. The American archaeologist Michael Schiffer argued in the 1970s and 1980s that the archaeological record is reshaped by both cultural and natural formation processes. Cultural processes include cleaning floors, dumping rubbish, reusing old stones, digging later pits and robbing graves. Natural processes include burrowing animals, roots, floods, frost and the slow chemistry of decay. Before asking what people did at a site, an archaeologist has to ask how the deposit came to look the way it does now.

Preservation is also deeply uneven. Stone and fired clay last almost anywhere. Wood, leather, cloth, food and skin usually rot within years or decades. They survive mainly where decay is slowed: waterlogged, frozen or extremely dry conditions preserve organic material, which is why bogs, glaciers, deserts and the mud of sunken ships yield such vivid finds. A site in well-drained, acidic soil may keep only its pottery and stone, giving the false impression that its people owned little else. Good archaeologists keep asking what is missing as well as what is present.

Archaeology of the present

Because archaeology studies things rather than words, it can check what people say against what they do. In 1973 William Rathje of the University of Arizona began the Garbage Project, in which students sorted and recorded household rubbish collected in Tucson. Comparing bins with interviews from the same neighborhoods, the team found that the trash showed far more beer drinking than people reported. People also claimed to waste less food than their bins revealed. The lesson reaches back in time: written sources record what their authors wanted remembered, while rubbish records what actually happened, though it too must be read with care.

Worked example: the Hoxne Hoard

In November 1992 a retired gardener named Eric Lawes was using a metal detector in a field near Hoxne, in Suffolk, England, looking for a farmer's lost hammer. He found silver spoons and coins instead. Rather than dig everything out, he stopped and reported the find. The next day county archaeologists excavated the hoard as a block of soil and recorded the position of every piece.

That choice turned a pile of valuables into evidence. The hoard held nearly 15,000 Roman coins and about 200 gold and silver objects, including jewelry, spoons and a silver pepper pot. Because the team recorded the layout, they could see that the objects had been packed into a wooden chest, with some items in smaller boxes and wrapped in cloth; tiny traces of the wood and fabric survived in the soil. The latest coins date to the early 400s, so the chest was buried no earlier than that, as Roman rule in Britain was collapsing. A worried family, it seems, hid its wealth and never came back.

Had the coins been dug out in a rush and sold one by one, the chest, the packing and the moment of burial would be gone. That difference, between an object and an object in context, runs through everything that follows.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What distinguishes an ecofact from an artifact?
2. Which of these is a feature rather than an artifact?
3. What does an archaeologist mean by an object's provenience?
4. Why do archaeologists insist on recording context?
5. What did Michael Schiffer stress about the archaeological record?
6. Which conditions tend to preserve wood, leather and cloth?
7. What did the Garbage Project find in Tucson's household trash?
8. Why is archaeology the main source for most of the human past?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia