Skip to main content

Imagine a doctor who could save five patients by secretly taking the organs of one healthy visitor. Most people think this would be monstrous even if the numbers add up. The American philosopher Tom Regan built his case for animals on that intuition. In The Case for Animal Rights (1983), he argued that the reason we may not sacrifice the visitor applies to many animals too.

Against adding up

Regan admired Singer's conclusions but rejected his utilitarian method. On a utilitarian view, what matters is the total of good and bad experiences in the world. Regan said this treats individuals as mere containers of value, like cups that hold a liquid. What counts is the liquid, the pleasure and pain, not the cup. If you can produce more total value by breaking one cup and filling others, utilitarianism says you should. Regan called this the receptacle view and held that it gets morality backwards. The individual has value, not just the experiences poured into it.

Subjects of a life

Which individuals have this value? Regan's answer was the subject of a life: a being with beliefs, desires, memory and a sense of its own future, an emotional life, the ability to act on its goals, and a welfare that can go well or badly for it whatever others think. Such a being is somebody, not something. Regan held that every subject of a life has inherent value, and that all subjects of a life have it equally. Inherent value does not come in degrees, so a genius has no more of it than an ordinary person, and an ordinary person no more than a dog.

Regan was careful about where the line falls. He applied the criterion with confidence to mentally normal mammals aged a year or more, and he urged giving the benefit of the doubt to others, such as birds and perhaps fish, where the evidence was less clear.

Rights as limits

From inherent value Regan drew the respect principle: we must treat beings with inherent value in ways that respect it, never as mere means to the good of others. Rights express this. A right works like a fence around the individual, and it cannot be overridden simply because doing so would produce better results overall. That is why the doctor may not harvest the visitor, and why, Regan argued, we may not use animals for food, research or entertainment, however great the benefits to us. His goal was to end these practices, not to make them gentler.

The lifeboat

Regan tested his view on a hard case. Four people and a dog are in a lifeboat that will sink unless one of them goes overboard. Who should go? Regan answered that the dog should, because death would take more from a normal human than from the dog: it would cut off a far wider range of satisfactions and plans. This is not a judgment that the dog has less inherent value, he said, only that it would lose less by dying. Many critics found the answer hard to square with equal inherent value. If the dog counts equally, why does it always lose? Regan held that the case was exceptional, a forced choice among innocents, and could not justify routine use. He added that the answer would stand even if the choice were between one human and a million dogs, since each dog's loss must be compared one to one with the human's.

Predators and other puzzles

The rights view also has to say something about nature. If a wolf kills a deer, has the deer's right been violated? Regan said no. Predators are not moral agents, so they violate no one's rights, any more than a falling tree does. Our duty is to avoid violating rights ourselves, not to police the wild.

Critics raise other objections. Some, including the philosopher Mary Anne Warren, found inherent value mysterious: a property that comes in no degrees and cannot be observed. Others note that the all-or-nothing criterion leaves the status of fish and insects unclear, which matters because they make up most of the animals people kill. Utilitarians reply that refusing ever to weigh harms can lead to worse outcomes for everyone, animals included.

Worked example: the pigeon cull

A city council proposes to poison a flock of pigeons that foul a train station, because cleaning costs a great deal each year. A utilitarian would weigh the birds' suffering and deaths against the costs, health risks and inconvenience, and might approve a humane cull if the balance came out that way. Regan's view works differently. First, are pigeons subjects of a life? They fall outside his confident category of mammals, so on his advice they get the benefit of the doubt. Second, if they are, saving money is not a reason that can override their rights. The council must find methods that do not kill them, such as netting, spikes or contraceptive feed. The disagreement is not about the facts of the station but about whether good results can ever license using an individual as a means.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Regan say utilitarianism does to individuals?
2. How is inherent value shared among subjects of a life, on Regan's view?
3. Which features mark a subject of a life?
4. To which animals did Regan apply his criterion with confidence?
5. What role do rights play in Regan's theory?
6. Why did Regan say the dog should leave the lifeboat?
7. What did Regan say about predators such as wolves?
8. Which criticism targets Regan's all-or-nothing criterion?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia