Skip to main content

Cloves grew on a handful of small islands in Maluku, and nutmeg and mace only on the tiny Banda Islands. For centuries these spices passed through many hands, Malay, Javanese, Gujarati, Arab and Venetian, before reaching European tables at enormous markups. Anthony Reid called the period from about 1450 to 1680 Southeast Asia's "age of commerce", when pepper and spices, Indian cloth and Chinese silk made port cities such as Melaka, Aceh, Ayutthaya and Makassar as large and rich as many cities in Europe. Europeans arrived in the middle of that boom, hoping to cut out the middlemen.

The Portuguese

The Portuguese reached India in 1498 and pressed east quickly. Portugal seized Melaka in 1511, under Afonso de Albuquerque, hoping to control the trade that passed through it. The plan backfired in part. Muslim merchants refused to deal with a Christian power that taxed and sometimes attacked them, so the conquest scattered Muslim trade to rival ports such as Aceh, Johor and Banten, which grew rich at Melaka's expense. The Portuguese held a fortress and some trade, but never the monopoly they wanted.

The Spanish in the Philippines

Spain came from the other direction, across the Pacific. Ferdinand Magellan's expedition reached the central Philippines in 1521, and Magellan was killed on the island of Mactan in a battle with the forces of the chief Lapulapu, who is honored today as a Filipino hero. Spain returned in force in 1565 under Miguel López de Legazpi and founded Manila in 1571.

Spanish rule was spread thin, and much of it was carried out by Catholic friars, who learned local languages, gathered scattered villages into towns around churches and often acted as local governors. Conversion went deep. Today the Philippines and Timor-Leste are the two mainly Catholic countries in Asia. Muslim sultanates in the southern islands resisted Spain for more than three centuries.

Manila depended on Chinese merchants and craftsmen, who soon outnumbered the Spanish many times over. Fear and debt made that relationship violent. In 1603 Spanish forces and their allies killed thousands of Chinese residents of Manila, and further massacres followed later in the century.

The Dutch company

The most determined newcomer was the Dutch East India Company, the VOC. The VOC set up its Asian headquarters at Batavia, on the site of Jakarta, in 1619. Unlike earlier traders, the VOC aimed at a monopoly on cloves, nutmeg and mace, and it used force to get it. It conquered the Banda Islands in 1621 with terrible loss of life, and in Maluku the VOC sent fleets to cut down clove trees outside the islands it controlled, so that the spice could only be grown where it could be policed. It took Melaka from Portugal in 1641 and broke the power of Makassar, a free-trading rival, in the 1660s.

Batavia, too, relied on Chinese settlers. In 1740 a massacre in Batavia killed about 10,000 Chinese residents, after Dutch officials feared a revolt. In both Manila and Batavia, a useful minority without political power proved terribly exposed when rulers grew anxious.

Crisis or consolidation?

What did all this mean for the region? Reid argued that the seventeenth century brought a crisis: as the VOC choked the spice trade and climate turned harsher, island kingdoms turned away from the sea, and their cities shrank. The historian Victor Lieberman offered a different picture for the mainland. Lieberman argued that between about 1350 and 1830 three large mainland states, Burma, Siam and Vietnam, absorbed their smaller neighbors, much as France, Russia and Japan consolidated at the same time. On his view, Europeans were one force among many before 1800, and mainland history followed its own strong rhythms. Both pictures can be partly true: Europeans hit the spice islands hard and early, while the mainland felt them much later.

Worked example: following a clove

Follow a sack of cloves around 1680. It grows on Ambon, one of the few islands where the VOC still allows clove trees. The grower must deliver it to the company at a fixed price, set low, and selling elsewhere is a crime. Company ships carry it to Batavia, then around Africa to Amsterdam, where it sells for many times what the grower received.

Now count who gains and who loses. The VOC's shareholders gain steady profits. Dutch consumers pay high prices but get supply. The grower on Ambon loses the right to choose a buyer, and on islands where trees were cut down, families lose a whole livelihood. Asian traders who once carried cloves lose their business, and some turn to smuggling, which the company treats as piracy.

The exercise shows why monopoly could not be built by trade alone. To keep prices high, the company had to control where plants grew and who could sail, which meant ruling people. Commerce slid into empire well before European states claimed most of the region in the nineteenth century.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What happened to Muslim trade after Portugal seized Melaka?
2. Who led the forces that killed Magellan at Mactan in 1521?
3. Which two Asian countries are mainly Catholic today?
4. Who carried out much of Spain's day-to-day rule in the Philippines?
5. Where did the VOC set up its Asian headquarters in 1619?
6. Why did the VOC cut down clove trees on some islands?
7. What happened in Batavia in 1740?
8. What did Victor Lieberman argue about the mainland from 1350 to 1830?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia