Skip to main content

In 1618 the heart of Europe was not a country in any modern sense. The Holy Roman Empire stretched from the North Sea and the Baltic to the Alps, and from the Rhine to the hills of Bohemia. Inside it lay hundreds of separate territories: duchies and counties, lands ruled by bishops and abbots, tiny estates of imperial knights, and dozens of free cities that answered to no one but the emperor. Each ruler governed at home, yet all of them shared a common legal order, and that shared order was what the coming war would test to breaking point.

How the empire worked

The emperor was not a hereditary monarch. He was chosen by seven electors: the archbishops of Mainz, Cologne and Trier, the king of Bohemia, the Count Palatine of the Rhine, the duke of Saxony and the margrave of Brandenburg. Since 1438 the electors had almost always chosen a Habsburg, the family that also ruled Austria, Bohemia and Hungary, and whose Spanish branch ruled Spain, much of Italy and the southern Netherlands. By 1618 three electors were Catholic churchmen, the elector of Saxony was a Lutheran, and the electors of the Palatinate and Brandenburg were Calvinists, although most of Brandenburg's subjects stayed Lutheran. That left Bohemia as the swing seat. Because the king of Bohemia held one of the seven votes, a Protestant on the Bohemian throne could give Protestants a majority in choosing the emperor.

The empire also had common institutions. The imperial diet, an assembly of princes and cities, voted taxes and laws. Two supreme courts heard disputes between rulers and even between rulers and subjects: the Imperial Chamber Court, founded in 1495, and the emperor's own Aulic Council in Vienna. These bodies were slow, but they gave the weak a place to sue the strong, and for decades they kept quarrels in the courtroom instead of on the battlefield.

The cracks in Augsburg

The religious settlement of 1555 had let each ruler choose between the Catholic and Lutheran faiths. It left two sore points. The first was the ecclesiastical reservation, a clause requiring a bishop or abbot who became Protestant to give up his territory rather than take it with him into the new faith. Protestants never accepted it, and in practice many northern bishoprics passed to Protestant administrators anyway. The second was the steady growth of Calvinism, which the settlement did not recognize at all.

These disputes clogged the courts and poisoned the diet. Catholics read the settlement strictly; Protestants read it as a living compromise that had to bend with change. At the diet of 1608 the Protestant delegates walked out, and the assembly broke up without agreeing on anything. Imperial politics now had no place where the two sides were obliged to meet.

Donauwörth and the rival alliances

A small town on the Danube showed how fragile the peace had become. Donauwörth was a free imperial city with a Lutheran majority and a Catholic monastery. In 1606 townspeople broke up a Catholic procession. Emperor Rudolf II placed the town under an imperial ban, and in 1607 Duke Maximilian of Bavaria occupied Donauwörth to enforce the ban. He then kept it, annexed it to Bavaria and restored Catholic worship. To Protestants this looked like proof that imperial law had become a weapon in Catholic hands.

Their answer came quickly. In 1608 a group of Protestant princes formed the Protestant Union, led by the Elector Palatine, the leading Calvinist prince. In 1609 Catholic rulers formed the Catholic League, led by Maximilian of Bavaria, a capable, devout and very rich ruler who built the League's army into the best in Germany. Neither alliance wanted war yet, but both now had treasuries, officers and plans.

Beyond the empire, a deadline loomed. Spain had been fighting rebels in the northern Netherlands since 1568. The Twelve Years' Truce between Spain and the Dutch Republic, signed in 1609, was due to expire in 1621, and Spanish planners already counted on moving troops and money along a corridor through Italy and the Rhineland. Any German crisis near the Rhine would draw Spain in.

Worked example: a rehearsal on the Rhine

In 1609 the duke who ruled Jülich, Cleves and Berg, a cluster of rich territories on the lower Rhine, died without children. Two Lutheran princes, the elector of Brandenburg and the count of Pfalz-Neuburg, both claimed the inheritance. The emperor sent a commissioner to hold the lands until a court could decide. The Protestant Union saw an imperial grab in the making; the Dutch and the French saw Spanish troops on their doorstep.

Apply the patterns above. A local succession dispute was immediately read through the lens of religion, because each side assumed the courts would favor the other. Foreign powers treated a German question as their own, because the Rhine was a highway for Spanish armies. And private alliances, not imperial institutions, became the means of action. King Henry IV of France was preparing to march when an assassin killed him in Paris in May 1610, and the crisis lost momentum. In 1614 the Treaty of Xanten divided the territories between the two claimants, by then a Calvinist and a Catholic convert.

The outcome looks like a success: no great war followed. Yet the lesson most rulers drew was darker. The dispute had been settled by armed pressure and foreign backing, not by the empire's own courts. When the next crisis came, in Bohemia four years later, everyone knew which tools worked.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who chose the Holy Roman Emperor?
2. Why did the Bohemian throne matter so much in imperial politics?
3. Which two courts heard disputes between rulers in the empire?
4. What did the ecclesiastical reservation require?
5. What happened at the imperial diet of 1608?
6. What did Maximilian of Bavaria do at Donauwörth in 1607?
7. Who led the Protestant Union founded in 1608?
8. Which deadline drew Spain toward a German war?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia