Skip to main content

Galileo Galilei (1564 to 1642) spent eighteen years as a professor of mathematics at Padua, in the Republic of Venice, teaching students, selling instruments and studying motion. Then, in 1609, he heard that a Dutch spectacle maker had asked for a patent on a tube that made distant things look near. Galileo built his own, magnifying about twenty times, and turned it on the sky.

A gift to the Medici

His short book The Starry Messenger (1610) announced mountains on the Moon, swarms of unseen stars and four moons circling Jupiter. Galileo knew what the moons were worth. Cosimo II de' Medici, the young Grand Duke of Tuscany, had been his pupil, and patronage was how a scholar escaped the grind of teaching. Galileo named Jupiter's moons the Medicean Stars to win the patronage of the Medici. It worked. He became chief mathematician of the University of Pisa, with no duty to teach, and mathematician and philosopher to the Grand Duke. The second word mattered to him. Galileo insisted on the title of philosopher, claiming the right to say how nature really is, not merely to calculate.

Friends and rivals in Rome

In 1611 Galileo went to Rome to show off his telescope. Jesuit astronomers at the Collegio Romano confirmed his telescopic observations, and the Accademia dei Lincei, a small society of naturalists, made him a member. But he also made enemies. He quarrelled bitterly with the Jesuit astronomer Christoph Scheiner over who had first seen sunspots and what they were, and his sarcasm wounded many.

Scripture and nature

As talk of the moving Earth spread, some preachers attacked it as contrary to the Bible. Galileo answered in a long letter of 1615 to the Grand Duke's mother, Christina of Lorraine. Borrowing a saying he credited to Cardinal Baronius, Galileo argued that the Bible teaches how one goes to heaven, not how the heavens go. Cardinal Robert Bellarmine, the Church's leading theologian, answered a similar argument that same year. If a true demonstration of the Earth's motion were ever found, he wrote, the Church would have to read the relevant passages differently, but he doubted such a proof existed. Bellarmine held that only a real demonstration of the Earth's motion would justify reading Scripture differently.

In 1616 the Church acted. Moving the Earth was declared contrary to Scripture. Copernicus's book was suspended until corrected, not banned outright, while a book claiming the theory fitted the Bible was banned entirely. Bellarmine privately warned Galileo not to hold or defend the doctrine.

The Dialogue and the trial

In 1623 Galileo's admirer Maffeo Barberini became Pope Urban VIII, and Galileo felt free to write. His Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems (1632), written in lively Italian, staged a debate among three friends and was officially licensed. But it made the weaker side look foolish. The defender of Aristotle was named Simplicio, and in the final pages he voiced the pope's own favorite argument, that God could produce the same effects in ways beyond human understanding. And Galileo's main physical argument was flawed. Galileo's chief proof of the Earth's motion, drawn from the tides, was mistaken.

Urban felt betrayed. In 1633 the Roman Inquisition tried the elderly Galileo, found him "vehemently suspected of heresy", made him formally renounce the Earth's motion and banned the Dialogue. He spent his last years confined to his villa at Arcetri near Florence. There he finished Two New Sciences, his work on motion and the strength of materials, which was printed in 1638 at Leiden, in the Dutch Republic, beyond the Inquisition's reach.

Legends

The famous words supposedly muttered after the renunciation, "and yet it moves", have no early source. The line "and yet it moves" first appeared in print in 1757, more than a century after the trial. In the nineteenth century the American writers John William Draper and Andrew Dickson White made Galileo the star of a story of endless war between science and religion. Historians today see a messier picture: Church politics after the Council of Trent, a proud pope, a sharp-tongued scientist, and many clergy who were astronomers. In 1992 Pope John Paul II accepted a commission's finding that Galileo's judges had erred.

Worked example: Milton at Arcetri

In 1638 a young English poet, John Milton, travelled through Italy and visited the old astronomer. Six years later, arguing against the licensing of books by the English Parliament, he recalled the visit in Areopagitica (1644): "There it was that I found and visited the famous Galileo grown old, a prisoner to the Inquisition, for thinking in astronomy otherwise than the Franciscan and Dominican licensers thought."

Notice what Milton did with the story. He turned a specific trial into a symbol of what happens when officials decide which ideas may be printed, and he aimed it at his own Protestant Parliament, not only at Rome. The symbol leaves things out: the book had been licensed, the quarrel was partly personal, and Galileo's best argument was wrong. The trial really did silence a thinker and frighten others; in the Netherlands, the French philosopher René Descartes put away a book of his own when he heard the news. Yet a symbol is not the same as a history. Reading Milton well means seeing the real injustice he points to, and also the details his purpose led him to smooth over.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why did Galileo name Jupiter's moons the Medicean Stars?
2. Why did Galileo insist on the title of philosopher at the Tuscan court?
3. Who confirmed Galileo's telescopic observations in Rome in 1611?
4. What did Galileo argue in his 1615 letter to Christina of Lorraine?
5. What was Cardinal Bellarmine's position in 1615?
6. What did the Church do with Copernicus's book in 1616?
7. What was the main scientific weakness of Galileo's Dialogue?
8. When did the words "and yet it moves" first appear in print?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia