Isfahan was a city of minds as well as monuments. Its colleges drew students from across the Shi'i world, and in the early seventeenth century a circle of thinkers there produced some of the most ambitious philosophy written anywhere in the Islamic world in that age. The same city later saw scholars push for strict religious rule and harsher treatment of minorities. Both stories belong to Safavid Iran.
The School of Isfahan
Historians use the phrase "School of Isfahan" for a group of philosophers and theologians who blended reason, mysticism and Shi'i faith. Among them were Mir Damad, who died in 1631, and Shaykh Baha'i, who died around 1621, a scholar from a Jabal Amil family famed for mathematics, astronomy and poetry as well as law. The most celebrated philosopher of the School of Isfahan was Mulla Sadra, Sadr al-Din Shirazi, who died around 1635 to 1640; the sources disagree on the year.
Mulla Sadra called his system "transcendent wisdom." It drew on Avicenna's philosophy, on the philosophy of illumination of the twelfth century thinker Suhrawardi, on Sufi mystical insight and on Shi'i theology. Two ideas stand out. By the primacy of existence, Mulla Sadra meant that the act of existing is what is most real; what a thing is, its essence, is more like an outline that the mind draws around a particular way of existing. And by substantial motion he meant that things change in their very substance, not only in their surface qualities, so that the whole world is constantly being renewed. Some clerics attacked him as a heretic, and he spent years in retreat in a village near Qom before returning to teach in Shiraz.
Reports or reasoning?
Among jurists a sharp debate opened. Akhbaris held that believers should rely on the reports of the Prophet and imams, the recorded sayings and deeds handed down by trusted chains of narrators, rather than on the reasoning of jurists. Muhammad Amin Astarabadi, who died in the 1620s, revived this view. Their opponents, the Usulis, held that trained jurists could use reason and legal principles to derive rulings on new questions. The Usuli side eventually won, but only after the Safavid era, and its victory laid the ground for the authority of senior jurists in modern Iran.
Majlisi and the turn to strictness
In the later seventeenth century the most powerful religious figure was Muhammad Baqir Majlisi, who died in 1699. Majlisi compiled the Bihar al-Anwar, a vast body of Shi'i traditions running to many volumes, and he wrote widely in Persian so that ordinary believers could read about faith and practice. As chief cleric of Isfahan from 1687, he attacked Sufis and philosophers as dangerous to true belief and pressed for strict enforcement of religious law.
Living as a minority
Safavid Iran contained Armenian and Georgian Christians, Jews, Zoroastrians, Sunni Muslims and Indian Hindu merchants. Their treatment changed with rulers, politics and the influence of particular clerics. Some Shi'i jurists taught that non-Muslims were ritually impure, and at times this led to rules keeping them from touching food in markets or using public baths. Under Abbas II, around 1656 to 1661, Jews in Isfahan and other cities were pressed to convert to Islam, an episode recorded in chronicles written in Judeo-Persian, Persian in Hebrew letters. Many later returned openly to Judaism when the pressure eased. Zoroastrians and Sunnis also faced periods of pressure, especially late in the dynasty. Indian merchants in Isfahan, many of them moneylenders, were tolerated because trade depended on their credit, though some clerics viewed them with suspicion.
Women and power
Women rarely appear in the chronicles, but royal women could wield real power. Tahmasp's daughter Pari Khan Khanum helped decide the succession after his death in 1576, and for a time she was among the most powerful people at court, until she was killed in 1578. Later, as princes were kept within the harem, mothers of heirs and the eunuchs who served them became important players in palace politics. European travelers, who could not enter the harem, often wrote about it with more imagination than knowledge.
Worked example: two faces of one city
Put Mulla Sadra and Majlisi side by side. Both lived in Safavid Iran, both were devout Twelver Shi'is, both studied in the same scholarly world, and Majlisi's own father had been a student of philosophers. Yet they pulled in opposite directions. Mulla Sadra wove together Greek philosophy, mysticism and revelation, trusting that reason and spiritual insight could reach the same truths as scripture. Majlisi gathered and organized the traditions of the imams and warned that speculation led believers astray. Each saw himself as defending Shi'ism. The lesson is not that one was the true voice of the faith and the other a deviation. It is that religious traditions contain arguments, and which side gains influence depends partly on politics, patronage and fear. When someone claims a tradition has always taught one thing, a history like this one invites the question: which of its voices are being left out?
