Skip to main content

G. E. Moore (1873 to 1958) was Russell's friend and Cambridge colleague, and in many ways his opposite. Russell was quick, restless and public; Moore was slow, scrupulous and famous for asking, of some grand philosophical claim, "What exactly do you mean?" He published little by the standards of his peers, yet his influence on how philosophy is done may have been as large as anyone's.

Against idealism

Moore's essay "The Refutation of Idealism" (1903) attacked the idealist claim that to exist is to be perceived. He argued that every experience involves two things: the act of awareness and the object one is aware of. The blueness I see is not the same as my seeing of it. If that is right, nothing about the nature of experience shows that objects depend on minds. The argument is debated still, but it signaled that the Absolute would no longer go unchallenged.

The open question

The same year Moore published Principia Ethica, which shaped moral philosophy for half a century. Its target was any theory that defines goodness as some natural property, such as pleasure, or what we desire, or what evolution favors. Moore's weapon was the open question argument. Take any such definition: good means pleasant. We can still sensibly ask, of something pleasant, "but is it good?" The question is not silly, the way "is this pleasant thing pleasant?" would be. So for any natural property, one can sensibly ask whether something that has it is good, which shows that "good" does not mean that property.

Moore concluded that "good" names a simple, indefinable, non-natural property, which we grasp by a kind of intuition, much as we see yellow without being able to define it. He called the mistake of identifying goodness with a natural property the naturalistic fallacy. Critics replied that the argument proves too much: "water is H2O" was once an open question too, yet it is true. Others doubted that we have any faculty for detecting non-natural properties. The debate over whether moral words name real features of the world began here.

The final chapter of Principia Ethica made a bolder claim. Moore held that the greatest goods we know are the pleasures of friendship and the enjoyment of beautiful things. This message electrified a circle of young people in Cambridge and London who became the Bloomsbury Group, including the economist John Maynard Keynes and the novelist Virginia Woolf.

A defence of common sense

Moore's other great theme was common sense. Some philosophers argued that time is unreal, or that we cannot know other minds exist, or that material things are illusions. The Cambridge philosopher J. M. E. McTaggart, for instance, argued in 1908 that time is unreal. Moore's reply was disarmingly direct. If time is unreal, he observed, then nothing ever happens before anything else; but he knew perfectly well that he had eaten breakfast before lunch.

In "A Defence of Common Sense" (1925) Moore listed truisms he knew with certainty, such as that he had a body and that the earth had existed for many years. In a 1939 lecture he went further, offering a proof of the external world by holding up his hands: here is one hand, here is another, so at least two external objects exist.

Any argument for skepticism rests on premises. Moore's strategy was to be more certain of everyday truths than of any premise in a skeptical argument. If an argument concludes that I do not know I have hands, it is more reasonable to reject one of its premises than to accept the conclusion.

Puzzles Moore left behind

Moore also noticed an odd sentence: "It is raining, but I do not believe that it is raining." It could easily be true, since I might be wrong about the weather. Yet it is absurd for me to say it. This puzzle, now called Moore's paradox, is a sentence that could be true yet is absurd to assert, and it has taught philosophers much about the link between asserting something and believing it.

Worked example: the airtight proof

Suppose a video goes viral claiming to prove, in twenty careful steps, that the 1969 moon landing was staged. Each step sounds plausible: shadows that look odd, a flag that seems to ripple, the difficulty of the technology. You cannot rebut every step on the spot.

Moore's strategy suggests a calm response. Compare your confidence in the conclusion with your confidence in each premise. You have overwhelming independent evidence that the landings happened: thousands of engineers, rock samples studied worldwide, retroreflectors that scientists still bounce lasers off, and tracking by the rival Soviet Union. You can be far more sure of that than you are that step fourteen, about shadows, is correct. So you may reasonably conclude that some step is wrong before you find which one. This is not closed-mindedness. It is the recognition, central to Moore's thought, that a clever argument does not outweigh a mountain of evidence merely by being hard to answer quickly.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does Moore's open question argument claim?
2. What did Moore conclude that "good" names?
3. What did Principia Ethica rank as the greatest goods we know?
4. Which circle took up the ideals of Principia Ethica?
5. What did "A Defence of Common Sense" (1925) do?
6. What gesture did Moore use in his 1939 proof of an external world?
7. What was Moore's strategy against skeptical arguments?
8. What is Moore's paradox?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia