Skip to main content

In April 1980 a new country took its name from a ruin. The choice was deliberate. A monument that settlers had used to deny African achievement became the emblem of an African state. That reversal is the last chapter of this story, and it raises questions that go beyond southern Africa: who owns the past, and who gets to speak for it?

A name for a nation

African nationalists in Southern Rhodesia had embraced Great Zimbabwe long before independence. For them it was proof that their ancestors had built a great civilization, and that colonial claims of an empty or backward land were false. The Zimbabwe African People's Union, founded in 1961, carried the ruin's name in its own, and the Zimbabwe African National Union followed in 1963. During the liberation war of the 1970s, the name stood for the country the fighters hoped to create.

At independence, the state built its symbols from the site. A soapstone bird from Great Zimbabwe appears on the national flag, and the bird also appears on the coat of arms, coins and banknotes. Great Zimbabwe became a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1986, along with Khami, which gave the country's past a place in the shared heritage of humanity.

The journeys of the birds

The birds themselves had been scattered. Eight carved soapstone birds, each set atop a tall column, were found at the site, most of them in an enclosure on the Hill. Several were removed in the early colonial years. In 1889 the hunter and trader Willi Posselt removed a bird and later sold it to Cecil Rhodes, who kept it at his house in Cape Town. Others went to the South African Museum, and part of one reached a museum in Berlin.

Their return became a matter of national dignity. Four birds held in South Africa came back to Zimbabwe in 1981 after negotiations between the two governments. In 2003 Germany returned the lower half of a bird whose upper half was already in Zimbabwe, and the two pieces were joined again. The bird once owned by Rhodes remains in South Africa.

Nationalism's own temptations

Nations need stories, but stories can harden into doctrines. After independence, the governing party used Great Zimbabwe for rallies and ceremonies and presented its own struggle as the direct heir of the ancient kings. The historian Terence Ranger used the term "patriotic history" for a narrow, state-approved version of the past, one that divided citizens into patriots and traitors and left little room for argument. Critics noted that such history could sideline the Ndebele and other groups whose past did not fit a single national line.

There is also the opposite danger. Archaeologists who spent decades fighting the foreign builder myth can be tempted to treat every new question as an attack on African achievement. Asking how much the city depended on trade, or whether its rulers were cruel or kind, is not a revival of colonial denial. Good history allows the people of the past to be human: inventive, powerful, divided and sometimes wrong.

Local voices

The nation is not the only claimant. Families living near Great Zimbabwe, among them clans who see themselves as its traditional custodians, have long held ceremonies there and disputed among themselves who has the right to lead them. Joost Fontein argued that official heritage management sidelined local communities' spiritual claims to the site, treating it as a monument to be preserved and toured rather than a sacred place where the ancestors still speak. Similar tensions appear at many heritage sites worldwide, wherever scientific preservation, tourism and living belief meet.

Worked example: bringing the dead home

For decades the University of Pretoria held the remains of people buried at Mapungubwe and nearby sites. In the democratic South Africa, many asked whether it was right to keep the bones of a people's ancestors in storage, however valuable they were for research. The human remains from Mapungubwe were reburied on the site in 2007, after long consultation.

The process was not simple. Several communities claimed descent from Mapungubwe's people, and they disagreed over who should speak for the dead and how the ceremonies should be performed. Researchers worried about losing the chance to answer future questions with new methods. Officials had to balance law, science and the wishes of living people with competing claims.

Consider the principles at stake. One is that the dead deserve respect, and that the descendants of the colonized should not have less say over their ancestors than museums do. Another is that knowledge of the past belongs in some sense to everyone, including future generations. A third is that no single community may own a shared ancestry. The Mapungubwe reburial did not satisfy everyone, but it treated those buried on the hill as people rather than specimens. That shift, from objects of study to ancestors with descendants, is perhaps the deepest change in how the region's past is now understood.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Which nationalist party, founded in 1961, carried the ruin's name?
2. What object from Great Zimbabwe appears on the national flag?
3. When did Great Zimbabwe become a UNESCO World Heritage Site?
4. What did Willi Posselt do with a bird he removed in 1889?
5. What did Germany return to Zimbabwe in 2003?
6. What did Terence Ranger mean by "patriotic history"?
7. What did Joost Fontein argue about heritage management at Great Zimbabwe?
8. What happened to the human remains from Mapungubwe in 2007?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia