For about a century, the most famous fact about Great Zimbabwe was a falsehood. European visitors, writers and officials insisted that Africans could not have built it, and they searched the ruins for proof of foreign builders. Their search damaged the very evidence that could have answered the question, and the falsehood outlived the evidence against it by decades.
Legends before excavation
The idea had old roots. Portuguese writers in the sixteenth century had linked the gold lands of the interior with Ophir, the place from which, in the Hebrew Bible, King Solomon's ships brought gold. In 1885 the novelist H. Rider Haggard set King Solomon's Mines in an imagined African interior, and the romance of lost white or Semitic civilizations deep in Africa became popular reading.
The first European known to have seen the ruins was a hunter, Adam Renders, in the late 1860s. In 1871 he guided the German geologist Karl Mauch to the site. Mauch was already sure of what he would find. Karl Mauch decided a wooden beam came from Lebanon because it smelled like cedar. The wood was almost certainly local, but Mauch took the scent as evidence that the building copied a palace of Solomon's age.
The company and its diggers
In 1890 Cecil Rhodes's British South Africa Company occupied the country, and the ruins became part of its story. In 1891 the company and the Royal Geographical Society backed an excavation by Theodore Bent, a traveler with an interest in the ancient Near East. Theodore Bent concluded that the builders were foreigners from the north, not local Africans, and suggested Phoenician or Arabian origins in a popular book published the next year.
Worse damage followed. The Ancient Ruins Company was licensed to dig ancient sites for gold, and in the late 1890s its prospectors stripped many zimbabwes, melting down gold ornaments and discarding what did not interest them. Protective legislation came only in 1902.
That same year Richard Nicklin Hall, a journalist, was appointed curator of Great Zimbabwe. He was convinced of foreign builders and saw the layers left by African occupation as later debris. Richard Hall cleared away deep layers of deposits from the Great Enclosure, in places several meters thick. Those layers held pottery, house floors and objects in sequence, the record that could have dated the walls and told who lived within them. Once removed without care, they could never be recovered.
The evidence answers
Trained archaeologists reached a different verdict. In 1905 David Randall-MacIver excavated at Great Zimbabwe and other sites for the British Association for the Advancement of Science, and he concluded that the builders were local Africans. Settler opinion rejected his findings.
The British Association tried again in 1929, when it held its annual meeting in South Africa. It invited the archaeologist Gertrude Caton-Thompson, who had worked in Egypt, to excavate. Gertrude Caton-Thompson's assistant at Great Zimbabwe was the young Kathleen Kenyon, who later became one of the most famous field archaeologists of the twentieth century. Caton-Thompson dug carefully placed trenches and studied the objects sealed beneath and within the walls. In 1931 she published her results: the site was African in origin and medieval in date, and nothing found there required foreign builders.
Why the myth survived
Science had answered, but politics kept the question open. For many white settlers, the idea that an older foreign people had ruled the land made their own rule seem part of a natural pattern. After 1965, when the white minority government declared independence, official publications were pressed to be vague or to give the foreign theories equal weight.
The myth also traded on a confusion. Great Zimbabwe did trade with the outside world, and imported objects were found in its ruins. Imported objects show contact through trade, not foreign builders, just as a Chinese vase in a European palace does not show that the Chinese built it. Radiocarbon dates from the 1950s onward added further support to the African, medieval account.
Worked example: what a sealed bead can prove
Caton-Thompson's method rested on a simple principle. An object sealed beneath a wall must have been dropped before the wall was built. If the object can be dated, the wall can be no older than that object.
Suppose a trench cuts under the foundation of a wall and finds glass beads of a type traded across the Indian Ocean in medieval times. Unless the wall has been disturbed, those beads give a date after which it was built. If the soil under the wall also contains local pottery like that made by Shona-speaking farmers, that points to those farmers as the builders. The argument does not rest on any one find. It rests on many sealed contexts all pointing the same way.
Now see why the earlier clearances were so harmful. A sealed context is valuable only while it is undisturbed. Each meter of soil that Hall removed destroyed sealed contexts that could have tested every theory, including his own. Destroying evidence in the name of a belief is the surest way to keep a false belief alive.
