Skip to main content

The early Tokugawa were not isolationists. Ieyasu welcomed foreign trade, collected information about Europe and kept a European adviser. Within forty years, however, his successors had banned Christianity, stopped Japanese from going abroad and confined Europeans to one small island. Fear of foreign power and of divided loyalty drove the change.

An open beginning

Ieyasu issued licenses to merchants trading with Southeast Asia, and red-seal ships, so named for the shogun's vermilion seal on their licenses, made around 350 voyages between 1604 and 1635. Japanese communities grew up in Manila, in Vietnamese ports and in Siam. In 1600 a Dutch ship limped into a Kyushu harbor with its crew near death. Its English pilot, William Adams, became an adviser to Ieyasu, built him two Western-style ships and received an estate and the status of a samurai. Adams helped the Dutch and English set up trading posts and gave Ieyasu a Protestant view of the Catholic powers, Spain and Portugal, as dangerous.

Banning the faith

By 1600 there were perhaps 300,000 Christians in Japan, including several daimyo. To Tokugawa leaders, missionaries looked like advance agents of Spain, which had conquered the Philippines, and converts looked like people whose highest loyalty lay elsewhere. In 1614 the shogunate banned Christianity throughout the country and expelled the missionaries. The Christian lord Takayama Ukon, who refused to give up his faith, was exiled to Manila, where he died weeks after arriving. Persecution grew fierce. In 1622 some fifty five Christians were executed together at Nagasaki, and officials devised tests to expose secret believers. Suspects were made to tread on fumie, images of Christ or Mary, and those who refused were tortured or killed. In Nagasaki the ritual became an annual event for every household.

Shimabara and the closing of the ports

In 1637 peasants on the Shimabara peninsula and the Amakusa islands rose against a ruthless lord. Many were Christian, and they rallied around a teenage leader, Amakusa Shiro. The rebels held out in the ruined Hara Castle for months against a vast shogunal army. A Dutch ship, at the shogunate's request, fired on the rebel castle, a service the Dutch hoped would show they were useful and harmless. The defenders were massacred in 1638.

The rebellion confirmed the shogunate's fears. An edict of 1635 had already forbidden Japanese to go abroad, and any who returned from abroad faced death. In 1639 the Portuguese, seen as the main carriers of missionaries, were expelled. The Dutch, who cared about trade and not conversion, stayed on under tight control, joined by Chinese merchants in Nagasaki.

Windows on the world

Controlled trade also meant controlled information. Each year the Dutch had to deliver the fusetsugaki, written reports of world news, which interpreters translated for the shogunate, and the head of the Dutch post traveled to Edo to pay respects. The shogun's officials learned of wars, revolutions and new colonies through these reports. Korea sent twelve formal embassies between 1607 and 1811, which crowds lined the roads to watch. Chinese junks, far more numerous than Dutch ships, brought silk, sugar, medicines and books, and from 1689 Chinese merchants in Nagasaki were confined to their own walled quarter. Imported books, including Chinese translations of Western works on astronomy and geography, were screened by censors looking for any mention of Christianity. Contact was narrow, but it was managed for the shogunate's benefit, not abandoned.

The faith that went underground

Some Christian communities survived in secret for more than two centuries without priests. They memorized prayers in a garbled mix of Latin, Portuguese and Japanese, baptized their own children and kept registered membership at Buddhist temples. They disguised images of Mary as Kannon, a Buddhist figure of compassion, so that a household altar looked ordinary to any inspector.

Worked example: the discovery at Oura

In 1865, after Japan's ports had reopened, French missionaries built a church at Oura in Nagasaki for foreign residents. On 17 March a group of villagers from nearby Urakami came to look. One woman quietly told the priest, Bernard Petitjean, that their hearts were the same as his, and asked to see the statue of Mary. Petitjean realized he was meeting the descendants of believers who had kept their faith hidden since the ban.

The joy did not last. When Urakami villagers began refusing Buddhist funerals, officials arrested them. The shogunate fell, but the new imperial government continued the persecution, and in 1868 to 1870 more than three thousand Urakami Christians were deported to domains across Japan, where several hundred died. Only protests from Western governments ended the ban in 1873.

The case shows both the reach and the limits of the Tokugawa state. It could register every household, test every conscience each year and still fail to erase a belief that ordinary families chose to keep. It also shows how freedom of conscience, now treated as a basic human right, was won in Japan only after generations of people had paid for it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What were red-seal ships?
2. Who was William Adams?
3. What happened to Takayama Ukon after the 1614 ban?
4. What were fumie used for?
5. How did the Dutch help the shogunate during the Shimabara Rebellion?
6. What did an edict of 1635 forbid?
7. What were the fusetsugaki?
8. How did hidden Christians disguise images of Mary?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia